News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by aidenn0 on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:15PM (#36514011)
It feels to me more and more like you need to be rich to afford living without bartering away your personal information.

I'm getting to be middle aged now, and have noticed a fatalistic attitude towards this by gen Z; kind of "it's impossible to maintain privacy, so I might as well milk my loss of privacy for all it's worth."

And I'm wondering now if that's not completely correct.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by RajT88 on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:41PM (#36514306)
I think for the most part, you can't really monetize your own data. You can just trade it away for "free" services.

Unless I've missed something...

Sidebar: The government is buying all your data from data brokers. We should all collectively submit FOIA requests to get copies of it, to create an undue burden on them doing so. Maybe they'll scale it back.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by Hermitian909 on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:37PM (#36514261)
It's true, and it's not great, but I think the flip side of this is that as I get older I find myself increasingly paying for the anti-social behavior of others.

There are lot of nice customer service things that are only possible if people don't abuse them: solid warranty/return programs, high quality phone reps, etc. But you need people who adhere to the social contract, the kind of people who don't, say, buy a $3,000 TV for a single super bowl party and then return it.

I actually desperately want some way to tell many of these companies "I am a responsible human being who respects social contracts" - all solutions I can think of violate my privacy but we'll find out what's worse...

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by don-code on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:06PM (#36514556)
Is respect for social contracts really all that's necessary? I don't see it as adversarial, so much as I see it as "normal _and_..." for many vendors.

For instance, even if I could buy a TV and then return it for free, why not return it and charge a fee? Most people are willing to pay the fee, even if they wouldn't return it, so what's the incentive for any vendor to not charge the fee?

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by Hermitian909 on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:30PM (#36514753)
> why not return it and charge a fee?

Your suggestion proves my point! With social contracts I don't need to pay this fee, but by getting rid of them I do; I'd be getting charged for other people's anti-social behavior!

Stepping back, social contracts are forms of trust at the societal level. Any economist or business person will tell you that being able trust others dramatically lowers transactional and operational costs. I want to be trusted so that I can take advantage of those lower costs.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by ghaff on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:28PM (#36514736)
Because they really don't like the TV for some reason/ Or an expensive purchase that should last for years falls apart after 9 months? Leaches who have made many companies cut back on generous return policies with "my ten year old coat is worn out, replace it" are basically turds who make life worse for other people.

ADDED: Furthermore, research has has shown (e.g late pickups at daycare) that when you add a fee to an anti-social behavior it can actually make the behavior more likely because it's now a transactional activity.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by Gordonjcp on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:24AM (#36518212)
> (e.g late pickups at daycare)

I've often wondered how well it would work if you went "right well, if you pick them up 15 minutes late today, you've got to pick them up 15 minutes early tomorrow", or "... drop them off 15 minutes late tomorrow".

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by supernewton on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:30AM (#36520838)
It still turns transactional. Maybe the parent has a job that is usually flexible but they have to put out fires every now and then, they'd happily sign up for this deal. Meanwhile it solves none of the daycare's problems and only adds new ones.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by barbazoo on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @09:51PM (#36515360)
Like a social credit score!
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by ThrowAway1922A on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:08AM (#36521430)
The more time goes on, the less opposed to this I am. There are too many bad actors in society who fuck things up for the rest of us.

Behaving is too hard for some people and I'm fine with punishing via a social credit score.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by Ruthalas on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:41PM (#36522915)
The problem with that is that it assumes both that the people giving the score are good, unbiased actors who agree with your assessment of what is appropriate, and that bad actors will be unable to game the system.

Even in a well-designed system, both of those will be suspect.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by marcosdumay on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:00PM (#36523279)
> There are too many bad actors in society

Yet you are arguing for giving some of them way more power to fuck things up.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by topposter32 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:26AM (#36517840)
> want some way to tell many of these companies "I am a responsible human being who respects social contracts"

Cultural background would be the strongest indicator of this behavior. It describes the norms and expectations to which you are accustomed. Unfortunately it's illegal to discriminate based on most signifiers of this trait.

