News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @09:01AM (#364276)
Equal rights? sure. But is it really that much of a big deal to just call it something other than 'marriage'?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ivankirigin on Friday November 14, 2008 @09:41AM (#364311)
The way to phrase your suggestion: marriage is a cultural institution, not civic. There shouldn't be laws about cultural institutions.

People should just do whatever they want.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @09:50AM (#364317)
Yeah it's all well and good to say you should be able to do what you want, but you have to take responsibility for society as a whole. Is poligamy valid in law? not here and rightly so I'd say. Also, it's just not very nice to hijack words.

It's like people who call HTML a programming language.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Retric on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:11AM (#364338)
What's wrong with poligamy? I am all for protecting the young, but WTF do you care what three forty year old people do in their own home?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:28AM (#364356)
Sorry perhaps I should have been clearer. I think there is something wrong about "marrying" multiple people at the same time. What you want to do in your own home is up to you.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by abstractbill on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:47AM (#364386)
I guess I'm not seeing what impact marriage has on society as a whole - can you elaborate?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:59AM (#364400)
Well I'd say to abolish marriage would be a big mistake for society. For me the main function of marriage is to provide the optimum situation for bringing up kids, as well as promoting monogamy and faithfulness which are IMHO good for society.

I think hijacking the word to mean other things muddies and confuses things for society, when there's actually an opportunity to use a new word to mean marriage between a same sex couple.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tdavis on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:24PM (#364515)
...provide the optimum situation for bringing up kids...

The fact that roughly 50% of marriages end in divorce (at least in the U.S.) makes whether or not marriages create said optimum situation the decision of a rounding error, more or less.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by abstractbill on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:13AM (#364420)
Also: As I understand it, marriage used to mean something more akin to ownership, before women got more equal rights. So the definition has already changed once. If that change was ok, why is another change not ok?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by abstractbill on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:07AM (#364413)
For me, marriage is something more personal - something a couple does because they want to let each other, and the rest of the world, know they're committed.

To be fair, I guess I can't say for sure what I think about whether marriage is important to kids until I have some of my own.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by wensing on Saturday November 15, 2008 @11:22PM (#365769)
What is the difference between a father and a mother?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:41AM (#364454)
This is the fundamental conflict here. Liberals look at marriage and see something people do to be happy. Telling some people they can't marry and be happy is just mean! They fail to see the deeper consequences of messing with tradition.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by abstractbill on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:54AM (#364472)
Yes, I think that's exactly right. To elaborate, I see the attitude of not wanting to mess with tradition as being the same attitude that used to make people say "if God wanted us to fly he would have given us wings".

Perhaps messing with tradition is risky, as was trying to fly. But I'm ok with that.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by scott_s on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:01PM (#364478)
So what are the deeper consequences of allowing homosexual couples to legally marry?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:20PM (#364511)
It devalues real marriage. The consequences will be much the same as past developments that devalued marriage as an institution and an oath, for examples no-fault divorce and much public welfare. One can reasonably anticipate more out of wedlock births and more divorce.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by scott_s on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:49PM (#364634)
Just to be clear, you're seriously arguing that homosexual marriage will lead to more out of wedlock births and divorce among homosexual couples?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Retric on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:08AM (#364414)
Honestly that seems more like a function of a church than a government. But, how does using that word to talk about other arrangements promote monogamy / faithfulness? I mean less than half the people getting married today in the US are going to stay that way for the rest of their life and in many of those that don't get divorced one or both partners are going to get some on the side so I don't think the word really does much at this point.

PS: A lot of people stay married to the end because one spouse kills the other is that a benefit?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:17PM (#364505)
There's nothing suboptimal about a stable same-sex family for raising children. If you want the law to maximize benefits for children, outlaw divorce.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by run4yourlives on Friday November 14, 2008 @03:38PM (#364751)
I wouldn't go that far. That may be the party line of the day but in my mind, it's clear that a child benefits best from having 1 female parent and 1 male parent, who are committed to raising that child within a stable family environment.

Yes this means I consider same sex families and single parent families "sub optimal". No, I would not suggest for a second that having a child requires "optimal" conditions.

I grew up in basically a single parent family. There are a lot of things I know I would have been able to benefit from (that I've learned and am learning along the way) had this not been the case.

We need to stop pretending that every different way of raising a child somehow produces the same results. At the same time we need to realize nobody is able to provide the optimal conditions all of the time.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Friday November 14, 2008 @06:38PM (#364961)
I'm really looking for evidence, or even compelling anecdotes, for why this "kids need men and women" concept is valid. What does a kid get from a male parent that they can't get from a female parent?

Note that seventeen comments after you make this case, when I concede some obscure point about the value of men or women in parenting, I'm just going to come back at you and say that this is really just evidence that we should ban divorce, like Ireland once did. What it has to do with gay marriage, I don't know.

