News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by sharts on Friday June 16, 2023 @05:12AM (#36353656)
This is known as capitalism. It is the norm. Not the exception.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by sumedh on Friday June 16, 2023 @05:26AM (#36353769)
Its not capitalism per se, when you are small you have to focus on your customers whether you like it or not but when you become big you can afford not to treat your customers properly.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by EGreg on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:00AM (#36354052)
Ok how about this

It’s capitalism for any business / platform that gets big

And has shareholders that want profits

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by tormeh on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:13AM (#36354158)
It’s less about size and more about moat, though most businesses with no moat tend to stay small. If you have a moat you have less competition so you can and will extract more profit.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by EGreg on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:15AM (#36354168)
I would say size correlates rather strongly to bad incentives for the shareholder class vs society.

Mark Z was an open source bro who turned down M$ in High School and ended up open sourcing Synapse. He built Facemash and Facebook and was going to build an open-source, decentralized file sharing network (“Wirehog”) but the Venture Capitalists proudly “put a bullet in that thing”. Gotta extract them rents!

I heard Sean Parker myself on stage at TechCrunch Disrupt 2010 telling the story. Sean likewise tried to make a file sharing economy (Napster), and got nailed for it by another set of really big monopoly-like organizations, in the music and movie industries. He learned his lesson of capitalism: don’t mess with the centralized control!

Peter Thiel, the first investor in Facebook, says like you: “competition is for losers, build a monopoly”. That’s not hyperbole, that’s the actual title of his talk at Google, that I listened to.

With such investors it is no wonder that Mark Z went from an open source bro to corporate golden boy who buys up the competition, makes unilateral decisions — moves fast, break things — and then says “calm down, breathe, we hear you.”

Society has become like this (lonely, angry, addicted) not by accident. It is the end result of the system where shareholders and venture capitalists and the profit motive shape our platforms.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by marcinzm on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:45AM (#36354406)
Anyone reading history or following world news will be well aware of that "power corrupts." Period. Capitalism is merely the modern fast means to power but even so its far from the only one. Kings are morally corrupt, politicians are morally corrupt, click bait thought leaders are morally corrupt, cult leaders are morally corrupt, etc, etc. There is always some proxy for social status and power which people will quiet literally kill for. Nowadays it's mostly money or at least it's the most accessible one.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by EGreg on Friday June 16, 2023 @07:03AM (#36354563)
So the answer is to distribute power and not let it concentrate.

The best is a gift economy with no profit motive. It creates more value for the world than its capitalist counterparts:

1) Wikipedia vs Britannica, Encarta, et al

2) VoIP vs Telcos

3) Linux vs closed systems like Sun, etc.

4) World Wide Web based on open protocols vs AOL, MSN, Compuserve

They beat them within a decade. Gopher was good but started trying to use the government to control its licensing. It lost.

Now, if you need an accounting system, that rewards ecosystem participants for storage, hosting, uptime/availability, computation, security, translating, moderating, whatever, then use decentralized crypto utility tokens based on open protocols. Micropayments can be done peer to peer via trustlines.

It’s the proper use case for crypto. And it beats the current system of financing projects because the end result is more like

1) Ethereum for business logic

2) IPFS for storage

etc.

vs Facebook, Twitter, Reddit and other centralized things.

The rest — realtime chats, video, endless doomscrolling feeds it’s all gimmicks designed to get you addicted to centralized control. It’s not good for healthy society.

Frankly, neither are celebrities who can tweet to 5 million followers at 3 in the morning. In true gift economies like Science, Wikipedia, Open Source software etc. people actually have to run the gauntlet of peer review for the privilege of having their ideas reach the public. That’s how it should be. Not polluting the public with mindless advertisement and smut and one sided news stories radicalizing them to hate and wars.

Think about it. https://rational.app also goes into more detail on the economics of how we got here and how to get out.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by marcinzm on Friday June 16, 2023 @07:44AM (#36354913)
Reddit and Wikipedia both get complaints for the abuse of power by power users or mods. They both work (well up to now for Reddit) because there's an absolute admin group bound through a corporate governance structure to step in when needed. Without that you get shit.

