News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by kkielhofner on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:56PM (#36712361)
I'd like to say politics could be avoided on this but not knowing anything about the science, historical stats, etc I've always had a simple nagging question on this issue that hopefully someone can help me understand. Elementary school science classes teach basic cause and effect.

My question is: How is it possible the planet can be billions of years old, then all of a sudden we discover fossil fuels in the past few hundreds years and start extracting and burning them at incredible rates, releasing them into the atmosphere.

Isn't it safe to assume there would be a basic cause-effect relationship here with /some/ kind of consequence? It just strikes me as a "no free lunch" scenario - I don't fundamentally understand how you could all of a sudden start burning all of this stuff and argue against there being negative effects for the overall atmosphere, ecosystem, etc.

Can someone help me understand how/why this wouldn't be the case?

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:57PM (#36713392)
No one can because it's clearly not true.

The only people arguing it isn't true are the various think tanks, foundations, coalitions, online PR bots, and the rest funded by the fossil fuel industry - working to persuade those who don't understand the issue, but are sure their opinion is very important.

Atmospheric CO2 science has been researched since the 19th century.

In the 70s Exxon/Mobil had its own climate scientists making shockingly accurate predictions of what would happen.

The IPCC climate change models - produced from 1990 onwards - have usually been conservative.

That is the objective reality. Everything else is spin, FUD, and noise.

https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2023/01/harvard-led-a...

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by majesticglue on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:12PM (#36713635)
those think tanks really did a number. the climate denialists, have made moving goal of going from denial to climate change is not man made.

The amount of americans who can't stand that fact that they were wrong on the matter is incredible.

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by zackees on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:33PM (#36713966)
The IPCC has not been conservative and it has not been accurate. They were caught engaging in “hiding the decline” in emails that were released to the public. Additionally almost all the weather stations for measure climate change are located on airport tarmacs:

https://twitter.com/perpetualmaniac/status/16299736771011584...

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by ben_w on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:53PM (#36714261)
Why are weather stations even still a meme in these discussions?

I used satellite surface temperature data nearly 20 years ago, it wasn't novel even then.

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by revelio on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:39PM (#36726381)
Because governments announce new "records" based on single thermometers that are located on the tarmac of airports, at the moment that jet fighters are landing.
Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by ben_w on Friday July 14, 2023 @01:05PM (#36726712)
Guess which bit of the planet the aforementioned satellite temperature data I used was? Not many airports in the oceans. Satellites covered everything, of course, but I was working with marine biologists at the time.

Now, do you want to try again, this time with an argument that isn't so trivial to dismiss with the stuff I did 20 years ago in the middle of my degree?

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by revelio on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:18PM (#36727867)
But we're not talking about what you, random HN poster, did twenty years ago. You asked, "Why are weather stations even still a meme in these discussions?" and the answer is "because governments keep announcing records based on them". Why would they not be a "meme" in this discussion, given that fact? If governments didn't use data from weather stations anymore for climatological purposes, indeed, discussion of them would eventually disappear. They will never do that because satellite data only goes back to the early 1970s and they want to talk about trends longer than that, therefore, weather stations will remain a meme.

So there's nothing to try again here. Your question was answered correctly the first time.

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by ben_w on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:01PM (#36729161)
> Why would they not be a "meme" in this discussion, given that fact?

"Given" assumes a falsehood to be true.

> Because governments announce new "records" based on single thermometers that are located on the tarmac of airports, at the moment that jet fighters are landing.

Give a link to one occasion where all of those things happened together.

Not each bit separate, all at the same time.

One government that's genuinely so incompetent that they literally announce something from one number literally during a landing.

And not just an intern on Twitter, an official announcement.

You don't get to mix different events. Nothing pre-satellite is:

> new "records"

Given the meaning of the word "new". Also:

> located on the tarmac of airports, at the moment that jet fighters are landing.

is fundamentally incompatible with

> They will never do that because satellite data only goes back to the early 1970s and they want to talk about trends longer than that

Given the actual trends people are interested in go back well before jet fighters, and indeed aircraft.

What we actually do is the exact opposite causation: observe what else correlates with satellite data so we can model the past. More satellite data makes such models stronger — and of course they also do publish the error bars, even if you didn't bother to look for them.

(The governments of the world also hate that scientists keep giving them these models, because it gives the politicians yet another problem to take the blame for no matter what; people keep demanding solutions that cost nothing and involve no changes to lifestyles, employment, products or services, which somehow also actually make a difference).

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by nerdchum on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:55PM (#36715094)
Everyone is so sensational about climate change but never looks at Earth's history.

Were at the tail end of an ice age.

For most of Earth's history, there were no polar ice caps.

For 400 out of 500 million years the earth was warmer than it is now.

https://www.climate.gov/news-features/climate-qa/whats-hotte...

https://www.climate.gov/sites/default/files/styles/full_widt...

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by ShellfishMeme on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:46PM (#36716488)
The earth is 4.5 billion years old so I don't understand what you mean with "400 out of 500 million years".

Also for a lot of that time earth was a hellishly hot place with little life.

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by nerdchum on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:25AM (#36719463)
The past 500 million years have been rich with life.
Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by austinjp on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:04AM (#36720762)
That's disingenuous misdirection. The current change is a threat to humanity of our own making.
Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by nerdchum on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:45AM (#36721135)
> threat to humanity of our own making.

How? Do you have concrete examples or just fear based conjecture?

Re:Last week was the hottest ever recorded – here’s why we k... by nojvek on Friday July 14, 2023 @09:17AM (#36723562)
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/9js5291m

This book goes into good detail in human population growth, growth in energy use, and growth in use of coal, oil and other energy sources.

Highly recommended. Lots of stats, charts and math.

It’s not about climate change, the book is about understanding human growth and energy (across its various forms) and their implications.