News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by res0nat0r on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @01:12PM (#3648933)
This is way too short. For example: 7 Habits of Highly Effective People is currently #52 on Amazons top sellers list and has been in the top 100 for 1500 days now. I don't know what the best time for copyright protection is, but 2-3 years isn't it.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by dredmorbius on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @01:23PM (#3648983)
The vast, vast, vast majority of published works are ephemera: news articles, magazine articles, technical publications, sports broadcasts, TV programs, etc. The economic lifetime of many of these is a few days or weeks.

The original term of copyright was 14 years, with one extension. This has grown to the current ~105 years.

Economic present-value analysis shows that the present value of an additional year of copyright past a couple of decades is virtually nil. As an incentive to create NEW works, global copyright extension makes zero sense. This argument hasn't been tested by SCOTUS, though Lawrence Lessig has stated that he might have done better in Eldred v. Ashcroft if he'd made that argument rather than claiming continued extensions violated the "for limited terms" Constitutional clause.

7HOHEP was published in 1989, giving it a 22 year life to date. Frankly, I don't think it's all that outstanding, but that's another story.

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by modeless on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:00PM (#3649406)
You're asking the wrong question. The question isn't "would '7 Habits of Highly Effective People' be making less money today if copyright were shorter?" (obviously yes). The real question is, "Would '7 Habits of Highly Effective People' been written in the first place if copyright were shorter?"

This is a much more complex question, and I'd argue the answer is probably yes, even if copyright was as short as 2-3 years. The writer of '7 Habits of Highly Effective People' didn't know ahead of time that it would become a perennially popular international bestseller, so the potential revenue from 50+ years of copyright protection likely played a small role in his motivation.

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by mortil on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @01:27PM (#3649004)
While I agree that 2-3 years is probably too short time, your reasoning is wrong. The purpose of copyright should be to incentivise the creation of creative works, not to perpetually reward the owners of works with a sustained commercial value.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by tsotha on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @02:22PM (#3649242)
Authors sell the rights to their books for income. The shorter the copyright period is the less valuable those rights will be. So it's not a question of "sustained commercial value", it's a question of the value of rights at the time of publication. 2-3 years would make writing a hobby for all but the very most popular authors.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by sp332 on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:18PM (#3649484)
I don't really care if the rights are less valuable. The author has no inherent (property) right to tell me that I can't make copies of his book. Furthermore, society would benefit if the book were in the public domain. It would be available from more sources than just the one state-granted monopoly that's selling them now.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by tsotha on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:47PM (#3649613)
>Furthermore, society would benefit if the book were in the public domain. It would be available from more sources than just the one state-granted monopoly that's selling them now.

No it wouldn't. It wouldn't be available from any source, because it would never get written at all. There's only so much time people are willing to put into an unpaid hobby.

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by sp332 on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:49PM (#3649621)
Why do you assume he wouldn't get paid for it?
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by tsotha on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:52PM (#3649638)
Who would pay?
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by sp332 on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:55PM (#3649657)
Anyone who thinks it's worth the money, anyone who wants to thank him for writing a book, anyone who wants to encourage him to make more books, anyone who makes an impulse buy, anyone who wants a physical copy... you know, all the same exact people who pay for it now.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by res0nat0r on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @04:46PM (#3649862)
Except for all the people who will be happy to get it for free instead, which they couldn't do previously without breaking the (copyright) law. If you were able to walk into your local Barnes & Noble tomorrow and everything was free to take, I'm sure you wouldn't be ponying up the money for everything you walked out the door with in your arms.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by sp332 on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @05:33PM (#3650047)
Actually, the people who currently get stuff outside the bounds of copyright law ("pirates") are the ones who currently spend the most money on it. http://arstechnica.com/media/news/2009/04/study-pirates-buy-... The COO of EMI knows that pirates are their best customers. http://www.cnet.com.au/will-former-google-exec-help-save-the... People do business with each other because they feel like it, not because they are legally obligated to. People give money to Kickstarter projects in return for very small rewards, or even nothing at all. e.g. http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/textfiles/the-jason-scot... I think Louis C.K.'s statement about piracy, while not especially insightful, has exactly the right idea:

Please bear in mind that I am not a company or a corporation. I’m just some guy. I paid for the production and posting of this video with my own money. I would like to be able to post more material to the fans in this way, which makes it cheaper for the buyer and more pleasant for me. So, please help me keep this being a good idea. I can’t stop you from torrenting; all I can do is politely ask you to pay your five little dollars, enjoy the video, and let other people find it in the same way.

