News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by TeeMassive on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @09:20AM (#36785841)
Just because medicine is socialized doesn't mean it overrides rights like habeas corpus and free and informed consent.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by nicoburns on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @09:44AM (#36786220)
No, but an infectious disease is also limiting on people's freedoms, so it's equally not obvious that those rights override the rights of people to be protected from infectious diseases.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by peyton on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:21AM (#36786827)
So at least in the US the founding political ideology is based on natural rights and social contract theory. Your conception is closer to patriarchal rights, which is in conflict (at least here in the US).
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by magicalist on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:42AM (#36787212)
You're talking about professed ideology (of some), though, which can always be free to ignore reality.

Quarantines and stringent public health measures have been part of the functioning of the US in practice since founding (and before).

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by TeeMassive on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:25AM (#36786899)
People are free to stay inside if they're afraid of getting sick. Rights can only be overridden if and only if there are no other choices, which is not the case here. Me getting to an hospital doesn't limit someone else's freedom.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by nicoburns on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:57AM (#36787509)
> People are free to stay inside if they're afraid of getting sick

By that logic, people are free to stay inside if I'm standing outside their door with a gun and they don't want to be shot. Yes, they're free to stay inside, but they're not free to go outside.

I think it's reasonable to believe that the rights of free movement override the rights to be protected from diseases in this case, but I don't think you can argue that via a general principle of rights. I think you have to argue that based on the specific consequences, and on your personal values.

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by BHSPitMonkey on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @12:15PM (#36788825)
Thousands of people going to the hospital at the same time due to a preventable phenomenon certainly limits the freedom of lots of people to continue living when those hospitals are overrun and unable to provide care. We had already tried a few months of the "let everyone decide individually and hope for the best" approach and the problem kept worsening superlinearly.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by black6 on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:10AM (#36786636)
What right to be protected from infectious diseases? If it exists then it's been violated my entire life.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by hinkley on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:40AM (#36787171)
We have started charging people with assault for attempting to infect others.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by nicoburns on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:15AM (#36786732)
Well, it's not an absolute right (and it's obviously constrained by the limits of what it is even in our power to control). But then neither is the right not to be detained, or really any other right. All rights run into limits when they come into conflict with other rights.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by TeeMassive on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:36AM (#36787097)
But people were also free and supported to stay inside if they were afraid of getting infected. This logic doesn't hold up here.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by s1artibartfast on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:58AM (#36787534)
I think it was a witness test of people's moral philosophy. Rights are fundamentally philosophical position, not a law of physics.

Those that favor preserving negative rights over positive rights generally objected to the lockdown.

In general, people who favor negative rights do so because they don't come into conflict with each other. Positive rights come into conflict with other positive rights and negative rights, and require trade-offs

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by nicoburns on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @12:01PM (#36788583)
I agree. My personal perspective is that I fundamentally don't agree that negative rights don't conflict with each other, or that there is a meaningful difference between positive and negative rights (which is of course a philosophical position that not everybody will agree with).
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by s1artibartfast on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:33PM (#36790140)
Negative rights not conflicting with each other is the main and perhaps only factor that distinguishes them from positive rights, so if you don't think that is true, of course you won't find a difference.

When it comes to practical implementation, the tools used to maintain negative rights are the same as the tools used to maintain positive rights, so they appear very similar.

If you're familiar with the concept, you probably already know that negative rights prohibit other people from actions, while positive rights require other people to take actions.

I'm curious why you think this distinction is not valid.

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by nicoburns on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @02:19PM (#36790874)
Consider two possible rights:

(1) The right to complete freedom of movement.

(2) The right to private personal space free of other people

On the face of things, neither of these require anybody to take actions. Nevertheless, one cannot fully exercise (1) without violating (2) and vice versa.

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by s1artibartfast on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @04:13PM (#36792521)
Interesting I think that is a great example of why and how the concept of personal property (bodily or material) is necessary to make negative rights consistent.

Also, the first right seems more like a positive right guaranteeing an entitlement to do or have access to something.

