News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by eigenspace on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @05:59PM (#36411285)
I wish Lemmy's default design was more of a copy of old.reddit.com. For me, that design was better than both HackerNews' design and way better than the current default look of Lemmy instances.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by tester457 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:03PM (#36411965)
Same. However it seems most people don't like the old.reddit look, only 4% of redditors use it. Most people are content with the slow bloated new reddit.

When redditors talked about what sites to migrate to most of them preferred the modern interfaces over text based ones like tildes.net.

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by Narishma on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:39PM (#36412310)
How many even know that old.reddit exists?
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by aerio on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @08:46PM (#36412880)
5%
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by tuchsen on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @08:01PM (#36412488)
I wonder how much this has to do with the devices people use to access Reddit. I always preferred the old.reddit site on the desktop. Although when I'm on my phone, it gave me eye strain to try and read the tiny font, and pinch/zooming all the time is super annoying. The newer Reddit web app was still incredibly annoying, given all the "install the desktop app" prompts, and it's general lagginess, but allowing me to just flick scroll through articles was actually better for me.

Lemmy's the same way for me, hate the UI on the desktop but it's fine on my phone.

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by Gigachad on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @09:18PM (#36413139)
I don’t think there is anything visually wrong with the new reddit. My issue is with how slow and buggy it is. And all the dark patterns and engagement tricks it’s full of.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by handsclean on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @08:51PM (#36412912)
4% usage doesn’t mean only 4% prefer it. It’s a buried setting that’s default off, that alone makes the choice for ballpark 80%. It doesn’t support mobile, which drops another huge segment, and it doesn’t support “new” features like images and tags, and Reddit spent years aggressively pushing everybody to switch. I wouldn’t be surprised if 4% is the vast majority of Redditors who actually tried both and had the opportunity to choose.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by JamesBell on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @10:17PM (#36413571)
I wonder what % of content is generated by old.reddit.com users, and what % from third party apps too. Figures not mentioned by Reddit mgmt so I'm assuming they don't favor their desires to end them.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by dublinben on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @09:34AM (#36418244)
This is highly subreddit dependent. Those numbers might be true for larger, image-based communities. For smaller, discussion based communities old is more like 60-70% of new, among desktop traffic. Mobile web and apps still make up the majority now, but that’s true of pretty much everything.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by rglullis on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:07PM (#36412007)
It's quite easy to change the css from Lemmy, and from a quick look their HTML is reasonably clean. I'm tempted to attempt it.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by chaosjevil on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @10:24PM (#36413610)
It's clean because they don't need to obfuscate anything to avoid people blocking ads.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by dirkt on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @11:45PM (#36414158)
Please do, a more condensed variant like old.reddit.com would be really appreciated by me and probably many other people.

I have also started looking at it, by $REAL_JOB doesn't leave that much time.

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by gerdesj on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:18PM (#36412099)
old.reddit.com looks rather dated to this 53 y/o bloke. Very busy too. I don't actually care because content is king and presentation is not but it would be nice if it looks good. Modern Reddit looks OK to me but I have recently deleted all comments I've ever made on Reddit and also my account. I will keep the mail alias alive for a while to see what shite turns up.

For me Reddit was a new and vaguely exciting thing once and I used it for around a decade and have now discarded it. I've dumped the Register too after around 20 years. I have no idea why I still have a /. account! that's next along with Facebook.

Back in the day I was asked to investigate this new fangled world wide web thing by an org with loads of cash and twiddling thumbs and I reported back it looked a lot like Gopher and WAIS but different. I might have also mentioned Teletext too.

I'm not an evangelist worth listening to but I've been here before. Just allow yourself to destroy accounts on systems that are no longer useful or productive anymore.

Move on.

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by lmm on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:25PM (#36412184)
> old.reddit.com looks rather dated to this 53 y/o bloke. Very busy too. I don't actually care because content is king and presentation is not but it would be nice if it looks good.

Displaying actual content seems to look "dated" and "busy" by today's aesthetic standard. Do you have any example of a UI that has the information density of old.reddit.com but "looks good" by your standards?

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by spiralx on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @05:37AM (#36416393)
My personal user style for old.reddit.com extends the comment width to the whole screen and moves the horizontal action list for each comment to align with the username and the right side of the screen, while changing the font to one I find easier to read as well as bumping the font size and line-spacing, as well as generally adding some small amounts of space and colour here and there to help separate elements.