>Science

There's a reason for the saying "science moves forward one funeral at a time." Those with power block those who do not have power from competing with them until they literally die of old age.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by marcinzm on Friday June 16, 2023 @05:44PM (#36364344)
Also, peer review is not something people go through for the joy of it. Academia and many corporations will literally not hire or promote you unless you go through it. Publishing and conference entities will not publicize your finding unless you go through it and historically without the internet that was the only real way to get publicity. In other words corporate power structures are forcing you to play the game or they will effectively block you from being able to do science professionally. So that seems a pretty poor example of non-corporate power structures.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by ziftface on Friday June 16, 2023 @07:46AM (#36354949)
I agree with you, but I think when people complain about "capitalism" today, what they mean essentially is "greed", meaning profits above all other concerns. Obviously that's not the precise definition of capitalism, but I see that as an example of spoken language evolving over time.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by marcinzm on Friday June 16, 2023 @08:35AM (#36355533)
My point is that greed always exists with or without capitalism. Many attempts over the last 150 years have been made under the assumption that "capitalism" is the problem and they all failed because "greed" is the problem. If you remove "capitalism" then people will simply find a new means to satisfy their "greed" because people are rather clever actually.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by AnonCoward42 on Friday June 16, 2023 @05:20AM (#36353717)
This is neither inherent nor exclusive to capitalism.
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by aniforprez on Friday June 16, 2023 @05:37AM (#36353867)
I'm getting really tired of people just vapidly attributing "bad thing" to capitalism. People are just shitty. That's not exclusive to capitalism
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by EGreg on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:05AM (#36354084)
No one said “exclusive” to capitalism.

It’s simple. The profit motive ruins everything as things get big. Usually because shareholders demand to extract rents from the ecosystem. Even while externalizing the cost to society and the environment

Open source gift economies are a far better alternative for society and don’t have that problem. But they require the productive participants to enjoy financial independence or some disposable free time, and universal basic income isn’t coming from daddy government anytime soon.

If you want to attract infrastructure providers and fund development for your project in an economically sustainable way, don’t sell shares in your corporation - release a utility token for your platform, and make it available worldwide. Heck, peg it to a USDC if you’re worried about speculators or complying with securities laws (although there are tons of exemptions from registration, like Reg D and Reg S and Reg CF etc). Issuing and managing them with smart contracts is super easy, and permissionless. You can do it in a minute. People have their own choice of how to store them. And micropayments for infrastructure can be implemented via trustlines in a free market pretty easily.

The utility token holders — even the people who hoard them — have a far better set of incentives than corporate shareholders do. Ether or Filecoin HODLers aren’t trying to ruin it for everyone using the network, nor are they even trying to assert central control over what people can do with IPFS or Ethereum!

Sadly, many people on HN have it completely backwards with what’s good for society. They hate Web3 with a passion and claim it has no use cases even though utility tokens would lead to a far superior set of incentives, wifh no parasitic shareholder class insisting on centralized control and rent extraction — essentially forever. They see what happens at Reddit, Twitter, Facebook, with a few people at the top making decisions, but they don’t put two-and-two together because the cargo-cult of anti-Web3 is strong in 2023. (But not next year, when the halving event happens and lots of innovation gets released again.)

Meanwhile they are in love with generative AI, the new kid on the block, despite most of its own most prominent inventors screaming about a large chance of catastrophe and running to the governmebf.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by aniforprez on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:32AM (#36354302)
Am I really being subjected to web3 crypto bullshit? No thank you
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by EGreg on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:45AM (#36354409)
That just about sums it up right there. Doing the same thing over and over (shareholder capitalism) and expecting a different result after the platform gets big. Calling daddy government. Bitterly complaining. But to acknowledge the root cause and an actual solution of programmers enabling decentralization? Nah, that smells like web3! Don’t subject me to this decentralized nonsense! Brrrr