The alternative to shared trust is costly and intrusive enforcement mechanisms.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by londons_explore on Thursday June 29, 2023 @07:50AM (#36519187)
How about just asking "Have you ever returned any item to a store for any reason except that it is faulty?"

If they say no, and you don't find their name on a few big stores lists of frequent item-returners, then you trust them. Everyone else, you consider shady and don't offer good deals to.

Remember lying to gain a benefit is wire fraud - so anyone who falsely answers this question has committed a crime - and a store is totally allowed to treat a customer they suspect has a committed a crime differently.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by topposter32 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:36AM (#36520921)
> and a store is totally allowed to treat a customer they suspect has a committed a crime differently.

That's not true either. There are vastly different standards of enforcement.

This issue is a lot bigger than returning items at the store. Every social system we have was built with assumptions about how people would behave. For example: the Seniors who are easily scammable are those who grew up around people who didn't scam each other.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by Casteil on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:25PM (#36514131)
Frankly, it's exhausting to try keep your life private. The sheer number of different ways your privacy can be violated via modern cars, phones, computers, social media, surveillance/facial recognition, IoT devices (including 'smart' TVs), etc. is quite staggering.

Definitely seems like a losing battle. My retirement plan is a remote cabin in the woods.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by eptcyka on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:35PM (#36514245)
Not only exhausting, it's also damaging one's social life, since preserving privacy is often making one the odd one out.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by javajosh on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:28PM (#36514170)
It may appear that way, but even privacy-for-profit schemes are illusory. The devices still send the data, it is still collated. Eventually this will effect the elites personally and negatively, someone will slip up with their parallel construction, and then we'll see real change in the US. Sadly, not before then.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by rkagerer on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:35PM (#36514244)
Even if you're rich it's difficult.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by renewiltord on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:29PM (#36514173)
No you can just get a cheaper car. You can get one for like $5k and the insurance won't be a lot. Just get minimums.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by aidenn0 on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:31PM (#36514200)
Do cheaper cars really lead to lower liability premiums?
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by renewiltord on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:41PM (#36514304)
No, you have to pay those anyway. But it will lower the total spend and so you'll have money available to pay them. You don't have to be rich or anything. I live in San Francisco, and insurance for my Subaru Forester costs me $1.2k/yr and I have comprehensive coverage.

So if someone were to buy a $10k car and instead chose a $5k car, it'll be as if insurance were cut to $700/year for the next 10 years!

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by louthy on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:49PM (#36514384)
> I live in San Francisco, and insurance for my Subaru Forester costs me $1.2k/yr and I have comprehensive coverage

Wow, that’s crazy high. In the UK my Porsche 911 (992) is cheaper to insure than that! (Without an insurance tracker)

Anyone know if US insurance generally much higher (than other comparative nations)? Or is SF an anomaly?

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by aidenn0 on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:55PM (#36514444)
I have comprehensive insurance for my car and it's about $850/yr. I'm also in California, but not near SF.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by renewiltord on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:03PM (#36514520)
About $868 of that is for "Comprehensive" and "Collision" coverage, if it helps. It's possible it's just me, though. I've crashed my car once, and been hit on my motorcycle. In general, given that, I would assume it's more because of that than in general since I'm obviously a high risk driver. When I set my address from San Jose to San Francisco (I used to store the car at my friend's) it went up $200/yr so that's the SF premium for Geico at least.

How much do you pay?

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by louthy on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:37PM (#36514805)
> How much do you pay?

About $1100 (comprehensive). I’ve never made a claim and have no speeding points, so I guess I get a good rate; but the OP rate still seemed pretty high for the model.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by renewiltord on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:47PM (#36514894)
I got Geico to make me a quote for this Porsche 911 https://www.carfax.com/vehicle/WP0AC2A90KS149357 and it comes to about $4.4k where I am.

And if I added this Porsche 911 https://www.carfax.com/vehicle/WP0CA29984S653662 it goes to $1.8k.

So I suppose it comes down to driver risk in the end since my car is only $32k, not $200k like yours.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by dingaling on Thursday June 29, 2023 @08:06AM (#36519328)
The majority of cost risk in insurance is that of third parties, not the value of your own vehicle.

