HFT does very similar things, except it's even more opaque to those not doing it. Large financial firms and exchanges sell their order data to HFTs. If you're interested in a deeper dive on what they're doing, a book like Flash Boys will explain how there's a lot more going on than just a quicker network connection.
So I occasionally try to think of a reason to have a guaranteed delay due to signal propagation delay to/from Mars. Would there be a use for putting an automated exchange there? Maybe, but then whomever gates the orders could monitor and predict what will happen 40 minutes out or whatever. Need TLS from trader to exchange or something.
Most of this is improvable with software. As other commenters point out, the resistance is from incumbent trading institutions who have a lot invested in the status quo.
What is an order cancellation? Would different legs on a hedge count as a cancellation?
The closing window is a massive challenge as well. It would have to be accurate down to the nano second and you can bet the exchange is going to get litigated against depending on which bucket the order ends up in.
If you set up mandatory delays per client you would have each hedge funds split up into hundreds of shell companies to get around it.
Having worked at exchanges, most surveillance and analysis of trades happen after the close of day. You’re proposing a literal real-time surveillance system that would be absolutely massive in scale.
> The closing window is a massive challenge as well. It would have to be accurate down to the nano second.
It wouldn't have to be - one could even say first second is for bids, second second there are no bids but a delay to give auction results mid-second and allow people to process.
> the exchanges would know
They can be forbidden to sell that info real-time by their regulator (it arguably would be market abuse and that could be made explicit).
It is definitely not impossible like you are trying to imply. (Financial markets participant with 20 years in the market here, for what it's worth.)
The only meaningful way to limit the efficacy of these modern trading styles would be purposeful market friction through minimum holding times, circuit breakers, etc. You can't just legislate that people mustnt have low ping.. it's impossible to enforce. And those market friction mechanisms can create scary market conditions like backlogs, etc and guess what, enable market making brokerages to do internal swaps etc. in spite of the friction and essentially be the only ones able to bypass restrictions.