News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by nhebb on Friday March 02, 2012 @02:10AM (#3655712)
Yes, he's egging the crowd on, but his comment did make me wonder what the legal ramifications of someone stealing bitcoins are. If one of the account holders tried to take Linode to court, do you think a US court would even acknowledge the value of a digital currency?
Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by DanBC on Friday March 02, 2012 @03:22AM (#3655860)
China doesn't acknowledge virtual theft, which caused some problems here:

(http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4072704.stm)

But a later case said that virtual property should be protected by law:

(http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2009-05/24/content_1142726...)

Dutch authorities arrested someone for virtual theft:

(http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/7094764.stm)

Here's another Dutch case, involving real world violence, which went to their supreme court:

(http://madisonian.net/2012/02/01/dutch-supreme-court-decides...)

That last one mentions US case about domain names.

I'd be really interested to hear from previous US court cases, or from lawyers, about this.

Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by rmc on Saturday March 03, 2012 @01:23PM (#3660705)
A lot of companies that deal in 'virtual goods', e.g. World of Warcraft, don't like the idea that the bits are property, because then it's hard for them to take the bits away from people (say for cheating), or if they want to shut down the servers etc.
Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by bradleyland on Friday March 02, 2012 @10:54AM (#3656984)
Bitcoin's status as a currency may not even be relevant. Your car isn't currency, it's property. If I steal it, I will be charged with theft relative to the value of the car.

I can't see how Bitcoins would be treated any differently. They're property, and they can be readily traded at an established value, so I don't see why someone couldn't be charged for stealing them.

Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by evgen on Friday March 02, 2012 @11:46AM (#3657228)
They did not "steal" them, they merely made a copy. The original owner still has their sequence of numbers. Snarky perhaps, but every possible argument one can make about why torrenting a video is not theft applies equally to the "theft" of bitcoins.
Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by bradleyland on Friday March 02, 2012 @02:20PM (#3657919)
I'd love to see that tried in court. I have a feeling that argument won't work very well. I have some limited experience in this area, as I worked for a bankruptcy trustee for a number of years. Debtors tried all manner of convoluted arguments to escape the spirit of the law. Judges have very little patience for that sort of thing.

The judge will make a limited effort to understand Bitcoins, but the core question will remain, "what harm was done and who was it done to?" The "owner" of the Bitcoins was, unquestionably, deprived of value.

So see it however you wish: Bitcoins as tangible property that was taken, or Bitcoins as tangible property that was irreparably damaged. Either way, the judge will ask the same question. Who was harmed and how?

Escaping the conclusion that the attacker's actions are responsible for the loss of value is impossible. You can bet that the State will consider these arguments very carefully if they catch the perp and bring charges against them. From there, it's up to the defense to find a jury so dumb that they'll buy the "Bitcoins aren't property" argument.

Regarding the arguments relative to video torrents, I believe this to be an error in logic. If I copy a video from a friend, that friend can continue to derive the original value from the video. That is, the friend can continue to watch the video and enjoy it. The act is different in that the original holder of the Bitcoins can no longer use them once they have been "copied" (to use your terms).

Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by rmc on Saturday March 03, 2012 @01:25PM (#3660711)
In this case the original numbers are totally worthless since they were transfered to someone else. The original owner has been completly deprived of the property.
Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by Tossrock on Friday March 02, 2012 @01:09PM (#3657594)
Wrong, actually. Read up on how bitcoin (or cryptocurrency in general) works.
Re:More than $215,000 stolen from Bitcoinica in Linode incident by gizzlon on Friday March 02, 2012 @04:41AM (#3656022)
A guy once hacked the SecondLife auction system and they closed his account: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bragg_v._Linden_Lab

I don't recall the details, but I think there was another case (in a Starwars MMO?) where the hacker "got a way with it" and build a house for the money. His buzzer plays the games theme-music :)