Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by mynonameaccount on Sunday June 18, 2023 @11:41AM
(#36381252)
It is Google so...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by lockhouse on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:12PM
(#36381532)
What’s wrong with opt-in telemetry?
Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by anaganisk on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:40PM
(#36381824)
Probably didn't read the title and article properly
Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by fathyb on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:46PM
(#36381882)
Or maybe they're hangover, in which case: opt-in = it won't send telemetry unless you enable it.
Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by hardware2win on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:46PM
(#36381883)
Even better question: what is wrong with reasonably telemetry turned on by default?
Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by jug6ernaut on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:55PM
(#36381978)
1. "reasonable" is going to be different for every person. In this case it seems that the accepted "reasonable" telemetry to be on by default is None.
2. There will always be group of people who will never accept any level of telemetry.
Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by lockhouse on Sunday June 18, 2023 @01:05PM
(#36382075)
In my opinion, the best approach to telemetry is to ask on first use. Explain clearly what telemetry you are sending and why. If this ever changes on a future update you ask again.
Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by technofiend on Sunday June 18, 2023 @03:55PM
(#36383810)
Doesn't work in firewalled / airgapped environments. Don't want to pay performance overhead from errors when it fails or configuration overhead to keep it off. What's considered reasonable can be changed over time and may not be defined by the end user. Potential side channel for data exfiltration if someone figures out how to abuse it, or mask stolen data to look the same. You get the idea.
Re:Google Go language goes with opt-in telemetry
by tredre3 on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:45PM
(#36384839)
> Don't want to pay performance overhead from errors when it fails or configuration overhead to keep it off.
I've seen times and times again applications going apeshit when checking for updates (or the standard calling home) on an unstable/firewalled network, they enter endless loops with no back-off delays. They just assume it will work. It's maddening, because my firewall defaults to drop everything.
OnlyOffice is incredibly aggressive if you dare to firewall it, it will do several hundred thousands connection attempts when you start any of its components.
But let's be fair here, even IF google were to implement opt-out telemetry in such a lazy way, it would get fixed soon enough after complaints.