I don't think he ever claimed to be an expert at the stuff he talks about and that we're free to talk about stuff we don't know everything about.
As it stands now, it seems like you posted this just to say something clever.
You list many categories of small groups of people opposed to one encompassing the absolute majority of all. How is the former more powerful by necessity?
The key is people realizing they are part of a large group with a common cause. And powerful if they organize as such. Your comment appears designed to prevent that.
Recognizing obstacles to your goals is hardly unhelpful. GP is clearly pessimistic (and admits as much), but that doesn't change anything. If we (presumably in the "people wanting privacy" camp) want to win, we need to go down that first list and either decide why each of those sorts of people don't matter, or figure out how to counteract their political power.
"How is the former more powerful by necessity?" is a good question that deserves an answer, but I think you seem to have already decided, without evidence, that those people are not powerful, which I think is mere wishful thinking.
"Counteracting" individual groups as you propose is a nonsensical approach. It is reactive and at best a second order addendum.
How you read from my comment I was making any assumptions about these groups is your secret alone.
Ok, sure...
> "Counteracting" individual groups as you propose is a nonsensical approach. It is reactive and at best a second order addendum. Understanding how the system you want to influence actually works...
I don't think you really understand how "the system you want to influence" works? Knocking down "the other side"'s argument is often an integral part of getting things done in politics. Certainly there are other ways, including trading favors and agreeing to support someone else's pet project for their support on yours. But that's not everything, and often is not sufficient.
Regarding coordinated action: I agree, but it turns out that's very hard to coordinate, especially when it comes to privacy issues, as most of the US electorate either doesn't care about privacy, or doesn't understand why they should care (seems they often fall victim to the whole "if I've done nothing wrong, I have nothing to hide" fallacy that the government always pushes). It's very hard to coordinate a group that at best thinks what you're talking about isn't important, and at worst has bought your opposition's propaganda efforts and thinks you're wrong.
> How you read from my comment I was making any assumptions about these groups is your secret alone.
Then what was the point of your post? OP was listing obstacles to getting this legislation passed. Some of them may not be relevant, but I don't think it's safe to blanket assume they all are. If you think they are indeed all irrelevant, then that's fair, but I'd disagree. If you think we don't need to care about those other groups, then I also disagree. If you don't hold either of those positions, then, again, what was the point of your post, and what did it have to do with what the OP was saying?
I tend to agree, but rarely discussed: why are things this way, as opposed to being better?
Would investigating that not be top priority in a corporation? Isn't it strange that with the literal system that (theoretically) oversees everything we seem to never wonder such things, as if governance is an immutable constant?
COVID Shattered my belief that people "wanting privacy from government" is a "large group" as you seem to imply
People are more than willing to trade their privacy for the promise of the government provided safety blanket, even if that promise is false, can never been realized and will result in massive abuse.
I dont think there is a a large group to organize.
Basically they find security in obscurity, and feel they have a better chance of surviving under the radar on their own.
vs
2) Those who think it should be easy and convenient to use services and free to keep that data private
Which group is in fantasy land? Privacy takes work and meaningful trade-offs.
How about this: services/sites make it abundantly clear what data they collect (no full page of legalese designed to make people scroll to the bottom). Make it a list of bullet points, maybe. Explain how the data will be used, maybe collapsed by default so it's not overwhelming. Depending on the service, it may be appropriate to notify users about an updated privacy policy. Enforce antitrust and whatnot so Google and co. aren't just dominating the landscape and forcing their way. Also remove dark patterns. This isn't exhaustive, by the way.
Then set a price. And no "here's a constant subscription notice that you can't really block". Guess what happens in my ideal world if a service is found violating the privacy policy.
How about a cell phone service that would not sell any location data connected to you or your phone usage. Would you be willing to pay over $200/month or less? What would you pay?
I recognize some folks want privacy at no cost to them.
If you think you can force it by law, then choose a good jurisdiction for that strong-arming.
On a more general note, it's ridiculous that the status quo is so entrenched to the point where discussions about privacy often feature doomerism and cynicism ad nauseum, as this thread shows. For all the hubbub (in the US, at least) about human rights, about justice, about democracy (however misguided some of these pleas may be), there is a sickening lack of attention when it comes to privacy. When you realize you live in a backwards (literally? figuratively?) world, do you point it out? Will the others merely laugh at you? Is your vision of something different just a worthless hope? I, for one, fervently wish that more people become antagonistic to the idea that privacy is meaningless or not worth fighting for.
We are not talking about the free service providers like google or meta, right?
All of those parties are collecting data about you. While there is some value to using that data internally, it is obviously valuable as a commodity to be sold to others. You might complain that your cellphone company benefited instead of you. But you gave up your data to somebody for some reason.
You can't complain about not getting invited to this weekend's party if you aren't willing to share your phone number with the organizers. If you weren't willing for them to sell that data later, you should have put them under contract. Of course, they may have responded by charging you admission to the party. If you don't like being charged admission AND getting your data sold, go to a different party or no party at all.
I know, I know. It isn't fair. Parties are a basic human right.