However much we lack strong heterosexual families, we're more awash in mediocre heterosexual families, and far more disturbed by unplanned single-parent families. You will have a hard time saying that a child will do better in a loving two-parent gay family than in the median family in the US.

Is it possible that children will, for a variety of reasons, some of then intrinsic and some of them extrinsic (such as societal pressure against homosexual parents --- the same arguments that might be marshalled against racially diverse couples), do marginally better in the Ozzie and Harriet family of the '50s than in the Ozzie and Ozzie family of the '020s. I concede the last point you just made, up front. But that argument doesn't preclude my argument, which is that availability of loving gay couples to raise wanted children will be a net benefit for society and for children.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by run4yourlives on Friday November 14, 2008 @07:26PM (#365016)
It's really not that hard to find. Here's the first link after searching: "Influence of fathers". Lot's of supporting citations.

http://www.civitas.org.uk/hwu/fathers.php

You will have a hard time saying that a child will do better in a loving two-parent gay family than in the median family in the US.

Which is why I'm specifically not saying that. In fact, this is what I said: No, I would not suggest for a second that having a child requires "optimal" conditions.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Friday November 14, 2008 @07:38PM (#365021)
Much of "influence of fathers" stuff is really talking about the implications of living in:

* single parent homes

* poor single parent homes

* poor and middle-class single parent homes where the single parent works full-time and has less influence over their children

* poor single parents homes in cultures that overtly disrespect fatherhood and implicitly promote weak family structures

I grant you immediately that it's not optimal to be raised in single-parent households --- with the obvious caveat that you have to control for income, culture, setting, and atypically excellent parents that pull it off anyways.

It looks like you & I agree more than we disagree.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by sanj on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:58PM (#365131)
My kid has three parents. At least two and a half. His stepmom is a loving, nurturing and influential piece of his life.

And he kicks ass: he's smart (probably smarter than me), well-liked, well-adjusted, confident and happy.

Seriously, at six he already rocks. I honestly think he's doing better than if me and his mom were together.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @02:12PM (#364665)
"There's nothing suboptimal about a stable same-sex family for raising children."

Seriously? You don't see any value in having both a male parent and a female parent?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Friday November 14, 2008 @03:10PM (#364720)
Well, I'm a male parent in a stable, conventionally-married Catholic two-parent family. Do my kids get value from being raised by Erin? Yes. For one thing, they eat yogurt; for another thing, they can dress themselves. Do they get value from me? Yes. For instance, I am good at making pancakes.

Is there some huge man-woman socio-cultural hoo-hah I'm missing about what our relationship imparts on our children that would be dramatically different if I was replaced with an equally loving woman? Perhaps the pancakes would become crepes (though I'm good at that too). The whole of western civilization shudders.

There might be a real argument you have to make, axod, but you have to actually make it. Innuendo doesn't cut it.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:03PM (#364844)
What???

Look into how badly boys do at school when there teachers are female - or how badly girls do when their teachers are men. The evidence is that neither do well in those circumstances.

Women and men are very very very different thank goodness. If you're missing out on either of them, you're missing out on a complete other world.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by azanar on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:25PM (#364871)
Source, please.

Just from my own anecdotal evidence, my ability to learn from a teacher was based far more on their knowledge and passion than their genitalia.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:32PM (#364875)
Erm. So you believe the only difference between women and men is their genitalia? What planet are you from? You've never seen any evidence of their thought processes being different, their completely different logic, social skills, spacial awareness etc?

I'm sorry but if you believe that you're blind, or really haven't lived.

Your statement sums up what is wrong with the political correctness/equality mob. Men and women are not equal. They will never be. Thank goodness. Celebrate the differences. Embrace them. Don't just blindly pretend they don't exist.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:57PM (#364903)
You were asked for evidence for an assertion you made that boys behave worse in classes with female teachers, and that girls behave worse in classes with male teachers. Put up or shut up, axod.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @06:14PM (#364922)
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14546994/?GT1=8404

http://www.menteach.org/news/its_not_who_but_how_boys_are_ta...

http://www.nowpublic.com/world/boys-taught-men-do-better-stu...

http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2008/sep/30/primaryschoo...

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/5294854.stm

"A study of 25,000 pupils by Stanford University economist Thomas Dee found children did 4% better in tests when their teachers were of the same sex"

"In general, girls learned more with female teachers and boys with male teachers"

"A large fraction of boys' dramatic underperformance in reading is linked to the fact that their reading teachers are overwhelmingly female," Dee concludes.

There are a large number of similar studies with similar results.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Friday November 14, 2008 @06:19PM (#364930)
Think you might be able to do better than one "controversial" study published by the conservative Hoover Institution by a visiting Swarthmore associate professor, an unpublished survey taken by a private consultancy in the UK, and an opinion poll in the UK?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @06:21PM (#364935)
Well, you seem to want to believe women and men are exactly the same, so you go on believing that.

My experience, including my kids experience of various teachers, is that they are not.

