I'm a great believer in behaving ethically, but this is not the sort of example I'd give.
The impression I meant to leave was that I risked losing out on the deal all together because the CEO could have simply done the deal with the other investor.
I would rather that have happened than to screw over the VC who convinced me to look at the deal in the first place.
I wonder how much of that is "doing the right thing" vs. protecting one's reputation so you can continue to do deals. (And you clearly referred to protecting reputation ..)
If you are just interested in "doing the right thing" then the issue of protecting one's reputation wouldn't even come up in the discussion, right? (And nothing wrong with sounding "pollyannish"?)
I wouldn't have done what your friend did at the dance. Not because I'd be worried about reputation but because it would make me feel bad to do it. I wouldn't want it to happen to me (empathy). I can tell you have empathy just by the way you wrote the post. I'm wondering if you feel a need to cloak it in "reputation" and are you sure that's as big a motive as you make it out to be? As if it won't be manly or something.
It seems to me that this situation started when the company had a signed term sheet but still went around to VCs trying to interest them in investing. Is this normal? (I'm a bootstrapper, so I have no experience with these games.)
Proven innocent: close friends you'd trust with your children or your money, colleagues you've been through the crucible with (you know the measure of each other), YC and other small companies with a strong rep built over years and a simple management structure that isn't likely to be co-opted, etc.
Gut feeling = wishful thinking + rose-tinted glasses. Ignore it.
Here's what "guilty until proven innocent" misunderstands: without trust, the relationship is doomed regardless of whether the mistrust is justified or not. If I don't trust someone, I don't do business with them, period. And if I subscribed to your "simple rule," there would be practically nobody I could do business with.
I spoke about it here: http://www.bothsidesofthetable.com/2010/02/08/how-do-you-ref...
In the case of the new vc / old vc example that wasn't me ... yes, there was a 'no shop' clause. but ...
1. those are mostly unenforceable (is a vc going to sue an entrepreneur over no shop? not likely) 2. if the team really wants to get around it they can just run out the clock. most no shops are 45-60 days.
In the end, a term sheet is really just an expression of honor and reputation.
I'd use the "reasonable terms" principle with friends I worked with for some time, or with people who have an immensely strong reputation for being reasonable (YC, etc.) But if you met someone two weeks ago, and they bring up the concept of an emotional bond into what ought to be a commodity transaction, alarms would go off in my head. (Note that it's easier to talk about an emotional bond when you're on the better end of the deal).
Mark probably is one of the very few people who work in a reasonable manner, but unfortunately for every person who works this way there are dozens of impostors who'll pretend they're reasonable and then eat you alive the moment you let your guard down.
So my advice would be the opposite. Unless you've worked with the person for a while, or have really strong evidence that they put insanely strong ethics before profits (and believe me, gut feeling is not strong evidence), or you've already indicated commitment, take the better deal.