Sincerely, Louis C.K.

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by jiggy2011 on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @10:26PM (#3650787)
I also imagine that Louis C.Ks audience is of a particular demographic where this may work (think relatively Internet savvy & intelligent , middle class 21-40 year old white people with disposable income).

If you were somebody creating lowest common denominator entertainment for an unemployed mother to put their kids in front of do you think you would get the same results?

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by tsotha on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @06:48PM (#3650311)
Will they still pay when the novelty wears off, though? Also, it's one thing to send money to a guy who makes you laugh. How many people would voluntarily send money for a textbook or an SAT prep workbook?

I doubt anyone would be buying music if Napster hadn't been shut down.

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by Hemospectrum on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @09:31PM (#3650676)
> I doubt anyone would be buying music if Napster hadn't been shut down.

Did you actually use Napster during its heyday? Of all the P2P software I've ever tried, it was probably the worst--or perhaps just the one most poorly suited to casual piracy. The search system was a joke. Even when your search turned up results, it was hit or miss whether they were actually what you were looking for. My favorite example was a file named "Beethoven's 9th symphony - by Mozart" (it was actually a Handel piece).

Now it's easy to find private torrent trackers with huge, well-maintained collections in very high quality. Comments and ratings make it easy to decide which of several versions to download, and moderators will even help look for rare files if someone can't find what they want.

I think the death of Napster was a big favor to pirates everywhere.

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by jiggy2011 on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @10:34PM (#3650800)
I'm sure bittorrent & private trackers is better for the discerning pirate, however napster was far more accessible.

You simply typed in what you wanted, waited for the search to finish and clicked to download rather than found an indexing site, selected a torrent based on "seeds" and "peers" and then worried about things like magnet links.

Many people who are not tech savvy and want to pirate either get their friends to do it for them or are still using kazaa and friends.

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by res0nat0r on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @04:17PM (#3649750)
Correct. He doesn't have property right(s), he has COPYright(s). Until you can abolish copyright protection in the USA this practice is still illegal.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by res0nat0r on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @02:01PM (#3649154)
This is a great argument, but a bit too idealistic in my opinion. If copyright kicks in a few years after I write my hit novel and then I see my revenue plummet to $0 even though I know tons of people are still willing to pay me for it, then I'd be less willing to write another book because of this. I'd be willing to bet that the next JK Rowlings of the world would fight tooth an nail to prevent any type of copyright change that doesn't at least extend until the authors death. Rowling and Stephen King aren't just in it for the money, but they do want to get paid.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by nitrogen on Thursday March 01, 2012 @04:11AM (#3651466)
Why should the author's death have any bearing on the length of copyright? That seems entirely unfair to the estate of the hypothetical dead author whose bestselling crowning achievement was written on his death bed, and entirely unfair to the public who want to have the works of unusually long-lived authors enter the public domain sooner.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by res0nat0r on Friday March 02, 2012 @01:02AM (#3655560)
This was just a hypothetical, extend it even after the authors death, this is fine by me. I'd like to see copyright such that the actual creator of the work defines how long the item stays under copyright. I say 1 year? Fine. I say until my death? Great. I say this book shall remain under copyright for 300 years? So be it. Take the good with the bad.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by wtallis on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:27PM (#3649527)
Idealistic or not, it's more than just a great argument. It's what the US Constitution requires.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by tsotha on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:51PM (#3649634)
But the constitution gives Congress a wide latitude in the implementation, which is why the Supreme Court is unwilling to curtail the perpetual extensions that got us where we are today.