Sure, I give data to my bank. I expect them to do bank things well, and if they expect action on my part then I'm liable for not doing it. I benefit and so does the bank, because it does investing or whatever. Does that mean the bank should have carte blanche to share my data now? As a pure matter of trust, I have no recourse because I trust(ed) the bank. That's the "scary cracker breaking into the database" kind of trust.
However, I feel I'm entitled to more than that as a citizen of the fine and upstanding US of A. Governments are worthless if they don't protect the people from (or at least try to resolve) getting robbed and whatnot. I view "not getting my data spread to arbitrary parties with possibly only direct consent or knowledge on the surface level" as another thing to be protected from. A cost-benefit analysis breaks down if my benefit is "I get to use these services" and my cost is "I'm literally, financially paying and I'm tracked everywhere and I have a social credit score" and I don't have a feasible alternative.
For parties, perhaps they shouldn't be regulated the same as companies, so I guess I should be prepared for my phone number to be sold if I go. I can still complain if their excuse is dubious.
If you work as W-2 in USA, your employer, or their payroll company, may be sending your payroll data including itemized withholdings to theworknumber. Some employers don't even know the payroll provider is doing this nonsense.
>> I don't have a feasible alternative.
Most people have to work.
The Work Number is good for us, says this university.
I'm on the side of people who believe in privacy, but not on the side of people who believe this. I do not believe that privacy should be contingent on how it affects the US economy, and as such I do not believe that if I can engineer a wealthy totalitarian economy, there's no reason for privacy.
I can't say I have ever heard this particular conspiracy theory before.
The all-powerful CEO who wants access to detailed customer data? He will be in The Database himself (if not his own, then in the one that a rival company offers). As will his favorite son with the drug habit, and the questionable thing he did on holiday that one time... Might not even be that bad or illegal. But would he want his workers to know those things about him?
The policitian whose party is in power right now? She is in The Database, too. As is her shady half-brother, all the info about the medical procedures she had done while in college, plus her husband's business dealings. Sure, they are legal but will it sound good to her constituency if it leaks? After all, her party might not be in the majority anymore after the next election...
Whenever your unbridled greed for tracking, profiling and surveillance becomes overwhelming, please attend your closest meeting of "Data Collectors Anonymous" and memorize the mantra: IYDTS - It's your data, too, stupid!
Your own daughter will be spied on by creeps. Your mother may be discriminated against when trying to get a mortgage. Whenever you collect people's data for profit or control, you WILL hurt yourself and the ones you love.
Even if you personally are the cleanest Mr. goodie two shoes to ever live, those around you surely aren't - and don't forget, in the end it's very easy for The Database to have some entries about you that might not even be true. Mistakes happen. Good luck proving or correcting them.
If you don't do whatever you can to protect privacy and minimize data collection, every day the chance increases that your own data will be collected and used against you or the ones you love. Then you might not be in a position to stop it anymore. And you may never be happy again...
This actually happened to me. A clerical mistake by a teacher changed my name in databases which led me to change my name officially so that I can have my original name back.
Take memes for example and how they out educated press conferences during the pandemic.
Creating content that is anchored to hell the everyday person learn and decide what’s important to them beyond conscience at the expense of security and privacy should be an informed decision.
On the other hand, if people went through this 20 years ago, chances are it will start to happen some more with a much larger group, only less technical.
Is it? Are you referring the the Fourth Amendment?
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and
effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated,
and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or
affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the
persons or things to be seized.
While that's a nice fantasy, it's not the reality.Firstly, while the fourth amendment does preclude the government from rifling through your physical belongings without a warrant, the Third-Party Doctrine[0] allows the government to get pretty much any of your information and private data if you provide it to a third party.
What's more, corporations are not subject to the fourth amendment and can do pretty much whatever they want and you have no recourse.
I wish you were right, as I value my privacy. Sadly, you're not.
I was responding to many of OPs bullet list focused towards the government.
I mean it is the supreme law of the land. So I am confident it is not fantasy. That the people only need to assert their rights, that is the fantasy.
I take your point and, as an American, I agree that's how it should be. What's more, upon further reflection, "fantasy" was probably too strong a term.
That said, there are serious issues around privacy in the US, given the legal jurisprudence around data you provide to others, especially since so many folks have their whole lives "in the cloud" (i.e., someone else's servers).
As such, I urge you to learn about and understand the Third-Party Doctrine[0].
It has a long legal history and is well established law in the US.
And it allows the government to obtain, without a warrant, any and all information you provide to a third party. That could be your cellular/email providers, your ISP, whoever stores your smart watch data, the company that hosts your menstrual period data, anyone to whom you willingly give information.
Granted, that third party could refuse and force the government to get a warrant/court order, but it's not required.
For many people that pretty much obviates most privacy protections of the Fourth Amendment.
That we have a right to "be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures," isn't at issue.
The issue is that so much of what you consider "private" data isn't private if you give it to a third party. And these days, we do that a lot by sharing our most private information with whoever hosts the app which tracks that information.