News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by janalsncm on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @12:53AM (#36502467)
People talk about how the US is the only country with truly “free” speech. But they should ask themselves how free are they really if keeping a job means not saying the wrong things publicly and having healthcare means having a job.

I think this is a reality that neither Twitter mobs nor American exceptionalist conservatives want to admit. If you believe all people deserve healthcare, then that includes people you might like to punish by contacting their employer. And for free speech to actually be free, one of the consequences of that speech should not be to lose healthcare.

Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by bugglebeetle on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @02:09AM (#36502905)
That’s the whole American kayfabe in a nutshell: create a boogeyman out of state power, while allowing businesses to stomp all over everyone. You have a greater right to free speech (in the absolute sense) in most European workplaces than you do in the US because your boss can’t take away your kids’ medical care because he doesn’t like some remark you made about politics or whatever.
Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by zpeti on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @03:59AM (#36503643)
Still, having speech censored at the company level is at least one step more decentralised than a government with the police and an army behind it.

It’s also much easier to change job than change country.

Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by johannes1234321 on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @04:08AM (#36503706)
For country leadership there are still elections, while flawed, in the U.S.

Over Google the people don't have much of a say. (The country can create legislation to steer it in a direction etc.)

And then internationally ...

Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by zpeti on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:46AM (#36505604)
People underestimate how responsive companies are to feedback, especially from customers, much much more responsive than governments. And again, you can switch jobs much easier than countries.

The entire current censorship issues are because of a small group of very organised people who want to enforce their worldview on the world. It's not views held by the majority, but companies still comply as they'd rather do that than fight.

But have a look at what happened to Bud light, they are in serious trouble because of one advertising deal. They changed their tune extremely quickly. This doesn't really happen with governments.

Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by janalsncm on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @02:34PM (#36510597)
Bud Light is not in “serious trouble”. They are a brand owned by a multinational beverage conglomerate.

But that’s beside the point. Whether or not these corporations are pro or anti LGBT depends on which way the wind is blowing today. It’s not fundamental to their business, so they don’t deeply care about your opinions on the matter. Try talking about something more fundamental, like labor rights, and you’ll quickly see the difference.

Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by bugglebeetle on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @01:15PM (#36509475)
I’m more worried about not being able to go to the doctor for having the wrong opinions than the US military pulling up to my driveway in a tank.
Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by zpeti on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @01:48PM (#36509992)
Oh come on, that’s just silly. There’s such a labour shortage anyone with a job can almost certainly get another one pretty quickly. And the more skilled you are the more likely.
Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by janalsncm on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @02:30PM (#36510551)
This assumes you aren’t blacklisted for speaking about something unthinkable like forming a union.
Re:Google does little to reduce advertisers costs by janalsncm on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @04:05PM (#36511847)
The counter argument to this is that the First Amendment is the reason you’re not afraid of the police knocking in the middle of the night over something you said. The law and 250 years of jurisprudence made it so.

Having your healthcare removed as a result of your publicly stated opinions is just one of many other possible negative outcomes that has not been prevented in America. I might go so far as to say that the US doesn’t have free speech so much as decriminalized speech.

(It’s not a perfect analogy in the sense that losing your job and healthcare isn’t identical to a fine, but it fits in reflecting the fact that prison isn’t the only punishment one can receive. Plus there are people financially situated such that the financial penalties of unpopular speech are immaterial. I’ll work on it.)