News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by karim79 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @11:02PM (#36626549)
There was this one bit in KQ4, I think near the end, where I got stuck for weeks.

A bunch of step stones going across a swamp, if I recall correctly, which needed to be navigated in order to get to the next screen.

I repeatedly tried stuff like "jump on stone", "jump across", "swim".

"YOU CAN'T DO THAT HERE"

It took weeks to figure out that all I needed to do was type "jump" without any additional text. Oh, the good old days.

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by cperciva on Friday July 07, 2023 @12:26AM (#36627120)
It was Space Quest 1 for my family and friends. "Insert disk into computer"? "Insert disk into drive"? "Use computer to read disk"? Nope, turns out the magic words were "Insert disk into slot".
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by vkazanov on Friday July 07, 2023 @02:55AM (#36628165)
Now, imagine the same problem, but for a kid who didn't really have a lot of exposure to English in his daily life.

I both loved and feared those moments in early adventure games: all good, moving on with the story and then... am I an idiot? Is this part of the game puzzle, or I have to iterate all the dictionary words again?

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by cperciva on Friday July 07, 2023 @04:04AM (#36628664)
I learned to spell by playing KQ1 and SQ1. Well, playing the games and having parents whom I could ask questions like "how do you spell 'search body'".

It's not just kids without exposure to English who struggled with typed English interfaces!

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by vkazanov on Friday July 07, 2023 @05:39AM (#36629336)
On the brighter side: I lived through that period when the games transitioned from text-based interfaces to point-and-click ones. What a relief that was!

I understand the nostalgia for Infocom games of people like Jimmy Maher - I also have a soft spot for beautiful and polished writing, but this definitely was a way forward for games in general.

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by cperciva on Friday July 07, 2023 @12:29PM (#36634179)
I hated the transition to point and click, because it turned into "hunt for the right pixel" -- with text based games you generally only needed to be in the vicinity of the object you were trying to manipulate.
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by DavidNielsen on Friday July 07, 2023 @01:59PM (#36635710)
Absolutely, but precision was also a bit of a problem for the text based games. I remember Space Quest was the king of this, requiring frequent saving to make it past certain sections where a single accidental button press could cause you to fall off a ledge or step on something that just killed you.

If you, say have a movement disorder, this happens all too often.

Still I have so many great memories of Sierra’s games from my childhood that I can’t bring myself to hate all the foibles.

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by vkazanov on Friday July 07, 2023 @02:59PM (#36636762)
My favourite pixel hunter was and still is Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis :-)

Can't imagine myself playing that kind of game again but back then this semi-serious and comfortably safe (no real danger and no sierra deadends as well) gameplay felt right for the 7-8 year old.

Oh, and Kyrandia..!

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by DavidNielsen on Saturday July 08, 2023 @06:24AM (#36643066)
Both games are classics, Indy 4 is one of my favorite games of all time.
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by vkazanov on Friday July 07, 2023 @03:03PM (#36636811)
Yeah, the pixel thing... Not as bad as most parser-based games but still.

But did the industry find a better way to tell a story without resorting to action-packed gameplay? I mean, Grim Fandango kind of slow story supplemented by visuals?

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by twoodfin on Friday July 07, 2023 @03:58PM (#36637513)
No offense to Grim Fandango, which is a great game, but for Sierra-style adventures, I don’t want to be told a story. I don’t want to feel like I’m moving on tracks through a ride, flipping a switch or solving a puzzle to keep the train moving.

Like the best interactive fiction, in classic Sierra games you’re interacting with the developers’ world to create the story. Free-form text input is key to this distinction. Play-throughs of richly written games like The Colonel’s Bequest are much more rewarding because your character isn’t limited to exploring the world via “look/talk/touch/use”.

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by vkazanov on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:44AM (#36663225)
Well, some of that free range kind of feeling can be achieved by introducing local non-linearity into the game, i.e. make certains parts of the game independent of each other.

Then, as the player progresses to the next episode the non-linearity would become a single step to the next episode, without any cross-episode interdependencies. Most well-designed adventure games have this branch-narrow-branch-narrow structure, where bottlenecks make sure the player is ready to proceed to the next level.

What was no very good about Sierra-style design is that they did introduce this non-linearity but there were often inter-episode links introduced. (e.g. "had to pick up this item a couple of episodes back it's late now"). So resorting to walkthroughs was the only way to avoid this kind of meaningless backtracking. It a very shady way to lengthen gameplay time!

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by twoodfin on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:51AM (#36668163)
I agree, though in the better games (most of them, I would say) this kind of thing was a) hard to get yourself stuck in if you were making a careful play-through and/or b) not fatal, only costing you the "best" ending or some final score points.

