> which add cost
We aren't interested in free. You get what you pay for.
I would say it's a somewhat weak correlation that breaks down completely if you consider a wider range of architectures. Back when Google was a startup "you get what you pay for" is what people running Oracle on Solaris would tell you.
And there was a sense in which it was true. There was no more reliable and feature rich way of scaling up. But starting something like Google on top of this egregiously expensive platform would have been completely uneconomical. It just wouldn't have happened.
And I think it's the same thing today. There are good reasons for using those egregiously expensive offerings from the largest incumbants but if you are starting something where servers are a significant cost factor then you are well advised to look at other options that are orders of magnitude cheaper, even accounting for labour.
Which one? We are using this stack in fintech, and are subject to PCI-DSS, SOX, AML, SOC2, etc. Many of our customers (small US banks & credit unions) are very interested in this kind of cookie-cutter, cloud-native stack in 2023.
> We can't even take pictures in the office, there's an absolute 0% chance we're trusting a cloud provider with anything.
Sounds like you work for an F100. Our IT budget is 5 figures and we are doing business with clients who have 6 figure IT budgets at the high end. Forcing an on-prem architecture would make our solution less secure in most situations, especially for those customers who do not have the confidence to run a complex SAAS solution on their premises. Many of our customers actively understand this reality and are very open to the idea of offloading complexity to the cloud.
Yeah. I spent a couple of years at a billion-$ company in the telco industry which was subject to all sorts of US federal and foreign regulations (because they operated in 20+ countries.) They ran almost everything onprem, but seeing how that was managed, cloud would have 1000% more secure for them. At one point, the entire senior staff of the IT department was fired because of a security breach that was pretty clearly due to their poor decisions.
Companies do exist where their onprem operations do seem very secure, but you need really big budgets and good management to do that properly. Most places are not like that, even in the highly regulated spaces.
I suppose in the end they achieve a kind of security with this behavior, but it would be a lot better to avoid such incidents in the first place - which would be perfectly possible, with good decision-making.
I literally rolled my eyes reading that. How do you think we did before cloud computing?
I am currently in charge of multiple teams scaling and deploying innovative applications for a large industrial company. We are using Azure for everything. Our cloud costs are insane for our number of users. I used to manage applications with ten times more user for one hundredth of the cost and less complexity. It’s billed to another part of the company which is responsible for this dubious choice (I really hope someone is getting nice business trips paid by MS so it’s not a complete waste) so I don’t care but how people can blindly put faith in the cloud is beside me.
For all of Microsoft's faults, you can get a person on the phone when you pay money.
There is a reason Microsoft kicks Google's ass all over the room in the enterprise space.
Performance is fantastic (using isolated app service plans in Azure), and I am completely over the ideological principals against per-request billing. Absolutely, you can do it cheaper if you own the literal real estate the servers are running inside of. Paying for flat colo fees makes per-request costs look ludicrous on the surface. But, achieving all of the other attributes of simple HTTP triggered functions in a DIY context is very challenging without also spinning up a billion dollar corporation and hiring 1k more people. Compliance, audits, etc are where it gets real super fast.
The "what about lock-in?" argument doesn't work for me anymore. HTTP triggers are a pretty natural interface to code against: "I've got a HTTP request for you to review, give me some HTTP response please". The only stuff that is vendor-specific are the actual trigger method signatures and specific contexts beyond HTTP, such as OIDC or SAML claims. You'd really have to go out of your way to design an HTTP trigger web app/API solution that is impossible to refactor for another vendor within a week or so.
If your business is a personal blog, then yeah I get it. It's more fun to buy a VM in Hetzner and get all artisanal about it. Also, if you are operating in a totally unregulated industry, perhaps you can make some stronger arguments against completely outsourcing the servers in favor of splitting hairs on margin vs complexity.