I have a series of screenshots and recordings where United would change information on their official app from, say, insufficient crew, to crew rest, to blaming weather. Had to take them to court (their delays cost us thousands) and won thanks to demonstrating how they altered their own information to blame everyone but themselves.
I think the modus operandi is simply to deny and obfuscate everything. That probably works 95+% of the time, as it takes a certain amount of motivation and effort to actually go through a small claim (even though it is ridiculously simple these days). My wife told me she would never have bothered.
So, they probably ultimately save a lot of money by doing this, even though it is annoying and nefarious.
Is this why many credit cards offer no/few questions asked travel insurance in case of airline fault? They know they’ll get a refund and they know how to work the process
And it was due to the airport being closed for inclement weather. Not even their fault.
Is very close to one of the many ways Best Buy got in trouble. Back in the day, their website would detect if you were looking at the website from a store-associated IP address, and display different pricing.
So when you shopped around at home and found your $200 hard drive, went to the store and saw that it was $300, the clerk could pull up the website and say "oh, no, you were mistaken, see?"
That started falling apart when cellular data plans became common place and people turned off Wifi and said "Well, huh, when I'm not connected to your network it shows a lower price. Please explain."
(Then there's the retailer specific SKUs... "Sorry sir, this hard drive is a WD8TB7200-BBY, not a WD8TB7200-AMZN, so it's not eligible for price matching"...)
It's likely way more complicated in practice, but I don't immediately buy the "it's cheaper not to fight it" idea, if the request is just for information they already have.
[1]: haha, couldn't be more wrong: "It is one of the most congested airports of Europe" according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisbon_Airport
Settling is generally legally neutral, but it’s not inherently exonerating in a social sense either.
The default should be "customer gets the refund" and the corporation needs to prove the refund should not happen.
Imagine being able to do a one step dispute with a consumer protection agency. The business in question would have 30 days to challenge in small claims court in the local jurisdiction. Consumer gets a letter in the mail about the determination with no effort beyond the initial dispute.
No underfunding the customer service phone lines, hoping to wear down the consumer. No hiding behind a self constructed obstacle course.
The corporate entity can run through a ninja warrior obstacle course to deny a refund.
Except...
they already stated they HAD investigated and reviewed things, and that's HOW they found that it was "ATC delay". So they already had the documentation...
... unless they never even investigated.
They also drag their feet on paying their software contractors. The company I worked for also had a digital adslvertising agency department. There were multiple times we had to threaten to pause all their Google and Facebook advertising campaigns until they paid. One time we actually had to do that, we had an email that payment was sent about 10 minutes later.
I think it's more likely that they decided it would be cheaper to pay the claim than to continue denying it, which would incur costs on their end to provide documentation and defend its denial.
Happens all the time with legal settlements. It's not an indication of actual guilt.