Re:Bell Labs Holmdel Complex
by etrautmann on Sunday July 16, 2023 @03:26PM
(#36750552)
How do you figure? The model now has been tech companies for the last 15 years.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I can't speak for the previous commenter but it does seem there is a different character to the research work happening at FAANG-scale companies (which is still generally in service of their corporate strategy) vs the work that happened at Bell Labs back in the day (which was more abstract and less directly-commercializable). Bell Labs was more of a large team of brilliant researchers with ample resources to support their work, and it just had to be useful to somebody rather than be part of a product/service that could be sold directly.
Re:Bell Labs Holmdel Complex
by shortrounddev2 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @04:27PM
(#36751101)
You're right. The invention of the transistor was a multi-decade effort by scientists working outside of regular hours, essentially inventing the field of solid state physics. It's hard to imagine such a technology coming out of a publicly traded company like Google or Apple, whose year-to-year or even quarter-to-quarter behavior is as sensitive to changes in interest rates and short term market conditions as a balloon in the wind.
Re:Bell Labs Holmdel Complex
by throwaway7868 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @10:30PM
(#36753416)
> which was more abstract and less directly-commercializable
Related acecdote: Charles Townes described that after the invention of the maser, he had to make a case for Bell Labs to patent it, against some resistance. As he described it, the eventual winning phrase was: "Well, it could be used for telecomunication".
Brian Kernighan's book, "Unix: A History and a Memoir" paints a compelling picture of just how open-ended research at Bell Labs can be.
FAANG do a lot of research, but the budgeting for those efforts is much more tightly controlled and connected to corporate strategy.