News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by wombatpm on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:54AM (#36695470)
There is a strong argument to be made that Truman should have been tried for war crimes for dropping the second bomb. You can justify the first bomb as shortening the war, bringing Japan to surrender. The second bomb was about getting an unconditional surrender with terms dictated by the USA.
Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by phone8675309 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:27AM (#36695990)
Especially with how little change the unconditional surrender had on Japanese life in the long run. Yes, the emperor came out and told the people he was not divine and has taken on a ceremonial role since then but the emperor was not forced to resign, members of the imperial family were immune from prosecution for war crimes (so the person at the top responsible for the atrocities in Nanking was never held to account for them), several politicians who were class A war criminals rose to the top of the Japanese political leadership after the war, and Japan has never officially apologized for their atrocities.
Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by kragen on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:55PM (#36697642)
unconditional surrender meant that all of this was at the pleasure of the occupiers, who were currently operating concentration camps for japanese-americans; other possibilities included turning japan into a second nanjing or pine ridge, where to this day occasional rapes by whites continue with impunity

https://www.niwrc.org/restoration-magazine/june-2017/today-i...

things have in fact worked out fairly well for japan, much better than it worked out for the people of jiangsu, but you can hardly blame the japanese leadership for expecting otherwise

Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by phone8675309 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:38PM (#36699643)
Calling the US internment camps "concentration camps" is both disingenuous and a neo-Nazi talking point.

The internment camps were a disgrace, were wrong, and the US government was right to issue both an apology and compensation to people who were interred there.

The government of Japan has never done the same to Nanking. I don't believe they ever will.

> where to this day occasional rapes by whites continue with impunity

This is yet another disingenuous point - rapes by soldiers in Japan occur, they're bad, and the military both investigates and prosecutes those who take part, unlike Japan and Nanking.

Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by kragen on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:17PM (#36701809)
you are the sort of person who compares people who disagree with them to neo-nazis; that is not the sort of person who is in a position to question my integrity in any way, much less viciously attack it as you have

it is not controversial that the japanese-american internment camps were concentration camps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentration_camp

(you can probably find neo-nazis saying the sky is blue as well)

i didn't mention the actually occurring rapes by soldiers in japan, which i agree in the actual world we live in are appropriately investigated and prosecuted; as demonstrated by my link, i was talking about rapes by whites in pine ridge and other so-called indian reservations, which to a large extent are neither investigated nor prosecuted

Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by phone8675309 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:41PM (#36703201)
> you are the sort of person who compares people who disagree with them to neo-nazis

I'm really not - calling the internment camps "concentration camps" is literally a neo-Nazi talking point and meant specifically to draw moral equivalence between the Japanese interment camps and the death camps in Germany during World War 2. I'm sorry if that offends your delicate sensibilities, but it's true. Look over my comments on this account if you don't believe me here - I have not and do not call people neo-Nazis for disagreeing with me (and I'm not calling you a neo-Nazi, I'm saying that it's a neo-Nazi talking point).

I think there's no other fruitful discourse we can have here.

Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by FatalLogic on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:04PM (#36696679)
The Nagasaki bomb may not have been necessary. As well a simple attack on Japan, the Nagasaki atomic bombing was also a cold-blooded test of the implosion bomb technology, and a demonstration for the rest of the world, particularly for the Soviet Union.

But between 100,000 to 250,000 died, Japanese and American, in the battle of Okinawa in 1945, the 3 month US invasion of Okinawa, before the atomic bombs were used. That was the first and only US attempt to invade the main Japanese islands, and it was a tragic and unnecessary loss of life.

About 80,000 died in the atomic bombing of Nagasaki.

But Japan should have surrendered long before any of the atom bombs fell. They had obviously lost. If Japan's leadership could not take that obvious step, then there was no easy solution.

Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by philwelch on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:54PM (#36697608)
> There is a strong argument to be made that Truman should have been tried for war crimes for dropping the second bomb.

By who?

Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by ndsipa_pomu on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:14PM (#36698000)
Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by philwelch on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:55PM (#36702221)
I'm asking who would have tried Truman.
Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by wombatpm on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:16PM (#36749317)
Crimes against humanity at the Hauge. Same place we tried Nazis
Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by philwelch on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:56PM (#36803351)
You've answered the questions of "where" and "on what charges", but not the question of who would be prosecuting.
Re:Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of vie... by naasking on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:06PM (#36697861)
From my hazy recollection, Japanese leadership didn't believe the US had been responsible for Nagasaki. The second bomb settled that matter. All of these could be true though, they aren't mutually exclusive.