Re:Ask HN: Is GitHub down?
by Shekelphile on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:51PM
(#36524056)
Pretty much every company has been shown to have fake status pages at this point.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Status pages are updated by humans and the humans need to (1) realize there's a problem and (2) understand the magnitude of the problem and (3) put that on the status page.
It's not fake, it's just a human process. And automating this would be error prone just the same.
I wouldn't necessarily call them fake, but the issue often has to be big enough for most companies to admit to it. AWS often has smaller outages that they will never acknowledge.
Very good points. Meanwhile I have clients asking me why they can't have a status page to which I reply: you can, but ultimately to be completely fail proof it will be a human updating it slowly. To which they reply: but GitHub or X does it...
Very infuriating, that.
There's some nice tooling these days for this. E.g. https://firehydrant.com/ and https://incident.io both make this a faster, more embedded process.
Re:Ask HN: Is GitHub down?
by sjwhitworth on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:46PM
(#36524926)
Hey, incident.io CEO here! Thanks for mentioning us.
Re:Ask HN: Is GitHub down?
by amandamacleod on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:54PM
(#36527286)
And Jeli.io for this! With the Statuspage integration, you can set the status, impact, write a message for customers, and select impacted components all without leaving Slack. Statuspage gets updated with a click of a button.
Also (2b) convince their boss that the “optics” are better to update sooner than later.
Pretty much. They want the burden of proof for SLAs to fall on the customer, not on themselves. If a customer has to prove that an outage specifically affected them, they are much less likely to have a successful case against the failure to meet their SLA.
(Not directed at GitHub specifically, but at bogus status pages.)
From my experience, GitHub is the best out there when it comes to updating their status page.
Re:Ask HN: Is GitHub down?
by Night_Thastus on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:03PM
(#36524293)
Really? Why?
That's so disappointing.
Two technical reasons capstoned by driving business motivation:
-False positives -Short outages that last a minute or three
Ultimately, SLA's and uptime guarantees. That way, a business can't automatically tally every minute of publicly admitted downtime against the 99.99999% uptime guarantee, and the onus to prove a breach of contract is on the customer