By the way, the reaction of those who were used to centralized control has always been priceless… this is the earliest moment when they were confronted with the possibility of everyone empowered to do their own thing on their own personal computers:

The committee meeting where the team first presented the Gopher protocol was a disaster, “literally the worst meeting I’ve ever seen,” says Alberti. “I still remember a woman in pumps jumping up and down and shouting, ‘You can’t do that!’ ”

Among the team's offenses: Gopher didn’t use a mainframe computer and its server-client setup empowered anyone with a PC, not a central authority. While it did everything the U required and then some, to the committee it felt like a middle finger. “You’re not supposed to have written this!” Alberti says of the group’s reaction. “This is some lark, never do this again!” The Gopher team was forbidden from further work on the protocol. (https://www.minnpost.com/business/2016/08/rise-and-fall-goph...)

Times change, the hilarity of resisting decentralization stays the same…

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by FridgeSeal on Friday June 16, 2023 @08:46PM (#36365952)
Are you genuinely trying to sell the hyper-capitalism-turned-up-to-11 that is crypto as a better alternative to…capitalism?
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by EGreg on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:08AM (#36379117)
That's the wrong way to look at it. Try to step out of the cargo-cult for just a second. Shareholders buying an IPO is hyper-capitalism. You have a market of buyers and sellers, say, and some utility token. Maybe it's FileCoin for file storage on IPFS. Maybe it's ETH for gas on Ethereum. It's global and convenient to pay once you have it. Maybe it's Disney Dollars.

But then, you have on top of this "hyper-capitalism". Peter Thiel says "competition is for losers, build a monopoly", making many capitalists blush. Venture Capitalists prop up money-losing unit economics for years (they call it "reducing friction") and then dump the equity on the public. The public then pushes the team to extract rents from all sides from the marketplace forever. Who needs these shareholders? That's hyper-capitalism.

In fact, I would even go so far as to say that your utility token shouldn't be freely available to everyone. Only the actual participants should be buying it. Otherwise a hyper-capitalist whale like Goldman Sachs can pump and dump it, hurting people: https://foreignpolicy.com/2011/04/27/how-goldman-sachs-creat...

It might even be designed to undergo demurrage, so that if you don't use it, you gradually lose it. This was done in Worgl and defied the depression all around it, even the Mises institute had to gradully agree it worked: https://mises.org/library/free-money-miracle

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by Brian_K_White on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:59AM (#36357705)
And yet this is just a vapid "people are bad".

In fact incentive structure matters.

So for example people in a co-op or volunteer org can be bad for reasons other than profit, like power or the illusion of regard instead.

But then a few days ago at a family gathering a guy asked what I do, and as part of that I was explaining what open source is, and he on his own started telling me how much he loved the vlc media player. Everything he loved about it was the result of the fact that no one working on it has any reason to mistreat the user.

There are examples of open source software that makes decicions I don't like, but even the worst of those are someone else's legitimate best idea how to do the best possible for the user.

Yes, Reddit's current actions are squarely the result of capitalism, not "people".

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by Draiken on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:00AM (#36354053)
Isn't everything that's happening with Reddit ultimately because of the pursuit of profits above all else?

For me that's as capitalistic as it gets.

It's the same frame of thought geared towards employees.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by irthomasthomas on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:13AM (#36354155)
That's the official Reddit narrative. Do you still believe the official Reddit narrative?
Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by Draiken on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:19AM (#36354203)
Not sure I'm following here. I can't really think of another motive for doing what they are doing. It's an attempt of a pump before dumping it in the public markets.

What else could it be?

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by irthomasthomas on Friday June 16, 2023 @07:04AM (#36354569)
Don't know, but there are more points to the compass than profit and loss. It's not hard for me to imagine that a site like Reddit, with a billion engaged and trusting users could add value to the companies that control it, without it being a profit centre directly.

And I added an edit to point out that if the profit motive was true, they would have accepted the money offered by the API users who agreed to the price hike. They went ignored for two out of the four weeks notice Reddit gave.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by Draiken on Friday June 16, 2023 @08:39AM (#36355582)
I see your point now, but I disagree.