It's evolved over a few years now and the combination of changes means that I don't generally lose much in the way of content density in the general case of a post with mostly small to medium comments where the increased body text size is balanced with the removal of the space for the action bar. And it was even better before I got a bit older and decided that I should bump the font size up another pixel to make things easier on my eyes :)

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by raincole on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @05:56AM (#36416539)
I don't want that much information density. That's the whole point. Information density is not net positive.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by przmk on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @06:55AM (#36416914)
It depends. I think a link aggregator needs that much density. The Reddit re-design makes it look like 9GAG and prioritizes mindlessly scrolling through memes.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by TX81Z on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @10:09PM (#36413507)
Bluesky is a lot of fun in that “great party before the trolls show up and shit on it all” way. Try it out, as a fellow old timer it’s all about finding communities before the turn to shit and moving on. Totally agree!
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by courseofaction on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:22PM (#36412138)
I am a fan of the software but I agree that the default design is horrible, it would probably serve Lemmy to get that addressed ASAP to get more people in the door.

It's open source, any UI/UX people spot some low-hanging fruit?

https://github.com/LemmyNet/

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by glenstein on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:27PM (#36412197)
Lemmy has a built-in capability to cycle through various themes, but unfortunately all this themes seemed preserve the basic spacing and overall structure. I do think customizability with themes would hold huge potential if it had any true variety to it, along the lines of, say, winamp skins or something. I don't mean that example too literally, only to illustrate how much unrealized potential there is for themes, which are already built in, to truly add value.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by asoneth on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @11:00PM (#36413856)
Judging solely by the desktop screenshot [1] it doesn't seem like a bad first pass but there are a few things that could be improved:

What jumped out first is the irregular post layout. For example the up/down arrows are farther from the image than the title, possibly to accommodate large, centered numbers. The titles can be at least three rows tall which results in posts that are quite different in height. The post images are all different heights and widths. Some users also have large circular icons that increase the height of the row while others have no icons. The other icon buttons are all slightly different sizes and appear to be from different sets. Finally, the content appears to be laid out a little haphazardly: why is the star icon next to the comments but the book icon next to the post's age? Why is the article's domain sandwiched between the community name and the age, and do we really need to show subdomains? (As an alternative, you could truncate large numbers with postfix magnitude to shrink their padding, make all images the same height/width, truncate long titles to two rows, make all icons the same optical size, and collapse the metadata to a single row such as: "From domain.org · Submitted by @name to community 11h ago · # Comments · star".)

The gray text on gray background results in poor contrast which makes it harder to read than necessary. This is especially apparent in the Posts/Comments and Subscribed/All toggles as the unselected option looks entirely disabled.

Finally, I'm not sure it works to put so many communities in one large block of wrapping rows. It may fit more content on the screen but makes for a loud block of bright green text that is attention-grabbing but hard to scan, especially since the list doesn't seem to have a visible sort order. It's also driving me crazy that the communities with icons result in inconsistent leading between rows. In that case I might start by finding out whether the page really needs to show six dozen subscriptions in the sidebar in the first place.

[1] https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LemmyNet/joinlemmy-site/ma...

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by class4behavior on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:31PM (#36412238)
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by neardeaf on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @08:20PM (#36412664)
This already looks way better
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by ronsor on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:33PM (#36412256)
In my opinion, the old Voat [0] design was the best one for a Reddit-style website.

[0] https://web.archive.org/web/20160216023609/https://voat.co/

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by jacooper on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @08:24PM (#36412700)
No, please no, if Lemmy looked like old.reddit no body will ever use it. There are custom themes, but it should be never the default.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by xigoi on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:00AM (#36415298)
Old Reddit is not responsive.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by mariusor on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:59AM (#36415716)
I work on a link aggregator that uses a more minimalist design. An example instance is at https://brutalinks.tech
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by alex3305 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @07:06AM (#36416965)
Completely agree. More so because font sizing is IMHO all over the place. I'm using my OS and browsers' zoom because I'm visually impaired and than Lemmy is kind of a mess.
Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by Okawari on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @09:28AM (#36418172)
Lemmy supports alternate frontends.

I'm kinda intrigued by https://fedibb.ml/, which replicates the default phpBB theme.

Re:Welcome Lemmy.world by polski-g on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:16PM (#36423015)
Its dead, Jim.