People often say "the insurance costs more than my car is worth!" as if it's scandalous. But what it's insuring you against, primarily, is the risk of paying millions of $CURRENCY in medical fees to the third party. Your car's value is peanuts in comparison.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:49AM (#36520358)
I have always maxed out my liability insurance (what my insurance company would have to pay others in case it was my fault), and I have a spotless driving record, and it has always been $40 to $50 per month for 5k miles per year.

Comprehensive and collision, what your insurance company pays you regardless of who is at fault, is what cases insurance to be expensive in my experience.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:48AM (#36520346)
Car insurance is partly based on the distances you travel with the car, and the area. The US is bigger than the UK, so on average, that component of the insurance price should be higher in the US.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by yieldcrv on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:54PM (#36514422)
think of it more like the Hunger Games and all behaviors are explained
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by NotYourLawyer on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:58PM (#36514474)
I’m reasonably rich and would pay good money not to be tracked. It’s not really an option.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by hysan on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:03PM (#36514527)
I’ve started seeing ads for companies that try to get your data removed from sites and data broker.[1] I don’t know how effective they are but we’ve reached an age where there is a clear market for privacy. That feels very dystopian.

[1] https://incogni.com/

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by NotYourLawyer on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @09:11PM (#36515081)
I’ve heard of this one too. I’m too cynical to believe it’s legit though.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by GrinningFool on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:09AM (#36519876)
... which on its home page tracks to google analytics, tag manager, and the payment services provider paddle.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by abhayhegde on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:00PM (#36514490)
I hate how true this is! A case in point is also apps like Ibotta or Fetch which reward you based on your shopping data. Sell your shopping patterns, earn money! Rich can protect their privacy.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by topposter32 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:32AM (#36517874)
You are also describing credit cards. That's the trade you made to get a 1-2% reward.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by marvin on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:57AM (#36518038)
It makes sense that one's privacy is a valuable asset one can sell.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by WirelessGigabit on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:03PM (#36514523)
Even if you were to pay the fee or drive a gas car, or you pay for the 'better' insurance to not be tracked, your movements are still recorded everywhere with ALPR cameras.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by uoaei on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:39PM (#36514826)
If not your car itself.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by vGPU on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:29PM (#36514741)
But at the same time, I feel like this creates opportunities for enterprising individuals. How hard could it be to feed fake data into said dongle and enjoy the lower cost?

Of course, I’d much rather prefer that stuff like this didn’t exist to start with. The older I get the less patience I have for messing with this junk. All of my cars are now idiot-cars thanks to the death of 3g, and I pull antennas and SIM cards ever since the onstar eavesdropping scandal.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by NoraCodes on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:32PM (#36514770)
> How hard could it be to feed fake data into said dongle and enjoy the lower cost?

Wouldn't that be fraud?

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by helsinkiandrew on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:03AM (#36518074)
> How hard could it be to feed fake data into said dongle and enjoy the lower cost?

A lot of the monitors for older cars (that don't have 'tracking' built in) just plug into the cars OBD2 port and the CAN bus data - and is extremely hackable by anyone thats used an Arduino. It would be much harder to interfere if the monitor is wired in or using its own GPS to monitor speed and distance travelled though.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2015/01/15/resea...

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by astura on Thursday June 29, 2023 @08:54AM (#36519721)
Insurance fraud is a crime.

Not only that, but insurance companies don't cover claims when the policy was obtained by fraud.

Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by ssss11 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:29AM (#36518246)
I think the people who say “the public doesn’t care about privacy” are either completely ignoring the fact that most people will give it up if it means the product is cheaper (because, financial survival) or they are deliberately pushing the agenda.
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by bmj on Thursday June 29, 2023 @07:14AM (#36518911)
My auto insurance provider (in the US) has never even offered such a tracking program to me (and I know my current rates are pretty reasonable/in line with other companies). Maybe it's because of my history with the provider (I'm 50 and they've been covering me since I was 16)?
Re:To Save Money on Insurance, Drivers Agree to Intrusive Mo... by hospitalJail on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:13AM (#36519920)
And if you are rich, you don't actually get privacy, just the illusion of it.

I have dumb electronics that are way less intrusive than their luxury versions.