Traffic Fatalities in CA:
2019 -> 2020: +3.4%
2020 -> 2021: +7.6%
Unclear about 2021 -> 2022, I'd have to run the SWITRS data myself. Keep in mind these are just fatalities. I'm guessing crash data will show an even larger effect.
Source: https://www.ots.ca.gov/ots-and-traffic-safety/score-card/ and other OTS resources.
Are you more likely to be shot on the streets of Chicago compared to Boise? Probably, yes, however you're MUCH more likely to get shot on the streets of Chicago if you're involved in gang related activities.
There are probably similar qualifiers for assault on the BART.
No, not really. Unless you have data to back that up. Source: I was assaulted outside a BART station randomly.
One more data point:
> Rojas added, "It looks like it was an unprovoked, unwarranted, vicious attack."
https://abc7news.com/bart-stabbing-arrest-john-cowell-lee-oa...
One more
You made the argument that attacks are targeted using an analogy without having data.
The logical fallacy here is the fallacy of composition. We've only been given the statistics as they relate to ALL riders of the BART (of which "random commuters" only comprise some portion of ALL riders of the BART). We can't draw conclusions about the likelihood of assault against commuters based on this data alone.
Their perception seems to be born out by the data:
From the Bay Area Rapid Transit Police Department [1]
Aggravated Assault (2019): 112
Aggravated Assault (2022): 114
Relative increase (2019 -> 2022) adjusted for ridership:
114/112/0.3 = 3.39x
[1] https://www.bart.gov/sites/default/files/docs/2023-01%20Mont...