Of course it's a "controversial" study - it highlights differences between the sexes. Which isn't "cool" in this politically correct age.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Friday November 14, 2008 @06:33PM (#364957)
That's not an argument; it's just circumstantial ad hominem. I could advance my argument against you the same way by saying you sound awfully threatened by women and gay people.

The claim you're citing is surprising not only because it defies conventional wisdom (which it does), but also implies that whole of the American educational system is built on an easily-corrected inefficiency. Why can't you marshall better evidence for your extraordinary claim? Why don't you have a better source than an untenured Swarthmore professor writing in a journal with dubious peer review?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by wensing on Saturday November 15, 2008 @11:56PM (#365791)
Are you conceding or just ignoring axod's point that men and women are different in more ways than anatomical?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Sunday November 16, 2008 @02:29AM (#365866)
When you or axod give me a relevant significant non-physical way that men and women are different, I'll address it. I chose to address the specific, relevant, wrong point he offered as an alternative.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ram1024 on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:14AM (#364423)
promoting monogamy and faithfulness?

one needs a legal binding contract for these things? i mean seriously. this is adult stuff, if "the law" is the only thing preventing you from sleeping around, then you aren't mature enough to be in the kind of relationship that requires it.

and as far as kids are concerned. i highly doubt a legally binding marriage of two people who don't want to be together being forced into raising a kid would create an optimum situation. if they want to be together, they will be. and if they don't, moving on is far healthier.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:17AM (#364426)
"if "the law" is the only thing preventing you from sleeping around, then you aren't mature enough to be in the kind of relationship that requires it."

Right. And the majority of grown adults are not.

Also I think it's a good idea to make breaking up a family hard.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by elai on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:44AM (#364458)
And furthermore, nothing in the law really makes sleeping around "illegal"
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:50AM (#364465)
It was illegal as recently as the 70s in many places. I think it was pretty much everywhere in the 50s. The cops would throw you in the slammer for "carrying on with a married woman."
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:22AM (#364433)
> I guess I'm not seeing what impact marriage has on society as a whole

Are you blind? You haven't noticed that it's ghetto shit-hole everywhere in modern world that stable two parent families aren't the norm? Marriage in its traditional form is an institution arrived at through a Darwinian process of cultural selection. It has been proven by time to be the best way to further a society. Messing with it is extremely dangerous.

Cultural conservatism is much like environmentalism. You just don't want to go blindly messing around with complex natural systems. The consequences are usually bad.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by geebee on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:45PM (#364543)
I upmodded you, though I completely disagree with what you just said.

For starters, monogamy in highly socially stratified societies is a very rare social phenomenon. You might want to check out "The Moral Animal" for some discussion of this. The line I remember: "socially stratified monogamous cultures are the true freaks of nature" (paraphrasing here, but I'm close).

However, they do tend to be the norm among highly prosperous and free societies, which takes us to your second point...

Haven't you noticed the strong correlation between wealth and freedom and gay rights? Look who is for gay marriage and who is against it. Genentech, Google, and Apple were were very high profile donors against Prop 8. This isn't just a San Francisco leftist coalition - we're talking the biggest, heaviest hitters in the most innovative fields in America.

I agree with you that Scandanavian countries are lauded a bit too much by the left... but let's compare these economies (where gay rights are supported strongly) with the cultural and economic environment in regions where they are not... oh, say, Afghanistan?

Even in the US, the regions that support gay marriage tend to be attracting the best companies with their top notch workforce. They companies come to them, not the other way around. The regions that don't are still wondering what low skilled factory they're going to be able to attract to replace the textile mill that closed in the seventies.

Seems to me like this one is pretty obvious.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by while on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:17PM (#365137)
Some people compare gay rights with slavery (which I think is a bit of a stretch) and argue that though the majority of the population thought slavery was ok back then, it didn't make it right. That's certainly true, but one must also realize that the "wealthy and free" were big supporters of slavery.

The point is, being wealthy and free does not give one a more "correct" opinion than one who is not.

And I don't see a strong correlation between "wealth and freedom and gay rights". I see a strong correlation between gay rights and political image.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Saturday November 15, 2008 @12:41PM (#365404)
> strong correlation between wealth and freedom and gay rights

The upper classes carry themselves on with bourgeois family traditions whatever the legal environment. They don't personally see the disastrous consequences of family breakdown because their families remain whole, so they don't give a second thought to liberalizing laws. In poorer areas, the breakdown of family values is a real pressing issue. People see the social catastrophe around them and recognize the further threats.

Wealthier areas are more socially liberal because it's personally irrelevant to them. The areas are wealthy usually because of strongly bourgeois family traditions. Poorer areas are usually more socially fragile.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by geebee on Saturday November 15, 2008 @05:07PM (#365566)
I assure you that families break down in upper class environments. I went to a very expensive episcopal school, and when I was making plans to play tennis with a classmate, he asked "should I call you at your mom's house or your dad's house?" I told him they lived in the same house. "Really?" he said. The assumption was that they were divorced. In one grade, 22 of 26 students were from divorced households.

