Profits from speculation is not the same as profits from business activities. People purchase everything from bar codes (yes, 11 digit bar codes are a commodity with limited supply), to trailers, to collectible video games, to oil and minerals, precious metals, art, antiques, etc etc all on speculation that they'll be worth more in the future.
But if you don't have a formal contractual relationship with Rolex SA, then it's quite simply not an investment contract.
That is not at all true. Rolexes will continue to accrue value even (especially?) if the company goes out of business.
Indeed, the brand may retain value for some time even if the company goes out of business, perhaps even for a very long time. Nevertheless, that doesn't negate the fact that ongoing marketing efforts can amplify the brand's value and momentum, and the brand's inertia will be even stronger should the company cease to exist.
Another way to look at this is to put yourself in the shoes of a prospective buyer in 1923. Wouldn't you say in that situation you rely on the company's continuing marketing efforts to further the value of the brand? At what point in the last 100 years do you stop relying on the company's efforts?
Also, Rolex can easily destroy brand value with ill-considered promotional campaigns, so you rely on the company to not mess it up.
The salient point is many things may be purchased for "speculative profit you hope to make [...] reliant on the business", but that by itself doesn't make them securities according to the law, so it's just not the right test to use.
The docket[1] has the ruling[2], but there's very little additional detail provided beyond the focus on "blind transactions" to invalidate one of the Howey prongs[3].
As an aside, thank goodness for Court Listener and the RECAP/PACER archive!
[1] https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/19857399/securities-and...
[2] https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/19857399/874/securities...
[3] https://www.sec.gov/corpfin/framework-investment-contract-an...
William Hinman of the SEC said much the same thing in 2018: https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/speech-hinman-061418
> A security is a contract, not just anything that people trade around in a speculative way.
The scary thing IMO is that I think if you had enough big money trading bottlecaps or baseball cards, you'd quickly find them being considered a security.
But words have to mean something. Things can't just be a "security" because they make the government feel insecure.
> Those sales were "blind bid/ask transactions," she said, where the buyers "could not have known if their payments of money went to Ripple, or any other seller of XRP."
I bet this gets overturned on appeal. It makes no sense to me. Seems like a huge loophole if it stands. Maybe it's explained better in the actual ruling, anyone have a link? Of course you can count on Reuters to never link to important information.