The best games (again, I'd cite The Colonel's Bequest) had numerous game-stage dependent side-quests and optional puzzles or secrets that made for rich replay value.

Overall, I wouldn't undersell the value of the possibility of failure & the frisson it provides over a carefully guard-railed world.

There's certainly an aggressively evil way to structure games like this. The first that comes to mind is Infocom's The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, but it's hard to escape the impression that the sadism towards the player was meant to be part of its charm.

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by ASalazarMX on Friday July 07, 2023 @02:40PM (#36636456)
I think the next evolution on it was classic JRPGs, like Dragon Quest/Warrior. There was still tons of dialogue, but the point-and-click was replaced by speak-to-everyone-and-try-stuff. It was still mostly linear, but it felt more interactive than just finding the right screen region.
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by vkazanov on Friday July 07, 2023 @05:42AM (#36629363)
Thinking about it again... In the end of the day, these games are what made English easy for me. In the longer term this definitely worked well!
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by DavidNielsen on Friday July 07, 2023 @09:13AM (#36631245)
I learned English playing Leisure Suit Larry when I was about 6, with a dictionary next to me, painstakingly translating everything. This turned into a lifelong love of adventure games, with the Space Quest games being an especially fond memory. This was also how I learned the difference between ‘make knife sharp’ and ‘sharpen knife’, or ‘put can in bag’ versus ‘put can in bag’ (the latter of which actually worked if I recall correctly, with Larry stuffing the spray can and then dying, which frustrated me to no end for ages. I always kinda thought that this is more in the style of what an educational game should be like, exploring with aids and the tasks being somewhat unforgiving, at least that worked really well for me.
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by cpeterso on Friday July 07, 2023 @12:26PM (#36634143)
> or ‘put can in bag’ versus ‘put can in bag’ (the latter of which actually worked if I recall correctly

Both commands above say “put can in bag”. :) What was the correct command?

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by DavidNielsen on Friday July 07, 2023 @01:45PM (#36635471)
And that will teach me to proof read, if I recall correctly then this was Larry 3 and it accepted both putting an air sick bag inside a spray can and the can inside the bag, the latter being the correct answer. It has been more than 2 decades since I last played the old Sierra games, so I might be misremembering, but it was all part of a really worrying suitcase bomb disposal puzzle near the end.

Don’t ask me how Larry stuffed the bag inside the can, but there was the same animation and everything. I remember being extremely frustrated with that, since the Sierra games are otherwise quite flexible in terms of accepting input. This was also why it was useful for learning English, since you could tell it things like ‘look item’ rather than requiring it to be “look at item’ and so on.

So I really loathed those cases where you had to be super precise, since they felt immediately off compared to the rest of the game.

Regardless good times, I think the best Sierra game of that era is Space Quest 3, which had some decent puzzles, a fun story and a hero I really liked.

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by twoodfin on Friday July 07, 2023 @02:19PM (#36636074)
The central puzzle of Space Quest 3’s first “act”—how to repair the hyperdrive on your crashed ship—has to be one of the best designed and most satisfying to complete in any game of any era.
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by cpeterso on Saturday July 08, 2023 @01:13AM (#36641532)
I’m not sure which is more frustrating: adventure games where you have to find the right command phrasing or games where you have to find the one magic pixel.

The limited grammar of these early adventure games had such a strong impact on me that I write my to-do lists now using the standard “VERB [ADJECTIVE] NOUN” grammar, as if I’m the character in my own game. :)

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by vkazanov on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:49AM (#36663264)
A slightly out of place geeky remark:

Note how "VERB.NOUN"/"ACTION.ACTIONABLE" is functional programming while "NOUN.VERB" is OOP. After 18+ years in the industry I still find the functional style more fluild: DO THIS, JUMP THAT, SEE HERE, etc. :-)

Now I see that it's the games that did this to me!

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by jasfi on Friday July 07, 2023 @05:09AM (#36629151)
You often had to take notice of the terms they used, and be sure to use those terms. That's why looking around was so important. In some ways those text interfaces were similar to crossword puzzles. They made you think, even as you described what you wanted to do.

The point-and-click UI was less frustrating, but there was also something lost compared to the text commands.

Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by ilaksh on Friday July 07, 2023 @07:07AM (#36629971)
It would be sort of interesting to put GPT-4 in front or something so it could determine if you were trying to do a valid action and then translate it to the correct command.
Re:Annotated scripts of old Sierra games by Zetobal on Friday July 07, 2023 @08:48AM (#36630902)
Oh my... I called one of the helplines that existed at the time and asked for the solution to a puzzle in one of the LucasArts Indiana Jones adventures.

Sounds so surreal in retrospect.