Now, that doesn't mean you're wrong about the social catastrophe that the failure of marriage brings in poor areas - just because wealthy episcopalians get divorced all the time doesn't mean they experience financial disaster when they do. They're well off enough that they can just split into two (or three or four) different households and still have enough to pay the mortgage, fix the car, buy clothes, and take nice vacations.

But I will definitely disagree that they are wealthy because of strongly bourgeois family traditions. Man, that's the last phrase I would use to describe these people.

For the record, I was in the 10% of the class that lived across town, and didn't come from a family with that kind of money - though I would certainly not describe myself as deprived or from a social class that feared financial catastrophe.

By the way - I'm genuinely interested in hearing why you think that gay marriage would be a threat to marriage in poorer areas. I do agree with you that families are important and should be protected - but why from gays? That one doesn't really make sense to me. It seems like poverty, layoffs, long shifts, poor schools, and so forth threaten families. Adultery and constant conflict (I'm not talking about the truly criminal violence, just the way people can be constantly fighting) can also obviously wreck a marriage - though I think that's often a symptom of the things I listed above.

Gays getting married? Seems like the last thing I'd worry about. This is why the anti prop-8 crowd is so frustrated to see the Catholic, Mormon, and Evangelical churches so actively working to ban gay marriage. It's like: people are hurting, and this is where you put your resources?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by azanar on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:13PM (#364854)
Two things:

1. You seem to have settled on a root cause ghetto shit-holes being the lack of social and cultural bonding rituals between one member of each gender. Generally, I look at cultures like that and see things like oppressive governments, lack of stable, productive economies, and the absence of anything resembling education causing strife? I haven't seen anything to suggest that oppression comes from the lack of observing ritualistic pair-bonds. Perhaps you have data to prove me wrong?

2. Marriage is not a natural system. Nor is culture, except for the tendency for humans to form them. That they manifest at all seems to be a product of human nature; how they manifest seems much more based on environment and random variation. Otherwise, our culture would be indistinguishable from that of everyone elses. Or are you suggesting that we are still in the process of cultural selection, and ours will inevitably prevail?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Retric on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:35AM (#364450)
For most of human history people married who their parents told them to. Calling what we do now traditional marriage is silly because it's been changing fairly rapidly over time. Look at marriage in nortic countries and you will see a large separation between having kids and getting married yet they are doing better than most of Europe and the US on most measurements of heath, happiness and economic growth.

Looking back it's hard to extrapolate the value of "traditional family values" because we have a lower crime rate, better educated population, and a better economy now than we did back with they where more common.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:46AM (#364460)
> because it's been changing fairly rapidly over time

No, it's been changing fairly rapidly for less than 100 years, and usually with serious unforeseen consequences.

> Look at marriage in nortic countries

I'm tired of hearing about nordic countries. First, they aren't nearly as great as the pom-pom crowd thinks. If you do an apples to apples comparison of middle class whites in northern US states to nordic countries, they're really not so fantastic. And there is plenty of hand-wringing about social degradation in Sweden. They're, what, one generation in to their shift away from more conservative arrangements? Give it time and you'll see problems.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Retric on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:06PM (#364482)
No, it's been changing fairly rapidly for less than 100 years, and usually with serious unforeseen consequences.

Woman's rights have been on the rise for much longer than 100 years. (I hear they can vote, own property, and even work in the theater.)

I used to be a crime to have sex outside of marriage but that's been on the decline for a long time.

There used to be limits on who could marrie based on class and or race lines. (Duke's don't get hitched with just anyone you know.)

Dowery's used to be common but now it's mostly just the wives family paying for more of the wedding. (This trend has been going on for a while.)

Divorce was introduced by one of the Henry's (he killed most of his other wives but their was one he liked.)

I could go on but most of these trends are a lot older than 100 years. One of the few things that does not really seem to change is infidelity. Genetic tests have shown that married women tend to have about ~20% of their kids from someone other than their husband. This does not seem to have changed much over time.

PS: Nordic marriage traditions go all the way back to the vikings, but they don't look much like "Christian" family values.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tptacek on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:19PM (#364508)
You forgot to end with ", I assert without evidence".
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Retric on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:01PM (#364476)
Edit: Deleted double post.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ram1024 on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:06AM (#364412)
people should have every right in the world to define their relationship to each other in any manner they like.

the law should simply allow simplification of contract terms should they be required (custody, assets, etc).

the idea that "marriage" is a set legal method that is rigid and unyielding to change is retarded. the concept is so ridiculously outmoded. society and culture have moved on, it's time for "marriage" to get with the program

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:53AM (#364471)
> WTF do you care what three forty year old people do in their own home

Have you read ANYTHING about these polygamous communities? They produce cast off boys and a trickle of 15 year old girls fleeing rape by 50 year old men. I would argue these are long term consequences of polygamy itself, not features of communities that happen to practice it.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by aaronblohowiak on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:47PM (#364545)
I read your argument as: insular religious extremists do bad things! Therefore, we should also deny thinking and responsible adults freedom to live as they please.

