News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by galaxyLogic on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @03:49AM (#36583551)
Spaced repetition takes effort, and causes pain. It is tedious. So it still fits in with the idea proposed.

I believe you need to be conscious of what you are trying to learn and if it is tedious, then you are conscious of it because tedious means you experience some strain.

You will remember it better because it was painful. Just speculating but it makes sense to my layman brain.

Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by dmvdoug on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:36AM (#36583877)
Your response prompts for me a point I left out above: there’s major ambiguity here about “learning.” Learning isn’t one thing. Memorizing definitions of vocabulary words isn’t the same thing as explaining how you might apply a word in different contexts (think categorization or classification). This is one of the major things I spend lots of time on as a history teacher. Ok, great, awesome, we can kinda say what a revolution is. Uh. Uh oh. Why do we have revolutions that are French and Scientific? Those don’t sound super similar. Hey, wait, let me tell y’all about how I got on the internet when I was your age. I had to plug my computer into a wall, dial something, and a box inside my computer would screech at me. Y’all carry the internet around in your hands everywhere you go. Is that a revolution? Etc. That kind of learning is very different than looking a word up in a dictionary. And there are other kinds (procedural learning, which turns out to be actually rather different from other kinds).
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by makeitdouble on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:48AM (#36583966)
Spaced repetition happens everyday outside of a "sit at a desk and learn" setup and is plenty efficient without effort and pain. The obvious one is seeing again and again a concept so much you end up remembering it, like the Dunning Kreuger effect (or to take it darker, being able to recipe an ad you've seen hundreds of time)

If anything, I'd argue the pain and effort can be negative it will still work.

Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by galaxyLogic on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:59AM (#36584047)
Some things you learn without really trying. We learn our native language by repetition because we hear it all around us. But the question here is what if you want to or need to learn something you won't learn automatically? What helps? Try spaced repetition. It doesn't happen every day automatically. You must force yourself to do it even though it is tedious, if you want to learn what you want to learn.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by arrowsmith on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @06:09AM (#36584583)
I think what GP meant is that we already learn a lot of things through "spaced repetition" even if we're not consciously applying that technique. E.g. if you drive the same route repeatedly, eventually you'll remember the way without needing to look at a map. That's spaced repetition.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by watwut on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:49AM (#36583975)
> Spaced repetition takes effort, and causes pain. It is tedious. So it still fits in with the idea proposed

This is not true. Anki is tedious and causes pain. Flashcards are such in general.

But dpaced repetition does not requires either.

Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by Alt4Alt on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:57AM (#36584029)
Can you please expand on that. Is'nt Anki one of the most popular tools for using spaced repitition? By meaning spaced repetition is easier do you mean to refer to some other tools which makes it easy to implement and use?
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by watwut on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:20AM (#36584165)
If you reread chapters of a book in intervals, you are doing spaced repetition. If you return back to previous topic in math and do exercises again, you do spaced repetition.

Flashcard are just easy to implement application of it.

Yes among flashcards, anki is the most popular. But naive use of it leads to a lot of pain and tons of problems, you have to learn how to use anki.

Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by blackbear_ on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @09:37AM (#36586464)
Do you have any resources for learning how to use Anki? I use the default settings and I find them okay
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by michaelcampbell on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:52AM (#36599716)
/r/anki on reddit is actually pretty good.

Default settings are ok although I'd say 2 things that are counter to some common advice there:

* Actually use all 4 ratings buttons, and come up with a scheme for when. For me it was 1: missed it, 2: had to guess, but guessed right, 3: got it, 4: got it without even reading the entire prompt

* If you're insistent on the (IMO bad advice) "only use 1 and 3 keys" thing, install the "Straight Rewards" plugin. Without it, all your ease factors will decay to their lowest level (130% by default) since '1' lowers it, but '3' does not raise it, so it can only go down. With "Straight Rewards", it'll up the ease factor for you gently as you rate a card '3' enough times in a row.

Alternately, install the FSRS4Anki plugin. It's more work, but is a more dynamic scheduler. Requires the V3 Anki scheduler being enabled, and one of the more later versions. Do some reading on this before you try it; you can always go back, but it's not been proven yet to be substantially better than SM2.

Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by davty on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:40AM (#36599574)
I think it is pretty well established that simply re-reading can trick you into thinking that you know the material (via recognition) instead of actually remembering/understanding.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by bavell on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @07:43AM (#36585375)
Listening to your favorite new song everyday for a week is spaced repetition and very enjoyable, no pain whatsoever. You'll quickly learn the nuances of the song that you didn't pick up in your first few listens. Also a great way to memorize lyrics.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by eimrine on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @07:53AM (#36585453)
This relates to learning as much as watching some coding streams on Twitch to an actual coding.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by germinalphrase on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @09:32AM (#36586404)
That’s a value judgement which has nothing do to with whether or not listening to a song repeatedly counts as spaced repetition.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by eimrine on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:17AM (#36587028)
Being exposed to a song does not really counts as learning, but another thing is an analysis of chords, lyrics, post-procession effects, rhythm. Intention to repeat that in their own creative project is a judge.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by TuringTourist on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:43AM (#36587403)
If I have gained the ability to recite the lyrics of a song after being "exposed" to it for some time, it seems that I have indeed learned something.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by eimrine on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:29AM (#36587988)
In some genres, such as opera or modern pop songs like "pumped up kicks" or rap with some well-hidden links, or just a song containing some foreign language - this approach is so hard that if you want to learn you just download the lyrics and just read with no distortion of sense.
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by galaxyLogic on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @01:08PM (#36603450)
Yes you have. But that has happened by accident. You didn't try to learn the song, you just happened to be somewhere it was playing many times. (I say 'many' if you really learned the whole song correctly)

If you really WANT to learn something you cannot rely on such accidents happening. Accidents are not a method.

Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by galaxyLogic on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:42PM (#36590035)
That's a good example of an exceptional case. It is a good result to know. But really the learning-science is concerned about how to make learning so enjoyable that you are willing to do it. However the case of learning your favorite tune does not help much with the general question of what techniques you should use when trying to learn something else than your favorite tune :-)
Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by michaelcampbell on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:47AM (#36599651)
> Listening to your favorite new song everyday for a week is spaced repetition and very enjoyable, no pain whatsoever.

That's not really SRS though; a key part of SRS is the heuristic for when you next get exposed to the thing you're trying to remember based on your previous "got it"/"missed it" response. I suppose "every day" is one such heuristic, but it's not really in the spirit of SRS.

And you're mixing up enjoying the content with the mechanics of an SRS system.

Re:Learning needs to be effortful to be effective by michaelcampbell on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:44AM (#36599625)
I find SRS to be more a scheduling mechanism, not a memory one. If my memory of something is "bad" before SRS, it's going to be bad after, it's just I can let the algorithm refresh it more often than the thing I CAN remember.

Actual memory "devices" (tricks, schemes, etc.) are orthogonal; SRS (for me) just optimizes my time so I don't have to go over shit I know more often than I need to.

For anyone curious, my 2 go-to books on actually learning how to remember are the ones by Higbee (dry, but thorough) and Lorayne (approachable, but feels less academic). I used SRS to remember those 2 authors w/o having to look them up, FWIW. ;-)