Yes, signing a few API users would "increase profit" but not as much as the profit they can (or perceive they can) generate by having control over their platform/clients.

With control they can employ whatever dark patterns they want to extract as much value as they can from ads. Some suggest ads by API but still that's nowhere near the same type of control/guarantee.

Ultimately this even strengthens my point. They want profits above all else. They are choosing the highest potential profit over the less profitable API deal that could be a nice middle ground.

In capitalism it doesn't matter if a better alternative costs a single cent more. If there is a choice, it will be to save that cent.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by AnonCoward42 on Friday June 16, 2023 @07:13AM (#36354652)
It's the capitalism cliché, but it is not the capitalism. Even if you only seek profits, it's not necessarily in their interest to get tunnel-vision and seek short-term profits. Depending on how it proceeds this might be a lesson in how capitalism actually eliminates this very behavior/cliché. We're going to see.

Disclaimer: I am all for criticizing capitalism, but using the cliché is not well argued imo.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by Draiken on Friday June 16, 2023 @02:28PM (#36361455)
Being a cliché or not doesn't make it untrue. It's not a novel argument but it's still absolutely relevant.

Saying it's not "the capitalism" is a bit of a true scotsman argument. There is only really one capitalism: the one we're living in today. There's no other version of this as far as I can tell. Maybe before we had different variations of it but with globalization, it's one to rule them all.

> it's not necessarily in their interest to get tunnel-vision and seek short-term profits

I wish I shared your hopeful vision because looking at history and current affairs, there's no indication that short term gains are ever going to be replaced by long term ones. The climate change issue is the prime example for that. Everyone knows long term it's bad, but who cares? We need those stocks to go up! [1]

[1]: https://www.derekchristensen.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/...

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by AnonCoward42 on Saturday June 17, 2023 @04:57AM (#36368510)
> Saying it's not "the capitalism" is a bit of a true scotsman argument.

The statement I answered was making the worst case the norm. That's why I said that it is not representative for capitalism ("not the capitalism"). Short-term-profiteering is just a part of it - that is usually eliminated, if that's all that is to it.

> I wish I shared your hopeful vision because looking at history and current affairs, there's no indication that short term gains are ever going to be replaced by long term ones. The climate change issue is the prime example for that. Everyone knows long term it's bad, but who cares? We need those stocks to go up!

Now you're shifting the goal post. I specifically speak about profit not about some other arbitrary goal. Capitalism (like any economical system) isn't going to magically fix everything (i.e. climate).

edit: clarify

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by Draiken on Saturday June 17, 2023 @01:18PM (#36372211)
> Now you're shifting the goal post.

That was not my intention. Climate change was just an example but the point is still about profits. It doesn't matter if you find that in 25 years profits will be better for everyone if we do X. Unless you get growth next quarter, stocks plummet.

Hence why I said I don't share your optimistic vision. With capitalism there is only the next quarter.

Even if you look at some of the longer plays like venture capitalism, it's the same mindset focusing on an exit that is a bit delayed. Swap profit at all costs with growth at all costs for a while in hopes you then profit later with monopolies.

Sure as you state short-term profiteering might not be all there is to capitalism, but I never claimed that in the first place. The issue is not the short-term part, it's seeking profit above all else. You can't really fix that within capitalism since it's what defines it.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by specproc on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:15AM (#36354167)
Capitalism is not monolithic. Markets and businesses work very differently in different countries on different continents. Or in the same country a few decades apart.

Shrugging at shitty practices and saying "capitalism" is at best reductive and unhelpful.

Re:Louis Rossmann calls community to leave Reddit by Eisenstein on Friday June 16, 2023 @07:32AM (#36354811)
It's called a 'thought terminating cliche'.

The most far-reaching and complex of human problems are compressed into brief, highly reductive, definitive-sounding phrases, easily memorized, and easily expressed. They become the start and finish of any ideological analysis.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought-terminating_clich%C3%A...