If anything, the lesson is that making something illegal pushes it underground, which makes it harder to protect those that may suffer from it in addition to punishing those that would gain from it. This is a lesson demonstrated over and over again -- there are even comments about it in the Tao Te Ching.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:06PM (#364573)
There are of course non-isolated societies in the world that allow polygamy. You wouldn't want to live in any of them.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by aaronblohowiak on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:15PM (#364585)
I'd like you to a cite a source about where I would and would not want to live.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tdavis on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:27PM (#364519)
Anecdotal evidence is my favorite flavor of evidence.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by run4yourlives on Friday November 14, 2008 @03:34PM (#364748)
You're missing his point. That has nothing to do with polygamy and everything to do with being a wacko religious sect.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by RK on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:59PM (#364563)
So you think only gays should have the right of polygamous marriage?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ibsulon on Friday November 14, 2008 @03:25PM (#364739)
I agree. Let's go back to the original definition of marriage.

How much for your daughter?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by gaius on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:59AM (#364474)
Well, that's not strictly true. Marriage is different things to different people. The State, the Church, individuals, all have their own meaning.

To the State, marriage is a mechanism for forming binding contracts to create viable economic units for raising small children. All the stuff the State tacks onto it, like tax breaks, are in support of that primary goal.The State does this because it needs a fresh supply of well-raised kids in order to fulfill its responsibilities, which range from schools to manning the military. In the eyes of the State, if you take the benefits of marriage and don't have kids and raise 'em good, you aren't upholding your end of the bargain.

Equal rights for their own sake is a laudable goal, but someone is going to need to articulate to the State what the benefits to the State of gay marriage are. Once that's done, you'll see some progress.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ivankirigin on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:55PM (#364645)

   forming binding contracts to create viable economic units for raising small children.
The purpose of government is to limit its own power and extinguish violence. Where exactly is that part in the constitution about stepping in to optimize GDP or influence child raising decisions?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by gaius on Friday November 14, 2008 @03:56PM (#364770)
Where is marriage in the Constitution at all? My point stands.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ivankirigin on Friday November 14, 2008 @04:16PM (#364791)
Actually, that is my point.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:15AM (#364424)
> There shouldn't be laws about cultural institutions.

That's a pretty shaky assertion. I doubt there's a society in human history that didn't treat cultural traditions and taboos as law in some form.

Are you for legal incest and sibling marriage?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ivankirigin on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:47AM (#364462)
I'm not going to voice approval for things that are taboo. I am going to stand my ground in claims that there is little benefit in laws about such taboos.

Your examples are debatably child abuse in the likely of troubled pregnancies, and so could reasonable be treated as violence. I'm all for laws against violence.

One take away is that you don't need laws against taboos. They are taboo and so largely self enforcing.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by sethg on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:34AM (#364368)
Saying "a same-sex couple should be allowed all the privileges of a married couple, but please don't call it 'marriage'" is like saying "a woman should be allowed to attend medical school and receive a degree and be licensed to see patients and prescribe medicine and collect insurance reimbursements, but please don't call her a 'doctor'".
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:44AM (#364377)
No, it's not. Female doctors can carry out the same tasks as Male doctors (Give or take).

Gay couples cannot carry out the same tasks as Heterosexual couples.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by swombat on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:05AM (#364411)
Of course they can. Unless you mean that the sanctity of marriage is based on the ability of one party to stick their thing in the other and produce a baby.

What about a marriage between a man and a woman who adopt a child? Are they allowed to be married?

Or are you implying that heterosexual couples raise their children better than homosexual couples? That'd be a pretty tough claim to support.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:13AM (#364422)
Not all heterosexual couples can conceive, but a large number can.

0 homosexual couples can conceive.

I'd also say yes heterosexuals are sure to raise kids better. What could be better than getting both a woman and a mans point of view on the world? :/

Wouldn't you worry if you sent your son to a school where all the teachers were women? I'd say he would be missing out on something.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by DaniFong on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:18PM (#364863)
What do you mean by raising kids better? Single parents and same sex couples can both raise kids extraordinarily well; better than many heterosexual couples. And if this is a statement about averages, it is already generally agreed that restricting individual rights based on the properties of a group are immoral and wrong.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by swombat on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:20AM (#364430)
0 infertile couples can conceive.

Should infertile couples not be allowed to marry?

0 post-menopausal women can conceive.

Should post-menopausal women not be allowed to marry?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:28AM (#364444)
> Should infertile couples not be allowed to marry?

It's not really a marriage, so maybe it should be called something else, just as with homosexual civil unions. But of course there's no way to determine infertility, so it's not practical. It's very practical for homosexuals, though.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by sethg on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:28PM (#364522)
If the purpose of marriage is to encourage procreation, then heterosexually couples who take advantage of the legal benefits of marriage (tax deductions, hospital visitation, Social Security survivor's benefits, etc., etc., etc.) without procreating are freeloaders. So let's amend the laws so that only a heterosexual couple that has produced a child can take advantage of those benefits. (Not adoption, and not artificial insemination by a third-party donor! That's cheating!)