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by Pet_Ant on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @11:06AM (#36787665)
Fundamentally, morally speaking those those aren't facts but opinions. Legally, I think it differs from country to country. Individual rights versus the needs of the state is something that we have really changed perspective on in the last hundred years.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by nradov on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @11:33AM (#36788096)
There is no right to protection from infectious disease. It appears nowhere in the US Constitution. There was never any valid moral or legal justification for restricting the 1st Amendment right of freedom of assembly during the pandemic.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by nicoburns on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @12:03PM (#36788610)
I would note that while the US Constitution is a valid authority with regard to legal justification (in the US!), it is very much not with regard to moral justification.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by stewarts on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @12:54PM (#36789513)
Well, that is not quite true at the State level. There are a number of States who have implemented laws that punish transmission of HIV/STDs knowingly. I'll concede there doesn't exist anything at the Federal level that I am aware of.

https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/policies/law/states/exposure.html

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by whoisthemachine on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @09:46AM (#36786237)
Are rights like habeas corpus and free and informed consent overridden in a time of war?
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by Clubber on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:43AM (#36787239)
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by felixgallo on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @09:47AM (#36786261)
that is just total word salad. Please look up what habeas corpus means. It's right there in wikipedia or any other reference work of your choice. Informed consent is not a right. Those are enumerated also in reference works. Medicine in the united states is essentially the opposite of socialized. Good lord.
Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by TeeMassive on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:34AM (#36787057)
>that is just total word salad

Simply saying "you're wrong" is not an argument.

> Please look up what habeas corpus means.

You cannot detain people without charges or probable cause.

> Informed consent is not a right. Those are enumerated also in reference works.

Okay then, here's a reference work:

"Informed consent is both an ethical and legal obligation of medical practitioners in the US" according to the NIH: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK430827/

> Medicine in the united states is essentially the opposite of socialized.

And yet it was public health officials who imposed lock-downs. There is clearly socialized medicine in the US.

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by felixgallo on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @11:47AM (#36788338)
> Simply saying "you're wrong" is not an argument.

Right, which is why I followed up with a categorical and complete description of the problems with your nonsensical word salad.

>> Please look up what habeas corpus means. > You cannot detain people without charges or probable cause.

No, you're thinking of the Fourth Amendment. Habeas corpus is the mechanism by which a person can report a suspected unlawful detention or imprisonment to a court, which can then order that the person be brought forward in person, in order to ascertain whether or not the particular imprisoning entity has the authority to do so. Obviously this has nothing at all to do with vaccines except in the fever swamps.

>> Informed consent is not a right. Those are enumerated also in reference works.

> Okay then, here's a reference work:

> "Informed consent is both an ethical and legal obligation of medical practitioners in the US" according to the NIH: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK430827/

Not therefore a right, got it.

> > Medicine in the united states is essentially the opposite of socialized.

> And yet it was public health officials who imposed lock-downs. There is clearly socialized medicine in the US.

What you're referring to as 'socialized' here is the government, which we as citizens and resident aliens agree to recognize in order to increase and defend the common good. For example, we agree to being policed, we agree to being taxed, we agree to being bound by laws, and we agree in particular in this case to working together to try to stop the collapse of healthcare systems, even if that is inimical to the political chances of the president at the time.

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by TeeMassive on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:36PM (#36806388)
> Right, which is why I followed up with a categorical and complete description of the problems with your nonsensical word salad.

Just because you disagree doesn't mean you have to be provocative and impolite. It's also against HN's rules BTW.

> Habeas corpus is the mechanism by which a person can report a suspected unlawful detention or imprisonment to a court,

You're making a distinction without making a difference. People were detained without charges or probable cause and were not allowed legal remedy.

> Obviously this has nothing at all to do with vaccines except in the fever swamps.

I was talking about lockdowns...

> Not therefore a right, got it.

Just repeating a statement won't make it true, it just makes you arrogant.

Informed consent directly derives from the right to bodily autonomy. It is such a basic right that if its blatant violation can be prosecuted regardless of jurisdiction. It is also protected by the 4h Amendment.

> What you're referring to as 'socialized' here is the government, which we as citizens and resident aliens agree to recognize in order to increase and defend the common good. For example, we agree to being policed, we agree to being taxed, we agree to being bound by laws, and we agree in particular in this case to working together to try to stop the collapse of healthcare systems, even if that is inimical to the political chances of the president at the time.

Actually "we" didn't "agree", what ever that means. The "common good" was never the foundation of the US, it was a Republic (thus power by and for the people) with limitations to protect individual liberties to limit the tyranny of the majority (the funding fathers were actually very critical of Athenian democracy BTW).

Taxes and police have their legitimacy through elected officials. But lockdowns and forced vaccination were put into place through edicts, the vast majority of whom were struck down by the Supreme Court, and thus never had the consent of the people nor respected individual rights.

Re:In the Asian Flu of 1957-58, they rejected lockdowns (2021) by WrongAssumption on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @11:20AM (#36787912)
Even those pro lockdown could literally only justify it with an unconstitutional suspension of Habeas Corpus.

https://verdict.justia.com/2020/03/15/lock-us-down-suspend-h...

Department of Justice used the precedence of state government lockdowns to gain the power to detain suspects indefinately.

https://www.politico.com/news/2020/03/21/doj-coronavirus-eme...

You need to look up what it means.