News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by tptacek on Saturday June 17, 2023 @01:54PM (#36372596)
Is this a traditionalist ("tradcath") thing? I feel like there was no such scrupulousness about the wine at masses when I was growing up.

I don't mean this as a dismissal. If you're not Catholic you might not have noticed that there is a weird cultural moment happening right now, with a very small but noisy (or prominent, if you like) faction of traditionalists, many of them young hipsters. It's oddly centered on New York City and Kansas/Nebraska.

So I see things like this, almost unrecognizable from the church I grew up in, and I wonder if this is just another tendril of that movement.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by madars on Saturday June 17, 2023 @02:41PM (#36373135)
n=1 data point -- as a practicing Catholic who cares about the discipline of sacraments, this is the first time I hear about concerns regarding sacramental wine. At the same time, the story of using invalid baptismal formula ("we baptize" instead of "I baptize"; discussed on HN here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30348624) definitely made rounds in my circles (attending Ordinary Form Mass but also leaning traditional)
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by mikece on Saturday June 17, 2023 @03:22PM (#36373610)
Makes me wonder if "I've been a traditional Catholic since 1975 AMA" would be an active topic on HN. :-)
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by probably_wrong on Saturday June 17, 2023 @02:34PM (#36373051)
Speaking from my personal experience, I feel my (South American) priest would have rolled his eyes at this, the same way I would feel about (say) the Rust foundation releasing a clarification document on tabs vs spaces.

I understand the need for a baseline to keep churches from holding mass with Fanta, and I agree that good wine is better than bad wine. But I easily imagine a Last Crusade moment where we learn that Jesus actually drank poor people's wine and, in an ironic twist (as suggested by a dead comment), it turns out that his wine was diluted and wouldn't fit the definition here.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by tptacek on Saturday June 17, 2023 @02:48PM (#36373210)
Right! I mean: there's nothing wrong with this stuff; Jewish people have kashrut, Muslims have haram and halal, Hindus (or at least a big chunk of them) have ovo-lacto vegetarianism.

But: this seems like something new. I doubt many people in my parish would care at all about the specific wine used at mass. For that matter: most people don't even take wine at mass.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by kevinmchugh on Saturday June 17, 2023 @07:05PM (#36375636)
I've seen a priest raid the pantry for bread to perform the sacrament and I think decided triscuits were better than cheese wheat thins. I've also seen a priest talk about the provenance of the wine and which member of the congregation had provided it from their travels. Only one bottle was transubstantiated, the second bottle came out for tasting later.
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by pyuser583 on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:20AM (#36377283)
This is very mainstream. There was a period of experimentation and lax discipline corresponding to my own youth. Catholicism was whatever the local priest wanted.

There pre-Vatican rules regarding Eucharistic matter have been almost perfectly followed for a few decades.