News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by oneplane on Monday June 26, 2023 @12:25PM (#36481900)
That sounds like a very one-sided argument. If you want a functioning government you're going to need money to pay for it, and if you don't have sales tax it means you have to get it elsewhere; it doesn't "make it go away".

If the argument was supposed to be 'a smarter, well-functioning tax system that pays for government facilities' then say that. But such a statement would need some references to back it up.

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by rootusrootus on Monday June 26, 2023 @01:01PM (#36482504)
Sales tax is an abomination. I walk into the store, pick something off the the shelf that says it costs $9.99, but I can't actually buy it for that. Argh.
Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by sircastor on Monday June 26, 2023 @01:43PM (#36483089)
I understand in some places in Europe (for instance) the price on the shelf is the price including tax. This is not a hard problem to solve.

I think Sales tax for most things is probably the fairest means of taxation. It can be applied equally between the wealthy and the poor. It is applied when you choose to get something, rather than arbitrarily before or after. It tends to be applied evenly whether you're buying a box of chocolates or a flatscreen TV.

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by Symbiote on Monday June 26, 2023 @03:58PM (#36485000)
It's pretty much only the USA where the prices on the shelves aren't the final price with taxes.

Sales tax (and VAT) is regressive since poor people spend a much larger portion of their income on goods subject to sales tax.

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by hellojesus on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:04PM (#36485828)
Meh, you could lower taxes on inferior goods and increase them on luxury goods to compensate. Income taxes are pure evil as they are unavoidable and maximally painful. As an Oregonian, federal+state income tax means I don't make any money I get to keep until late April. I think about killing myself every year because of it.
Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by ksherlock on Monday June 26, 2023 @07:18PM (#36487122)
In 1991, a 10% federal luxury tax went into effect. Result: rich people stopped buying yachts and planes. Revenue raised was a rounding error (less than $13 million in a year and a half), luxury industries were decimated, and the tax was repealed 2 years later.
Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by sircastor on Monday June 26, 2023 @08:25PM (#36487620)
So the lesson learned here that very wealthy people are more interested in not paying taxes than they are in owning their own planes and yachts?

I understand that $2.2 million is more than $2 million, but I find it kind of baffling that people spending that kind of money on that kind of thing are price sensitive.

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by no_wizard on Monday June 26, 2023 @09:22PM (#36487926)
Yachts and luxury boats yes[0] however it was effective on cars until 2002[1] however they still managed to collect $3.94 billion off the luxury tax by 2000[3]

One could argue that if they had the stones to keep the tax in place, eventually people relent and start purchasing high ticket items again, and it could have compounded to make a significant difference by now

[0]: https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-xpm-1993-10-07-19932801...

[1]: https://archive.is/pTR5E

[3]: https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20020307_RS20314_f70eb8...

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by fomine3 on Monday June 26, 2023 @08:50PM (#36487765)
More importantly, sales tax is equally applied to foreign companies. I'm theoretically a fan of sales tax since it's very fair tax, but very unpopular for other reason (bad for economy). I think average people (no way to avoid tax) should support sales tax for fairness. Negative income tax for equality.
Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by throwawaymobule on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:37PM (#36501203)
The EU has a thing called the clear pricing directive, which mandates all normal taxes be included. (doesn't vibe with laws in 'invitation to treat' countries, but has the same effect)

Still seen pfand deposits charged extra in Germany though.

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by lotsofpulp on Monday June 26, 2023 @04:33PM (#36485440)
That has nothing to do with the existence of a sales tax.

That has to do with the merchant not wanting to show a price label inclusive of all taxes.

There could be a law requiring merchants to display a final price, but I have yet to see a jurisdiction in the US with a law like that so I presume it is not a politically popular enough of an issue.

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by Arrath on Monday June 26, 2023 @04:39PM (#36485529)
I hate the argument that it would be too hard on the merchant to post proper price tags, there are too many different taxes to account for and so on.

Wait a minute, the register/POS figures it out just fine...

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by lotsofpulp on Monday June 26, 2023 @04:48PM (#36485621)
I have never heard of that. The argument is usually if merchant A advertises prices excluding taxes, and merchant B advertises prices including taxes, then merchant B will risk losing out on some customers who go to merchant A because they think buying from merchant A will cost less.

On the internet, taxes are based on shipping address, so there I think it would be impossible for a merchant to show tax inclusive price unless the buyer enters a shipping address first.

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by FredPret on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:50PM (#36486344)
The POS figures it out because it likely has a subscription to a sales tax calculation service like Avalara. US sales taxes are frightfully complicated and change constantly, compliance is not optional, and ignorance is no excuse.

Local/state politicians can raise or lower taxes on all sorts of products with conditions attached for fun / electability.

www.accuratetax.com/blog/top-10-weirdest-sales-tax-laws/

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by eldritch_4ier on Monday June 26, 2023 @01:53PM (#36483242)
It isn't all or nothing. Imagine the government we could have if we all paid 90% in taxes - except I don't want that. I don't even want the kind of government that needs a budget of 40% of my income.

If you live in a rural area, the government needs a budget to repair infra and run a few programs, it doesn't need the budget of NYC. Likewise, a government that lacks a sales tax mechanism doesn't "need to get the money elsewhere", it can simply go without and adjust it's services accordingly.

Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by anon291 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @01:43AM (#36489298)
Well my county raised it's property taxes and now can't spend the money so is offering opt in discounts to those in the know (i.e. the well connected). Completely perverse misappropriation of funds
Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by teawrecks on Monday June 26, 2023 @02:54PM (#36484130)
Sales tax disproportionately impacts the lower class. If I had the choice between no income tax vs no sales tax, I'd take no sales tax.
Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by hellojesus on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:17PM (#36485978)
It only does so if the sales tax itself is regressive. The entire point of excise taxes is to be avoidable through conscious consumption. Heavy sales taxes on luxury goods are better than income taxes because it ensures anyone can avoid them by not spending but also ensures luxury good consumption merits disproportionate societal funding.
Re:Oregon Finally Legalizes Pumping Your Own Gas After 72 Years by lionelholt on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:37PM (#36527104)
Taxing FOOD is always regressive.