There's a very practical suggestion. If I lived in California I'd be tempted to put it on a referendum and see how many votes it loses by.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by scott_s on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:09PM (#364486)
I think you're the one here who is redefining marriage.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by azanar on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:01PM (#364841)
"I'd also say yes heterosexuals are sure to raise kids better. What could be better than getting both a woman and a mans point of view on the world? :/"

How about the points of view of multiple women and multiple men? You make the mistake here of assuming that there only are two fundamental points of view, delineated by gender, that people are exposed to. By that argument, it should be trivial to map gender to things like political party, religion, or any of a number of other perspectives? That we don't see this suggests your premise is wrong.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:25AM (#364439)
> Unless you mean that the sanctity of marriage is based on the ability of one party to stick their thing in the other and produce a baby.

I would say exactly that. I would even go so far as to say that a marriage where it is known before hand that the heterosexual couple is infertile is not a "real" marriage.

Of course the whole point of marriage is the biological production of the next generation.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Jasber on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:02PM (#364480)
> I would say exactly that. I would even go so far as to say that a marriage where it is known before hand that the heterosexual couple is infertile is not a "real" marriage.

Wow. So a couple that chooses to be married yet chooses no children is also not a "real" marriage?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:04PM (#364481)
I would say that's so.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by scott_s on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:08PM (#364485)
Fantastic. I'll go tell three married couples I know that their marriages are invalid.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by kingkongrevenge on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:12PM (#364491)
Not invalid, just inferior to "real" marriages, which produce biological children.

Again, this is a critical distinction between liberals and conservatives. Liberals are obsessed with making sure everyone feels equal and unoffended. Conservatives do not shy away from the reality that not everyone and everything are of equal value. From the perspective of society a biologically fruitful marriage is a superior thing and deserves special status. Sorry if that hurts feelings.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by abstractbill on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:44PM (#364542)
inferior to "real" marriages, which produce biological children

I don't understand. Do we need more people? Is there a population shortage? Six billion isn't enough for what exactly?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:58PM (#364559)
We're getting a bit into the meaning of life here now surely ;)

I'd say we need more smart people.

It would be scary if the smart people stop having kids. The world would be taken over by stupidity.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by swombat on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:29PM (#364873)
I'd say we need more smart people.

Then I have a simple suggestion based on the same wide-ranging generalisations you base your reasoning on:

Make marriage illegal for all the heterosexual couples who believe that same-sex marriage should be illegal.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by aswanson on Saturday November 15, 2008 @12:20AM (#365159)
Have you read any newspapers lately?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by natch on Friday November 14, 2008 @04:11PM (#364783)
>Conservatives do not shy away from the reality...

Um, Jesus walking on water? Talking snakes? Worshiping a book that condones slavery? Believing that there is a "God" that just popped into being out of nowhere existing beyond time, and that this idea is more likely than the universe just always existing beyond time?

The Branch Davidians called. They want their delusion back.

BTW your comments about liberals don't apply to all of us. I'd be very happy to offend you, and I'm sure it wouldn't be hard, since you seem to be a conservative.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by scott_s on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:16PM (#364499)
No, it doesn't hurt my feelings. I just think the assertion that marriages that produce children are automatically better for society than those that do not is ridiculous.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by natch on Friday November 14, 2008 @04:05PM (#364776)
This is just sad. Go back to reddit, please.

Just because interracial couples can't produce pure-bred babies in the same way as same-race couples, and just as same-sex, infertile, and "mature" (beyond the healthy child bearing years) couples cannot conceive children together in the same way as some people... doesn't mean a tyranny of the majority should have the ability to take away their civil rights.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by josefresco on Friday November 14, 2008 @09:08AM (#364286)
Separate but equal huh? I think I've heard that one before.

The racists of the 60's called, they'd like to work with you and your brilliant ideas.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Maktab on Friday November 14, 2008 @09:37AM (#364309)
Regardless of the merits (or lack thereof) of the parent's argument, your comparison is facile. So-called 'separate but equal' legislation never provided for anything close to legal equality. Civil unions, on the other hand, could provide the same legal rights as marriage.

But that's besides the point. The real story here is that Prop. 8 passed mostly due to the high turnout of African-American voters as a result of Obama's candidacy. As a block, American-Americans tend to vote against gay rights and gay marriage issues, and so the high turnout was what swung the ballot in favour of Prop. 8.

The lesson here should be that the gay community of the US has not done enough to reach out to the African-American community in order to gain greater acceptance and understanding. Despite all the advocacy against white religious conservatives and high-profile court campaigns, there has been precious little effort in convincing voters why they have nothing to fear and why gays should have the right to marry because that would be fair and just.

