Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by x86x87 on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:17PM
(#36452911)
What is Cameron going to say? Seriously, short of questioning their practices and virtue signaling this whole thing is worth close to zero.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by corinroyal on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:40PM
(#36453173)
Right, who wants to hear the opinion of a leader in the field? Virtue signaling is whatever I want it to mean.
Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by x86x87 on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:05PM
(#36453434)
It's not about hearing from thr guy. It's about asking: what does this add?
Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by corinroyal on Friday June 23, 2023 @08:57PM
(#36454311)
Did you even watch the interviews? Cameron pointed out that the safety record for these kind of craft is perfect until today, that these subs are a known quanity, that he and others warned OceanGate against using carbon fiber because it's a laminate that delaminates and fails catastrophically with no warning, and that Cameron knew of the implosion the day it happened. All quite newsworthy.
Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by parl_match on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:45PM
(#36453228)
> virtue signaling
The virtue of testing, certification, and solid design goes well beyond "signalling", when an expert in the field raises their concern.
"virtue signaling" is a mean-nothing phrase
Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by shawn-butler on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:53PM
(#36453315)
Virtue signaling is hardly a “mean-nothing” phrase.
But most people confuse virtue signaling (attempting to fit in by saying the right things) with moral grandstanding (garnering attention)[0]. Which behavior Cameron is engaging here is for the reader to judge.
Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by jrflowers on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:48PM
(#36453261)
Right? What could someone that’s only been to the Titanic 33 times know about submarines? That’s not even three dozen.
Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by x86x87 on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:04PM
(#36453419)
Those two are othogonal. I've been to the Grand Canyon a couple dozen times in my life. Does that make me a geologist?
Re:James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speakin...
by mulmen on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:09PM
(#36453472)
> Does that make me a geologist?
No, that makes you a tourist. If someone falls off an observation platform I'm sure you are qualified to offer some insight.
James Cameron is a legitimate submariner. He is in a more exclusive club than the astronauts who walked on the moon.