News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by zirgs on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:04AM (#36586846)
They are protected by copyright, but anyone is free to learn from them.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by elric on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:06AM (#36586880)
Sure, but there have been many copyright cases about plagiarism (in writing and in music). It's rarely cut and dry. There's a fine line between inspiration and plagiarism, which can only seemingly be settled in court. That approach is not feasible when dealing with the amount of data (and copyright holders) that Google gobbles up.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by zirgs on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @03:46PM (#36591694)
Using AI is probably the most inefficient way to obtain copyrighted content. It's much faster to simply find the original image or text and copy that instead.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:35AM (#36587287)
“Free to learn from them” isn’t specific enough. The question is “in what ways are people free to profit off of them?”
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by ajsnigrutin on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:05AM (#36586867)
Even AI? :)
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by Y-bar on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:27AM (#36587189)
Putting aside the fact that what we call AI today is not learning in the same way as humans. They operate on a VASTLY different scale compared to humans. On a good week I can read a book. A single book. A massively parallelised data centre can do that billions or trillions of times faster. Scale of effect (lacking a better phrase) must be considered.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by zmjjmz on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:22AM (#36587103)
Do believe that a human learning from a book is fundamentally different than training a model off of it, and thus should be regulated differently?
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by staticman2 on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:26AM (#36587162)
If corporations are allowed to own AI there's a strong argument that it shouldn't be treated anything like a human.

Humans aren't property so of course they should be regulated differently from AI.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by mjr00 on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:44AM (#36587417)
There have always been legal differences between a human doing something and technology doing the "same" thing.

It's legal for me to go to a nude beach and stare at a topless woman. It's probably legal for me to draw a picture of that topless woman and distribute it. It's definitely not legal for me to take pictures of that topless woman with my phone and post them on the internet.

It's legal for me to overhear a conversation you and your friend are having on a bus. It's legal for me to transcribe what I heard and post it online. In most jurisdictions, it's not legal for me to record that conversation.

Ingesting data for use in machine learning models is still too new to have any specific legislation around it. But the argument that the technology is just doing a thing that humans do has zero relevance.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by og_kalu on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:02AM (#36587607)
>It's definitely not legal for me to take pictures of that topless woman with my phone and post them on the internet.

This is legal. You can take pictures of anyone, nude or not in a public setting and post them anywhere.

>It's legal for me to transcribe what I heard and post it online.

This is murky. It's legal to take notes of what you've heard but that comes with all the pitfalls of hearsay. Legally, it's not treated as the human equivalent of recording because humans have no such equivalent.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by ajsnigrutin on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:14AM (#36587773)
The first one is iffy.... probably depends on a country too. If you take a panoramic shot of the beach, and someone is randomly topless.. sure. If you take a telephoto lens and single them out, it's questionable, and in many countries, illegal. Same as with walking vs following someone, even in public... the intent is different, so is the legality.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by JohnFen on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @01:27PM (#36603723)
I believe this, yes.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by madhadron on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:33AM (#36588045)
The fact that we call the curve fitting/optimization/compression that we do to fit machine learning models to input data "learning" is really unfortunate and leads to this kind of conflation.

If we trace the path of how we ended up here, it's similar to how people incorrectly refer to loci of DNA as genes. We have behavior analysis where we speak of learning as the conditioning via the antecedant-behavior-consequence loop. There was the Hebbian theory of how the ABC loop manifested physically in neurons. Early neural net papers took inspiration from that that mechanism and called it learning.

Meanwhile, actual learning is far, far richer than the Hebbian theory of synaptic strengthening, and has a lot more going on than just operant conditioning.

So, please, it's time for everyone to stop pretending that the fact that ML inherited the word "learn" as a term of art for curve fitting has any philosophical weight.