Until that happens, gay Americans are going to have to be content with winning brief victories through the courts while fearing each and every time the general public is given the chance to have their own say on the issue.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by sethg on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:19PM (#364509)
_Prop. 8 passed mostly due to the high turnout of African-American voters as a result of Obama's candidacy._

Nate Silver of fivethirtyeight.com points out that first-time voters voted against Prop. 8 by 62-38, while experienced voters favored it by 56-44. Therefore, if Obama's candidacy had not boosted turnout, Prop. 8 probably would have passed by an even higher margin.

Yes, black voters voted 70-30 in favor of Prop. 8, but they were only 10% of the electorate, and lots of other demographic subgroups favored it as well. (E.g., 22% of the voters attend church weekly--I bet that 22% includes the vast majority of the black voters--and they favored Prop. 8 by 82-18.) So I think treating the black vote as the reason for Prop. 8's passage is unfair.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Maktab on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:19PM (#364593)
Fair enough, I had not seen Nate Silver's analysis yet before you alerted me to it.

But even if the black vote was not pivotal in this case, Silver's analysis still validates the chief point I was trying to make, which is that support for gay rights amongst African-Americans is frighteningly low and that the gay community's advocates are not doing enough to understand and get the support of the only community in the United States that truly understands what it means to be denied rights that others enjoy.

It doesn't have to be this way.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by sethg on Saturday November 15, 2008 @09:10PM (#365704)
I don't think the historical or current experience of being oppressed automatically makes a person more sympathetic to other oppressed groups. It can just as easily harden a person--"I and my ancestors suffered through X, why should I care about your Y?" So while I agree that the gay community could do a much better job selling gay rights to African-Americans, I wouldn't describe the support level as "frighteningly low".

PS: There's a black church on the south side of Chicago which is unusual, for black churches, because it stands firmly in favor of gay rights. Its pastor, until recently, was a guy named Jeremiah Wright. You may have heard of him.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Maktab on Sunday November 16, 2008 @11:22AM (#366061)
It may not grant you automatic support, but it provides a level of common ground on which you can begin building support. And the stats I've seen are indeed 'frighteningly low'.

As for Wright, I think if we go by the rest of his sermons (which were frequently racist), his support for gay rights is as likely to be because of his desire to be contrarian and controversial as it is due to deep-seated personal convictions.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by mynameishere on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:30AM (#364360)
I suspect that, in general, homosexuals had better prepare themselves for some retrenchment. Their opposition is solidly "multicultural" in flavor, but all of their tactics are essentially of the same sort used against Southerners, viz, to call them "bigots". This will not work against blacks and hispanics, the two groups that will be increasingly important in the future.

Word to the wise: The purpose of the "civil rights" movement is to weaken national unity and destroy traditional culture. That has been its purpose since day one, and the actual rights of man per se do not enter into strategic consideration. When the ruling class has to decide between alienating gays, alienating blacks, and alienating hispanics, it will do the first. When this becomes actual policy is difficult to say, since it isn't a straightforward headcount issue.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by aswanson on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:58PM (#365154)
The purpose of the "civil rights" movement is to weaken national unity and destroy traditional culture. That has been its purpose since day one, and the actual rights of man per se do not enter into strategic consideration. When the ruling class has to decide between alienating gays, alienating blacks, and alienating hispanics, it will do the first. When this becomes actual policy is difficult to say, since it isn't a straightforward headcount issue

How did you come to these conclusions?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @09:35AM (#364307)
They aren't equal. They can never have children naturally.

They should have equal rights in terms of their union, but in terms of procreation and furthering the species etc, how can they?

Racism doesn't really have such an argument does it.

I just don't see why the word matters all that much. Surely as long as you are equal in the eyes of the law, why not have a different word to mean same sex marriage? Then if you say "joe is married" you don't have to ask "to a woman? or another man?".

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by redrobot5050 on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:23AM (#364350)
So should my parents marriage be invalidated, seeing as my mother has undergone menopause, and thus, they can "never have children naturally" anymore? What about anorexia survivors? Malnutrition plays hell with uterine linings. Should we deny them the right to marriage? Is an eating disorder more or less of a 'a choice' than homosexuality in your eyes?

Alan Turing was gay, and never had children. He developed the code-breaking machines that allowed the Allies to win world war 2. Don't think for a second that Churchill being able to read Hitler's mail before Hitler read it didn't "tip the balance".

So it sounds like gay people can further the species without procreation. In fact, I'd argue that smart people (gay OR straight) are better off not having children until their career has 'peaked'. For the truly brilliant -- the Turings and Einsteins of the world -- a child is not going to be "their greatest accomplishment".

Seriously, a gay man basically did more for Western civilization than you or I or any Veteran still alive has. He was shamed into killing himself because of his sexual orientation. You'd really object to his happiness?

sigh. I'm going to stop here before I pull a Godwin.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:31AM (#364362)
You're starting to distort everything I said.

