News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by adventured on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:18PM (#36329197)
That's not how it's actually going to play out.

As the AI generated content becomes dramatically overwhelming in scale, the human content will become increasingly easy to spot (and there will be multiple cues to the human content that make it fairly obvious). There will be a crossing of the two along the way, in regards to the amount of content generated, a relatively brief time where it will be difficult to tell which is which.

The more AI content there is, and the more it advances, the easier it's going to be to play spot the human. The time in which it'll be hardest to tell them apart, will be in the middle frames rather than in the later stages.

Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by jerf on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:36PM (#36329480)
"As the AI generated content becomes dramatically overwhelming in scale, the human content will become increasingly easy to spot (and there will be multiple cues to the human content that make it fairly obvious)"

I feel like you're not accounting for the amount of that AI content that will be deliberately and intelligently intended to masquerade as human. Every signal you can think of and may start using is a signal that intelligent humans can and will forge. And they'll get the ones you didn't think of either, because that's their job.

I don't even have to hedge or qualify this prediction, because we have decades of experience with people already forging every signal that is technically possible to forge, and pouring very substantial effort into doing so, right up to having dark businesses that provide these things as a service. "Forge all the signals that are technically possible to forge" is a product you can buy right now. For example, from 13 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36151140

I don't know what signals you think you're going to see, but I'll guarantee A: yes, you will indeed see them because there's a lot of degrees of competence in the use of these systems (I still periodically get spams where the sender sent out their template rather than filling it in with a mail merge), but B: those will just be the ones you notice, not the entire population.

Rather than a binary decision, I like to measure with "how much information does it take for me to detect a forgery". For instance, things like modern architecture renders can absolutely fool me as being real at standard definition, but at 4K they still struggle (too precise, too clean, even when they try to muss it up on purpose). I need a few paragraphs of GPT text to identify it conclusively, and that's just the default tone it takes. Ask it to give you some text in a specific style and I don't know how much it would take. For all I know I'm already missing things. You're probably already missing things you didn't realize.

Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by willcipriano on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:51PM (#36329724)
ChatGTP has a number of topics it will refuse to discuss so any writing on those topics will be more often than not human generated.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by jerf on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @02:09PM (#36330022)
As I mentioned in another post, OpenAI does not have any sort of lock on LLMs. There's already plenty in the wild and they're only going to get better. Already the commercial AI companies are expressing concern about how much faster the truly open stuff is developing than their stuff. The companies can still throw better hardware at the problem somewhat more reliably but that's not much of a moat; it's still commodity hardware, it's just a bit much to drop on just being able to LLM better if you're not being paid to LLM.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by willcipriano on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @02:20PM (#36330222)
Do any publicly available services like this offer a uncensored bot? I have models I can run on my laptop without censorship but they aren't very high quality.

I know they can exist but from what I can get my hands on it seems saying something offensive is a way to prove you are human for the time being.

Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by sbierwagen on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @02:38PM (#36330546)
Llama 65B exists and you can just run it on a cloud GPU instance.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by willcipriano on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @02:50PM (#36330742)
Ahh thank you, still that has a cost, legal and technical bar to cross but seems to meet the criteria.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by jerf on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @03:57PM (#36331682)
Yes, I do agree with you that it is nowhere near as trivial as it is to just pop open ChatGPT and ask it something right now, and at the moment, that matters.

I'm looking more long term, like, a year out, five years out, and on that time frame I think it's very reasonable to expect to see ChatGPT-levels of quality being completely commoditized. OpenAI or whatever commercial entity may by then have the next level AI, but there's definitely a threshold where the combination of LLM + human ingenuity gets to the point where there are effectively no signals of humanity left.

Moreover, I'm running on the theory that detecting LLMs is in fact not an arms race, but clearly ends in a win for LLMs. Basically, there exists text that simply looks human. It doesn't matter what level of superhuman AI you throw at it, it simply is in the space of "texts that a human was likely to generate". Once that level is attained, it won't matter that there is something that can generate superhuman text quality or something.

(Or, put another way, if your clever "ride the AI wave" startup plan is "create a startup that can detect LLM usage", I advise you strongly to wargame out your 1 year and 5 year futures for that tech, especially in the face of deliberate attack. I would not be optimistic.)

Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by tjoff on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:34PM (#36329445)
Like Kessler though the problem isn't to detect it but to get anything through. We might not see human content for a few decades before we've sorted it out.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by AndrewKemendo on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @02:25PM (#36330324)
Exactly! I just point to the root lack of differentiation as intractable

As in you can’t sort it out…just like so far there’s nobody that really knows how to clean up space long term

Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by 317070 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:25PM (#36329306)
Because the human data will become "stupid" in comparison, is that the reason?

I don't understand why spot-the-human will become easier otherwise.

Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by HideousKojima on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:29PM (#36329371)
The human content will contain the n-word or other shibboleths.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by jerf on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:38PM (#36329497)
The "n-word" or any arbitrary other shibboleths may guarantee you didn't use OpenAI services, but they don't have any sort of lock on LLM technology and it's trivial to ask non-controlled ones to use any you like.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by chaxor on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:33PM (#36329433)
This also doesn't make any sense, as it would be much cheaper to use local LLMs to generate text, making it likely to see generated toxic language.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by sorokod on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @02:41PM (#36330577)
AI generated text is still that even with human shibboleth decorations added
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by George83728 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @02:45PM (#36330642)
Deep irony to use such a dehumanizing word as evidence of humanity.
Re:33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production... by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @05:24PM (#36332916)
Its easy to sprinkle a few n. or other words onto AI generated content.