Re:Key Techdirt SOPA/PIPA Post Censored By Bogus DMCA Takedo...
by wmf on Monday February 27, 2012 @10:25PM
(#3641749)
The headline seems a little alarmist; the article in question wasn't "censored" completely, it was just removed from Google. (I'll preemptively disagree with the argument that if a page is not Googleable it doesn't exist.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Key Techdirt SOPA/PIPA Post Censored By Bogus DMCA Takedo...
by irons on Monday February 27, 2012 @11:24PM
(#3641877)
The fact that you had to employ the modifier "completely" to make your point suggests that the headline's use of the verb "censor" was defensible.
Re:Key Techdirt SOPA/PIPA Post Censored By Bogus DMCA Takedo...
by Groxx on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @12:01AM
(#3641963)
You just rationalized all hyperbole.
Their post was obliterated. Could not be found. Ceased to exist. The DMCA take-down notice removed TechDirt from Google. TechDirt was erased.
All completely true if you don't require modifiers to be stated. I'd prefer that HN doesn't turn into a tabloid.
Re:Key Techdirt SOPA/PIPA Post Censored By Bogus DMCA Takedo...
by irons on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @12:15AM
(#3641999)
This is a wonderful linguistic cul-de-sac you've steered into, but the fact remains that "censor" means "suppress"; it does not mean "eradicate". When the government of China or Acela's internet filtering vendor block a site, they are censoring it, without removing it from the internet. The same principle applies here.
Re:Key Techdirt SOPA/PIPA Post Censored By Bogus DMCA Takedo...
by Groxx on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @12:01PM
(#3643849)
Indeed - it was only eradicated from Google's search results. My point is that that's a modifier, therefore the use of it is defensible...? That's an objective claim that's completely ridiculous when taken to other contexts.
Whether it's alarmist / excessive is subjective. And, since either would be technically correct, it probably has more to do with implied meanings or the common use of a word, and not the dictionary definition. Their usage of it is certainly defensible, but that has little to do with whether or not a modifier would make it more accurate.
Re:Key Techdirt SOPA/PIPA Post Censored By Bogus DMCA Takedo...
by rhizome on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @12:23AM
(#3642018)
No, not "all hyperbole." Just the title.
Re:Key Techdirt SOPA/PIPA Post Censored By Bogus DMCA Takedo...
by Natsu on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @01:56AM
(#3642202)
I think we agree that the people who issued this DMCA notice have taken action to suppress content they find objectionable. I can also understand that 'censorship' is a Bad Thing (TM) and people want to limit its use to only the most extreme cases.
But that leaves a problem: what do you call behavior like this?