News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by rmc on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:49AM (#3666211)
I love that it's open source

Technically not open source. It's released under a Creative Commons CC-NC-SA which is not an open source licence, and is not approved by OSI nor FSF

However, the source is available, and it's CC, which isn't exactly a propriatry programme.

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by wcarss on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:54AM (#3666348)
I get that these terms do have specific meanings, but it bothers me that those meanings are so restrictive as to be unintuitive to someone not steeped in the dogma of the community.

These people made the source openly available and, by the CC license applied, can't it be modified and redistributed? That feels like "openness" to me. Thus, this feels like "open source", but technically the open source proprietors haven't opened the term "open source", so it's not.

Or have I misunderstood the license in this case? I admit, I am posting before looking, because the time it would take to look could make my post irrelevant.

Correction: I just went and looked. The license acts as I expected and has a digestible compact form for easy consumption.

Now I've gone and looked at the OSI site, and the CC license is not one they have approved. Yet they provide the material on the OSI site as CC licensed.

This distinction suddenly just seems dumb. Can someone elucidate it, or its use, please?

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by mseebach on Monday March 05, 2012 @08:04AM (#3666364)
The problem is the "NC" = non-commercial. It is, when you think about it, a very strong restriction on what you can do with it. I totally get that the author doesn't want somebody to come along and go make money on the back of his work.

But let's say that you download the code, enhance it and put it on your Github for the world to see. Great, you're allowed to do that[1]. But what if you're a contractor and your Github is part of your public profile, i.e. your professional marketing material? You could very well be in breach of the NC clause.

That's why FOSS enthusiast tend to be a little purist about it. OSI and FSF approved licenses contain no such ambiguity.

Also, there's the down-watering of the term itself. RMS actively opposes the term "open source" because it's less free than his "free software" definition, the success of which he considers OSI to leech on. I'm not even sure how open source is less free than free software (although I'm sure it is), but I agree with the concern that the term open source should be protected to include the concern of absolutely free usage.

1: Although you could construct the argument that since Github is a commercial entity that benefits from showcasing code on their website, it's actually a commercial usage.

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by wcarss on Monday March 05, 2012 @09:33AM (#3666581)
Awesome! Thanks to you and icebraining for the responses. The Non-Commercial distinction makes sense.

To be clear though, would a CC BY or CC BY SA license be fine, then? It's not listed on the OSI Approved Licenses list (which is the issue others took earlier in the thread, or so I thought), but those would appear to serve the same ideals that approved licenses do. If that wouldn't be fine, I'd love to better understand why not.

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by icebraining on Monday March 05, 2012 @10:00AM (#3666686)
I don't know what's the OSI position, but they're considered Free by the FSF/GNU, although they'd prefer if people used something else, since they're GPL-incompatible.

https://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html#ccby

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by cdcarter on Monday March 05, 2012 @11:02AM (#3666932)
The rhetoric that tends to be thrown around is that CC licenses aren't specifically designed for code, and that there are other licenses that accomplish the same thing but cover your bases better.
Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by mseebach on Monday March 05, 2012 @11:14AM (#3666985)
That's not rhetoric, it's an argument. And a good one.
Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by cdcarter on Monday March 05, 2012 @11:43AM (#3667106)
hmm, perhaps I should have used "language". I agree.
Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by alttag on Monday March 05, 2012 @12:23PM (#3667297)
Is there an OS-type license that includes a NC clause?

(Yes, I understand that true OS licenses can't have that restriction by definition, but I hope the intent of my question is clear.)

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by rmc on Monday March 05, 2012 @02:59PM (#3668091)
Creative Commons like this project uses?

The FSF and OSI are both clear about what liberties a licence must give to people for it to be called open source / free software, and "must allow commercial reuse" is one of them.

Software that includes a non commercial clause doesn't get built upon much and so clauses like that don't get much traction.

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by icebraining on Monday March 05, 2012 @01:27PM (#3667616)
As far as I know, there isn't any free licensed license¹ for software that includes that clause, but in theory nothing prevents you from taking e.g. the MIT license and adding that clause yourself. IANAL, YMMV.

¹ As written works they are, licenses are themselves subject to copyright, so you can't just copy someone else's licenses and use it yourself.

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by rmc on Monday March 05, 2012 @10:11AM (#3666729)
The definition of open source / free software is quite short and succinct, as can be seen by the Free Software Defintion (aka "Four Freedoms") ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Free_Software_Definition ), the Debian Free Software Guidelines ( http://www.debian.org/social_contract#guidelines ) and Open Source Definition ( http://www.opensource.org/osd.html ).

The absolute deal breaker with CC-NC-SA that would stop it dead from being "open source" is the "NC" or "non-commercial" clause.

For someone just playing around, this isn't too much of a problem. But when you start building & distributing it, you start to run into headaches. e.g. If you were to improve this lots and make it way better, and put it on your website, would you be allowed to have Google Ads on your webpage? Is that a commercial use of this? You can never sell a computer fully loaded with linux and this game, cause that's a commercial use, etc.

Imagine

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by icebraining on Monday March 05, 2012 @08:05AM (#3666368)
Just to explain it: It's the "NC" (noncommercial) part. From the OSI:

The license shall not restrict any party from selling (...) the software

And the FSF:

A free program must be available for commercial use, commercial development, and commercial distribution.

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by Trufa on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:47AM (#3666321)
I'm curios, the difinition of open source implies (demands) more than making the source code available?

Just in case I'm not talking in a broad sense, I'm asking whether just being able to see the code is enough to consider a piece of software open source.

Thabks

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by rmc on Monday March 05, 2012 @10:13AM (#3666741)
the difinition of open source implies (demands) more than making the source code available?

Yes.

Essentially, you have to provide the source, and also allow people to make & distribute derived works based on it. This CC-NC-BY licence does not allow you to distribute derived works for commercial purposes. Lots of companies use open source software in commercial purposes.

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by repsilat on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:58AM (#3666355)
It depends who you ask. The OSI have a definition (http://www.opensource.org/osd.html). It isn't the only definition, but it's probably the only definition self-important enough to have its own webpage. Some people get angry if you don't agree with that definition, but there's no real reason to consider it privileged above the lay definition ("the source is available").
Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by benatkin on Monday March 05, 2012 @12:52PM (#3667446)
Thankfully OSI was unable to get a trademark on "open source" so people are at liberty to use the term as they please. I accept the OP's use of the term. You might reject it but please say why you don't think it should be considered to be open source.
Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by emillon on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:40AM (#3666307)
It's open source, but not free software.
Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by rmc on Monday March 05, 2012 @10:02AM (#3666697)
The OSI tried to get a trademark on the term "open source" to prevent it being used outside what they want, but it was denied as too broad a claim IIRC.

As such there is no canonical definition of "open source", however in the context of open source software, this would not be considered an open source code.

There are very very few things that are "open source" but not "free software". The main difference is ideological and/or tribal.

Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by dagw on Monday March 05, 2012 @09:21AM (#3666540)
Not according to the OSI. So I guess you could say it's open source, but not Open Source.
Re:Mari0=Mario + Portal ..Open source game by mst on Monday March 05, 2012 @09:49AM (#3666629)
I've always been fond of referring to such a thing as "source available" - and commercial software such as Radiator where you only get an un-obfuscated version of the source with a purchase as "source supplied".

"Available" just seems like a better word than "open" for this sort of case.

(the author apologises for overuse of quotes in the above but preferred to be consistent even at the potential cost of some irritation and/or incorrect usage)