Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by ionfish on Thursday November 13, 2008 @04:12PM
(#363601)
I remarked earlier to my flatmate how much it said about our society that this wasn't the top item on all the major news sites. At least it's the first thing on Hacker News.
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by abstractbill on Thursday November 13, 2008 @04:29PM
(#363620)
I have a theory about this: Misleading headlines often make people tune actually interesting things out.
I've seen a bunch of articles before this one, with headlines that make it seem like photos have been taken of planets in other solar-systems. On closer inspection they've often turned out to be artists' impressions, computer renderings, or similar things.
The net result is that today, when I saw this article, my reaction was a mix of "didn't that happen already?" and "are they real photos?".
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by jimbokun on Thursday November 13, 2008 @09:19PM
(#363858)
Now number 1 on Google News, and considering that Google News is a news aggregator, this must mean that a lot of other news sources are giving prominent coverage as well.
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by habs on Thursday November 13, 2008 @04:17PM
(#363605)
Scientists and engineers have long been the engine of progression for societies. I think it's a shame that people don't have more of an appreciation at the technological and scientific wonders of the modern world. But like you said "At least it's the first thing on Hacker News" :D
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by habs on Thursday November 13, 2008 @04:07PM
(#363597)
"Scientific truth is too beautiful to be sacrificed for the sake of light entertainment or money. Astrology is an aesthetic affront. It cheapens astronomy, like using Beethoven for commercial jingles."
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by unalone on Thursday November 13, 2008 @08:53PM
(#363832)
I know you didn't quote this because of the latter part of that quote, but: I discovered Chopin by playing a song on DDR that used one of his themes. So I've always been partial to people who use grandiose things for the sake of pop. Or at the very least, I'm a bit forgiving of it.
Astrology I can't stand, though. I'd like it a lot more if people didn't actually believe in it.
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by hugh on Thursday November 13, 2008 @10:35PM
(#363921)
What kind of telescope would be necessary to actually view the details of a distant planet?
An incredibly large one. I don't have time to figure it out right now, but if anyone feels motivated then what you need to be looking at is the diffraction limit:
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by lutorm on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:36PM
(#364614)
Yeah, if you mean "detail on the planet" and not just resolve the planet from its star, then it's completely infeasible. The current 30m-class telescopes that are under development (ie www.tmt.org) in combination with high-contrast adaptive optics will make it possible to see earth-size planets, if I'm not mistaken, but not to resolve detail on their surface.
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by 13ren on Thursday November 13, 2008 @09:33PM
(#363868)
If there was a habitable planet in that system with intelligent life, with the same capabilities as us, they wouldn't be able to see any of the planets in our solar system.
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by breily on Thursday November 13, 2008 @11:23PM
(#363966)
Why not? It seems like if we can see them they could see us - unless you just mean our planets are smaller so they'd need a better telescope than we can make?
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by jmtame on Thursday November 13, 2008 @09:07PM
(#363848)
Sorry kids, My Very Elegant Mother Just Served Us Nine Pickles is going to become merely an introduction for the book you'll have to memorize after this project is finished ;)
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by jodrellblank on Thursday November 13, 2008 @07:03PM
(#363766)
Did anyone ask the inhabitants whether they agree to have their information stored in our computer systems under the terms of the Data Protection and Privacy laws?
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by mechanical_fish on Thursday November 13, 2008 @10:14PM
(#363906)
I'm no legal expert, but I'm guessing that the Universal Supreme Court will affirm that a nation doesn't have legal jurisdiction outside of its light cone.
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by mechanical_fish on Friday November 14, 2008 @09:05AM
(#364283)
We are in the light cone of the light that they emitted several hundred years ago. The light that they are emitting "now" [1] is still a few hundred years outside of our light cone, just as they still a hundred years or more away from learning about our discovery of radio.
It's theoretically possible that they know about Earth's IP laws as of a few hundred years ago. But in Dickens' day England couldn't manage to enforce their IP laws in the United States, let alone the rest of the Milky Way.
These days I'm sure that many lawyers wouldn't hesitate to sue Pluto for misappropriating the name of a Disney character, but that news has yet to reach many of our extrasolar neighbors.
[1] Keeping in mind that, in a discussion involving relativity, you have to be very careful with the word "now".
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by rgrieselhuber on Thursday November 13, 2008 @07:53PM
(#363799)
Wouldn't it be interesting to have a Google Earth-like products of other planets (due to spectacular advances in imaging, of course :-) ) long before we ever have the means to travel there?
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by mellow on Friday November 14, 2008 @07:37AM
(#364200)
This is incredible. If astronomers analyse the spectra of the planets they can now image and find oxygen, methane and CO2 in certain proportions, the only conclusion will be life. Imagine if they find the spectral lines from chemicals produced by an industrial, polluting society!
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by albertcardona on Friday November 14, 2008 @08:19AM
(#364224)
If current technology had enough resolution, scientists would have scanned the planets already for oxygen, methane and water (which mixed together don't quite exist unless there's a continuous force, like life, unbalancing the physical reaction).
Re:Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other ...
by lutorm on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:32PM
(#364609)
Actually, they have. There are observations with the Spitzer space telescope infrared spectrograph of planets occulting their star, where if I'm not mistaken one could see something like methane absorption signatures of the atmosphere of the planets. That's not very surprising, since these are Jupiter-like planets and they have methane clouds in their atmosphere.
Wired did a much better article, and shorter, with less speculation: http://blog.wired.com/wiredscience/2008/11/first-direct-im.h...
Original paper: http://tinyurl.com/6fdeu5 or http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/sci;1166585v1...
I've seen a bunch of articles before this one, with headlines that make it seem like photos have been taken of planets in other solar-systems. On closer inspection they've often turned out to be artists' impressions, computer renderings, or similar things.
The net result is that today, when I saw this article, my reaction was a mix of "didn't that happen already?" and "are they real photos?".
Suits believe they are progressing things. And the rest will always credit the nearest authoritative looking type.
Worse still, many scientist and engineers credit the suits themselves.
I'm saying, "Suits are overvalued. And nerds are undervalued even by themselves. That's always been true with periodic exceptions."
And I don't mean "suits" as a pejorative; I'm not using it in contempt. It's a fact that people of that class wear them.
Actually, I like wearing them.
- Richard Dawkins
"Nothing exists except atoms and empty space; everything else is opinion"
- Democritus
Astrology I can't stand, though. I'd like it a lot more if people didn't actually believe in it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:HR_8799_planetary_system_...
An incredibly large one. I don't have time to figure it out right now, but if anyone feels motivated then what you need to be looking at is the diffraction limit:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffraction_limit
That's the fundamental limit on how small a feature you can pick up using a telescope of a given size.
The sky might be full of earth-like planets, and we wouldn't know (yet).
unless... detecting star-wobble is already sensitive enough to detect earth-like mass and distance from sun?
It's theoretically possible that they know about Earth's IP laws as of a few hundred years ago. But in Dickens' day England couldn't manage to enforce their IP laws in the United States, let alone the rest of the Milky Way.
These days I'm sure that many lawyers wouldn't hesitate to sue Pluto for misappropriating the name of a Disney character, but that news has yet to reach many of our extrasolar neighbors.
[1] Keeping in mind that, in a discussion involving relativity, you have to be very careful with the word "now".
Enjoy! It's really amazing