ZFS is COW with checksums so it wouldn't edit the same blocks and there is the possibility for sending snapshots to another pool (which may/may not use deduplication). Although, deduplication comes with a performance cost. I had all my photos spread out on various disks and external media, sometimes extra copies (as I did not trust certain disks) - if I remember it correctly I went from 3.6T to 2.2T usage by consolidating all my photos to a deduplicated pool. All fine, but the zpool wanted way more RAM and felt slower than my other pool. After I removed duplicates (with help of https://github.com/sahib/rmlint ), I migrated my photos to an ordinary zpool instead.