News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by JohnBooty on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @06:51PM (#36513769)

    it's all people who heard something who heard something
People with direct access to such classified materials would not legally be able to divulge details and especially not publicly. It would be a fairly quick trip to prison.

This doesn't directly prove the claims of Grusch or anybody else, of course. But it is a decently persausive explanation for why it's always "people who heard something who heard something" and not direct sources.

    "if Grusch is right about any of this, why did the DoD allow him to say it publicly" 
I don't know anything about Kean so I have no opinion on her.

One thing you have to say about Grusch is that he is really putting it all on the line. He is going through the official whistleblower channel and is triggering a major investigation.

If he is telling the truth, the DoD would more or less be admitting guilt by going after him.

(There is also a third possibility. Grusch is being truthful, but he and/or others have been deceived. I think wrapping a secret program under the cover of some UFO nonsense could be pretty effective camouflage, since UFO-related claims usually are instantly deemed noncredible in the eyes of many)

   "she has a particularly harebrained theory that DoD 
   classification rules allow Grusch to describe this 
   stuff in generalities as long as he doesn't cross a 
   line of specificity, which, just, no"
I honestly don't know how this works. Surely there is some line of specificity? I mean, you and I can talk about this and it's legal. At what point are you close enough to something classified to make it illegal?
Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by revscat on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @06:59PM (#36513853)
> People with direct access to such classified materials would not legally be able to divulge details and especially not publicly. It would be a fairly quick trip to prison.

I believe this is no longer strictly true for UAP-related information [1]. Congress has gotten much more serious about offering legal protections to those who have knowledge about UAP programs.

[1] https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/ufo-whistleblowers-wou...

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by tptacek on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @10:59PM (#36515821)
Whatever else those protections might mean, they apply only to disclosures made through official DoD channels, not to interviews given to book authors.
Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by revscat on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:32PM (#36515998)
> In accordance with protocols, Grusch provided the Defense Office of Prepublication and Security Review at the Department of Defense with the information he intended to disclose to us. His on-the-record statements were all “cleared for open publication” on April 4 and 6, 2023, in documents provided to us.

Source: https://thedebrief.org/intelligence-officials-say-u-s-has-re...

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by tptacek on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:12AM (#36520599)
Yes: we all agree that what he's saying is cleared for publication. Because it's nonsense and the DoD doesn't care.
Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by tptacek on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @06:58PM (#36513837)
It's absolutely true that, if the USG were in possession of extraterrestrial technologic artifacts (ETA's, must credit me for this coinage), it would be illegal for people with firsthand knowledge to disclose them. But lack of firsthand evidence of ETA's does not constitute evidence of the existence of ETA's. It would be illegal for me to disclose the existence of a +4 Wand of Magic Missile, too, if such a thing existed. But regardless of what I say I've heard about DoD custody of D&D items, we both know they don't exist.

The rest of this: I don't care, except that you have to work yourself into contortions to simultaneously argue that all firsthand reporting of ETA's has been stymied by legal threats from DoD, but Grusch's claims are true because they haven't been.

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by JohnBooty on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @09:12PM (#36515084)

    But lack of firsthand evidence of ETA's does not constitute 
    evidence of the existence of ETA's
I said this. So... yeah, agreed.

    The rest of this: I don't care, except that you 
    have to work yourself into contortions to simultaneously 
    argue that all firsthand reporting of ETA's has been 
    stymied by legal threats from DoD
Your logic is incorrect.

First, the whistleblower protection is new. It hasn't been around very long. https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/ufo-whistleblowers-wou...

It would definitely be illegal for anybody with firsthand knowledge via their security clearance to go public with classified stuff. That is 100% clear; probably the only 100% solid fact in this whole circus. They could, presumably, take it to the whistleblower channel in a non-public way, but I don't know the details there.

What Grusch has done is more of a legal limbo area. We can't say how legal or illegal it is without knowing exactly what the classified info is.

What's also clear is that there is a heavy price to pay in terms of career even when going through the whistleblower channel. There are all sorts of incentives to not do it. Just because others in his position does not necessarily mean he is lying.

Personally I don't believe it's aliens. I find it incredibly unlikely that alien races would send crewed ships here and then be clumsy enough to crash them or get shot down. I think it is far more likely to be some kind of camouflage for another more mundane program.

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by midoridensha on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @10:12PM (#36515509)
>Personally I don't believe it's aliens. I find it incredibly unlikely that alien races would send crewed ships here and then be clumsy enough to crash them or get shot down.

It's unlikely, but it's possible. Maybe the aliens are rather primitive technologically, and have weapons technology similar to cannons from sailing ships in the 1700s (and spacecraft technology otherwise resembling our early 1970s craft), but they somehow discovered a simple but somehow-overlooked portion of physics that allowed them to build spacecraft that could instantly teleport across the galaxy.

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by JohnBooty on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:17PM (#36515914)

    a simple but somehow-overlooked portion of physics 
    that allowed them to build spacecraft that could instantly 
    teleport across the galaxy
Well, I certainly can't say you're wrong, lol.

But science is so iterative. I realize that not all hypothetical species would follow the same tech tree as humans, but "skipping steps" seems so unlikely.

But hey, there are a lot of planets out there. I suppose it can't be ruled out.

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by int_19h on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:36PM (#36516028)
Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by jncfhnb on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:18AM (#36519969)
Every time aliens come up on HN, someone brings up this idea, and then references that one sci fi story, and then the discourse “well that’s dumb as hell but the story was fun”.

My dude if there is some aspect of physics that would allow for teleportation by low tech people, the earth would be annihilated by some dudes whim or accident with a month

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by midoridensha on Thursday June 29, 2023 @08:37PM (#36528924)
>My dude if there is some aspect of physics that would allow for teleportation by low tech people, the earth would be annihilated by some dudes whim or accident with a month

Maybe low tech aliens stumble upon the remnants of some (other) alien race and figure out how to salvage their warp drives, but can't get the rest working.

The universe is big. Maybe the warlike Pacleds just haven't found us yet. If they're low-tech (aside from FTL), they probably haven't figured out how to do long-range astronomy to look for habitable worlds either.

Obviously the whole idea is a big stretch, but damn this site sure seems to have a LOT of people who are completely and utterly lacking a sense of humor.

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by jncfhnb on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:02AM (#36533374)
There’s no such thing as low tech aside from FTL. If you have FTL you have weapons of mass destruction orders more powerful than anything we have. And energy sources greater than anything we have.

It’s not humorous when people bring the same idea up every time and defend it sincerely.

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by revscat on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @09:26PM (#36515171)
False premise.

> It's absolutely true that, if the USG were in possession of extraterrestrial technologic artifacts (ETA's, must credit me for this coinage), it would be illegal for people with firsthand knowledge to disclose them.

This is not true. For people with knowledge of UAP or UAP-related programs Congress has instituted procedures for those people to come forward and be protected in doing so. Those mechanisms are what allowed Grusch to come forward without fear of legal reprisal.

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by JohnBooty on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:18PM (#36515921)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but that just gives people with UAP knowledge whistleblower protection when it comes to reporting those programs through designated channels.

Whistleblower protection != the right to publicly disclose classified material

Re:US Congress doubles down on explosive claims of illegal U... by revscat on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:33PM (#36516005)
Unless cleared to do so by DoD, which he apparently was.