What if you could self host on all your devices and they were all seamlessly connected to each other like a single distributed OS without any kind of server in the middle? Then when your data is abused you have nobody to blame but yourself and all your data is always available so long as your devices are connected. No ads, no weaponized personal data, no spam, no extra expenses. Its just your hardware, your internet connection, and just the right software solution.
The reason why networks used to be symmetric is because ISPs believed users downloaded far more frequently than they uploaded and therefore a greater percentage of the pipe was dedicated to download channels. That increases QOS on bandwidth constrained pipes but comes at a traffic management cost. Now IPS figure if the network is already fast and the user wants it to be even faster then they can just pay for a larger pipe and everybody's happy.
Except the ones you send to people using Google...
Right now I am using a set or solutions:
* email * [2]
* files * using NextCloud
* blog * using Hugo
* news * using my own RSS reader
* pihole * to filter things
What I consider to use in the future
* pictures * using photoprism
* citadel * I found some sort of suites like citadel. Not sure if that works, if it is good, or if it fits my needs at all [3]. At the first glance seems like a fun project.
Links:
[1] https://specbranch.com/posts/one-big-server/
[2] https://github.com/LukeSmithxyz/emailwiz
All in all it is time consuming to setup up, and update regularly.
unattended-upgrade does the security upgrades and I occasionally upgrade the rss reader (as it is not packaged)
mail was pretty much fire-and-forget postfix+dovecot on file config, no DB for list of accounts + some catchalls.
If I had to pay say $5 for each of those services vs pay myself to manage that it would more less come out the same, minus ability to fix any little annoyances I had directly vs hoping cloud provider gives an option for it.
I do use syncthing for file sync so no annoying dealings with PHP apps
They can't or won't.
...and the ones that do are an insignificant drop in the bucket in terms of numbers. Unless "self-hosting" one's digital infrastructure can become easy and off-the-shelf for non-tech folks (or even tech folks that value their time and effort), it just not going to happen.
I think you might have meant distributed and decentralized systems in general. But the answer has nothing to do with technology. We have all the decentralized technology we need (long before blockchain by the way), even e-mail is somewhat decentralized (well, at least distributed), yet it doesn't solve the problem by itself.
Even if you’re scared of Linux and writing exim.conf, there are more or less turnkey docker containers out there and whatnot too. I can’t recommend one because I think docker is pointless for a single host running a few applications.
However, you do need proof that you 'own' the IP address by means of a reverse IP address. ISPs generally don't allow their customers to set a reverse-DNS record for the IP address, because you do not own the IP. Since most spam originates from botnets from consumer IP addresses, adding the reverse-DNS requirement resulted in a huge reduction in spam.
The email service providers didn't ruin email, spammers did.
That plus the fact that the receiver on almost all my emails would be storing them on one of the few big providers and it just never felt worth it.
I have very, very rare deliverability problems, maybe once every two years AT&T decides to block mails from my domain but I resolve it through their easy process.
I have the advantage of having done this for 15 or so years so my IP has some good reputation, but I don’t think IP reputation is really that huge or necessary. The first rule of self hosting Email is “never spam—not even once.” Follow that and you’re in good shape.
The reason I do it is that E-mail is often the only identity on other services I use (it’s often the only way to reset your passwords), and I feel it is too risky to be dependent on a megacorp for my identity, a megacorp who may decide out of the blue to suspend my account for no reason.
I’m dependent on my VPS provider, but I have backups and can take my Debian config with me to a different one. Or bare metal if I have to.
I’m dependent on my DNS registrar and haven’t figured out a good way to mitigate that risk.
Besides that, that’s it.
If you're worried about getting the same treatment as KiwiFarms...maybe don't spread hate or dox and stalk people??
Governments make the same arguments. If you want encryption you are either a terrorist, or extremist. Everybody should be able to self host, and nobody should be looked down upon for selfhosting.
It is not a bad thing that somebody wants not to rely on any centralized government or corporate system, or want their data to be private.
Centralized bodies are prone to abuse power. We should work towards decentralized systems, and towards self hosting.
If the ability to self-host came, without exception, at the cost of being able to prevent groups like KiwiFarms from bullying, harassing and abusing people, then it would not be worth it.
Fortunately, that's not the case! We can have a middle ground, where people who treat each other with respect and dignity can self-host without fear, and people who abuse the system to actively harm others can be taken offline.
This is a feature, not a bug.
1. Self-hosted by me
2. Stored by a for-profit company I am paying
3. Stored by a megacorp
4. Stored by a non-profit
--
2 and 3 have an economic incentive not to lose my data, and have money to pay for decent engineers. 4 is basically having my data stored on a crappy Core2 Duo server under a staircase, managed by a teenager
> 4 is basically having my data stored on a crappy Core2 Duo server under a staircase, managed by a teenager
... isn't 1 the same then ? Aside from teenager part
A last one : I was ask to pry open the personal windows of a freshly dead employee because apparently a bunch of critical informations were stored on it ( payroll, bunch of passwords to Linux boxes running stuff )
I refused, then asked to get permission of family.
Then I learned that the plan was to basically reclaim that personal laptop of a dead employee because migrating stuff was too hard.
I told them I was busy.
I think they stole that laptop containing private correspondance and still use it today.
It’s a NGO you heard off. Running on most continents.
My take : IT and security are a distant thought in those places and you need strong top down directions and training to enforce basic hygiene
2 and 3 have absolutely no incentive not to lose your data. When was the last time any company got seriously hurt by a data breach? Hell, even password managers lose data and keep chugging on.
Oh wait. He don’t anymore .
since he switched laptop and don’t care anymore, but weirdly nobody made backup because their is a sense that this once teenager ought to keep things running, somehow.
( inspired by real life even. )
But I think this basically exists and is called indieweb?
Google will not scan your mails, will not scan your drive. Microsoft will not scan you drive. Apple will not process your pictures. Twitter will not control your speech. NSA will not see if you were at a protest, or went to a medical facility to perform a surgery of any kind.
"But does it matter if NSA sees me at a protest?" asks somebody. We will see. We will see. Maybe in a year. Maybe in two. Maybe never. Let's hope so.
Most of things you can self host. Probably the biggest problem is to selfhost videos, as they are heavy.
"But it is difficult to self host, and dangerous" says somebody. Yes it is. Yes it is.
"But I will not be able to talk with my friends" complains somebody. Let's wait how it all pans out. Maybe corporations and governments will not see and control everything we do. Maybe they will.
They have all the money they want. They can make all the money they want.
They have a machine, they can make all the money. It's not about money.
It's about control, it's about their vision of how they wanna see the world.