I don't care if gay people wish to have even more rights than me. Fine. Just don't mess about with a word that has been defined clearly for a long time.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by redrobot5050 on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:08PM (#364578)
They're NOT messing with a word that's been defined for clearly a long time. I don't think they'd define the pleas for equality before the law to be considered "messing" or "trouble making".

You DO realize that the definition of marriage has changed several times, right? Women are no longer property owned by their fathers until transferred into the possession of another Man. Being of different race no longer means you can't get married, either.

Furthermore, we re-define words all the time in the computer field. Think about how the definition of "fast" gets redefined every 18 months to to years. And how what was "fast" is now "slow".

Hands down you cannot string a rational argument against gay marriage because there isn't one. Its based on cultural fears, and intolerance. You're on the losing side of history, next to the Mississippi state police that physically assaulted my father and his friends for helping black people register to vote in early 60s. Next to KKK. And the confederates, and so on. Have fun explaining to your children or your children's children, who will grow up with gay marriage, how you were the bigot.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:46PM (#364626)
"Think about how the definition of "fast" gets redefined every 18 months to to years. And how what was "fast" is now "slow"."

What?? Do you know what definition means? The definition of fast has never changed. Absolute values you might be measuring have.

Hopefully my children won't grow up with gay "marriage", they'll grow up with "marriage", and "gay marriage/union/whatever they want to call it". That's an important distinction.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by redrobot5050 on Friday November 14, 2008 @04:16PM (#364793)
How? How is that an important distinction? Do you honestly think your right to be with someone of the opposite sex is somehow better than someone's desire to be with someone of the same sex, and if so, on what rational grounds?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Saturday November 15, 2008 @03:41AM (#365245)
Yes it is better in the context of creating new life.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by natch on Friday November 14, 2008 @04:35PM (#364826)
So would you also deny that other words have meanings that have evolved and or changed over the years?

You keep using the word "gay" -- are you not aware that that word has changed its meaning?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by natch on Saturday November 15, 2008 @02:48PM (#365487)
Crickets...
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by natch on Friday November 14, 2008 @04:21PM (#364803)
Defined how?

* A nun is married to God (in some religions)

* A priest is married to God (in some religions)

* A man can be married to more than one woman (in some religions)

* A woman can be married to more than one man (maybe in darkest Africa, who's to say?)

* A man can be married to a woman

* A man can be married to a tree (in India, true)

* A man can be married to a man

* A woman can be married to a woman

Why are you so sensitive about words, anyway?

Gay was defined for a long time to mean happy.

Conservative used to mean saving and preserving and conserving, instead of spending, destroying, and squandering.

Faithful used to mean good, just, and moral, instead of vituperative, devious, dim-witted, and delusional.

Words get redefined all the time. Get over it.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by natch on Friday November 14, 2008 @04:27PM (#364811)
You distort things enough yourself.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Retric on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:16AM (#364345)
Two women could have children from their own DNA with a little genetic engineering or just cloning. Plenty of heterosexual coupples can't have children do you want to forbid them getting married? How about if they decide not to can they get married?

PS: I honestly just get creeped out when people start talking about labels as if a word by it's self means something.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by redrobot5050 on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:27AM (#364355)
Yeah. I'm all about the 'traditional marriage' myself. You know, where my lord's regent picks my wife from one of the other serf's, pays her father a small dowry, lets my lord enact Prima Nocte, and then unloads her onto me, where she's my property to do what I wish with.

(NOT).

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by axod on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:29AM (#364358)
A father and his daughter could probably have a healthy child with a bit of help from science, but that wouldn't make it a good idea would it.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Retric on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:44AM (#364378)
Ok, that's creepy, but if they are 30 and 50 what's the problem? My point is just because I don't like something does not mean I get to stop people who are not hurting me from doing it.

There was some story about people who where both adopted got married and then found out they where siblings. And yea it's creepy, but while I would be ok forbidding them from having children (for the public good) I don't see the value in forcing them to break up. And, even forbidding something on genetic grounds becomes a slippery slope problem because it's one step from their to sterilizing people.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by astine on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:32AM (#364364)
'Equal,' or 'identical?' The former implies an equation in terms of absolute 'goodness,' while the later merely implies a concurrence of kind.

If you are going to rag on same sex 'marriage' as not being truly 'marriage' for any of the reasons you state, then you also have to discount many heterosexual 'marriages' as well.

The problem is that for one half of our society, the meaning of the term has changed radically over the past century and for the other half it hasn't changed a wit. As a result, the laws have grown confusing and contradictory and there is no longer any easy way to reconcile the terms.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by natch on Friday November 14, 2008 @04:14PM (#364788)
Interracial couples can never have pure-race children naturally. So would you say that makes them different enough that they should not be eligible for marriage?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by dgordon on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:57PM (#365153)
So instead of marriage, let's call it...butt-buddies.

Besides, why do you care so much whether Joe is married to a woman, a man, a genderless entity, or no one at all?