News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TypeScript 5.2's New Keyword: 'using' by manojlds on Monday June 19, 2023 @06:14AM (#36389343)
> Symbol is a built-in object whose constructor returns a symbol primitive — also called a Symbol value or just a Symbol — that's guaranteed to be unique. Symbols are often used to add unique property keys to an object that won't collide with keys any other code might add to the object, and which are hidden from any mechanisms other code will typically use to access the object. That enables a form of weak encapsulation, or a weak form of information hiding.

> Prior to well-known Symbols, JavaScript used normal properties to implement certain built-in operations. For example, the JSON.stringify function will attempt to call each object's toJSON() method, and the String function will call the object's toString() and valueOf() methods. However, as more operations are added to the language, designating each operation a "magic property" can break backward compatibility and make the language's behavior harder to reason with. Well-known Symbols allow the customizations to be "invisible" from normal code, which typically only read string properties.

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Refe...

Essentially if they use dispose() like you mention, what happens if someone already has code that has dispose? And in future, avoid people accidentally calling these.

Re:TypeScript 5.2's New Keyword: 'using' by vbezhenar on Monday June 19, 2023 @06:41AM (#36389485)
Using `using` is opt-in. So if you have code that has dispose function used for other purposes, rewrite that code before using `using`.
Re:TypeScript 5.2's New Keyword: 'using' by manojlds on Monday June 19, 2023 @08:17AM (#36390196)
That's case for this particular feature, but the approach has been with know symbols and is how they introduce new features into the app.

Also, you are assuming the consumer of a class is same as someone that used / uses the class. What if the library author has dispose and someone wrongly use using with it?

Re:TypeScript 5.2's New Keyword: 'using' by MrJohz on Monday June 19, 2023 @09:33AM (#36390911)
Kind of the other way round. If you have code that has a function named `dispose`, it will keep on working just fine, nothing needs to be renamed (not now, and not in the future when you want to start using `using`).

The symbol `Symbol.dispose` is special, unlike any normal string or identifier, because it didn't exist until the new standard, so existing code can't have been using it. This guarantees a level of backwards compatibility that wouldn't exist otherwise.

Re:TypeScript 5.2's New Keyword: 'using' by chrisco255 on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:25PM (#36393863)
This would break many sites on the web, if they roll this out as a native feature of JS. Importantly, JS generally cannot break backwards compatibility.