I can foresee a situation where cabs start to favor only bookings/hailings from this app, since the fares (i.e. people getting into the cab) clearly have money (since they have a smartphone) and will hopefully tip better.
The rest of us schmucks trying to hail a cab the old-fashioned way will be out of luck, since all the cabs will be waiting to pick up a smartphone fare.
Less usefully, but along the same lines you still see doorman blowing whistles to try and get taxis to come down a side street.
I'm not sure how this translates into a solution for your problem, but I think you need to consider some hybrid meatspace / internet mechanism.
"Outdated thinking" might mean NIMBY nuke plant aversion, or it might mean infant cannibalism--without providing more information we have no idea what you're talking about.
For a TL;DR: you can't book yellow cabs in New York- the only way to get one is by hailing one on the street. I think that is an outdated and inefficient method, and think that there ought to be change.
There is even an online service and app which claims to do it: http://itaxinyc.com/ (competitor to you?)
There's nothing wrong with those services- indeed, as I mention in the article, it's likely the route my app will go down. But there are a lot of yellow cabs, and not being able to include them is a real shame.
NYC has really gone to great lengths to protect the existing medallion system - no surprise given the amount of money that it brings in.
I think that's probably the core of it, yes. At the end of the day, it isn't a problem for me to use for-hire taxi services- it's just a shame that I can't use yellow cabs.
I didn't really intend for this post to be a complaint about government regulation- it exists everywhere, and often for good reason- but more about the fact that the average startup has no time to lobby government for change.
Edit: Hurp durp, you mentioned Uber in your post. Ignore me :)