What country do you have in mind specifically? I live in a non-puritan country (Poland) and we absolutely need to produce the ID.
Anyways, I never had to produce ID when I bought alcohol and cigarettes while I visited Poland.
(short version - puritanism was a movement that orignated on the British Isles, and spread to the US from there. It never ever made it to Poland).
As for the original issue - once it's visibly obvious that you're over 18, nobody asks you to produce your ID. The only exceptions are automated (self-service) tills.
From your link: "Puritanism was never a formally defined religious division within Protestantism, and the term Puritan itself was rarely used after the turn of the 18th century." - that makes it extremely unlikely I meant it literally, don't you think?
As for the original issue - I wasn't over 18 back then and it was very visible.
You just walk up and the cashier eyeballs you and if you an obvious minor but then you get a friend that plays sports to buy it - just seem like a silly liability waiver for not getting sued when Timmy DUI's and wipes out somebody.