News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit Doubles Down by Terr_ on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @09:13PM (#36320016)
> It's so easy to think of other ways this could have been handled.

Well, assuming Reddit executives were telling the truth about their goals/needs, which I don't think they are.

They claim the purpose was some kind of emergency band-aid to stop the service from hemorrhaging cash from evil large-scale data-sucking AI developers without compensation... But in that case, they could have simply introduced it as a fresh terms-of-service restriction, with some payment-tier to come later that permits that use of the data.

Re:Reddit Doubles Down by jprete on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:03PM (#36320467)
I don't think Reddit was telling the truth either.

But AI developers/companies seem to almost universally believe they have fair-use rights to train their models on any data they can get their hands on, and a sufficiently expensive API at least forces them to do engineering work to get all the data. So at the time I believed Reddit's reasoning.

Re:Reddit Doubles Down by tetris11 on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:26PM (#36320647)
Pushshift was the best unofficial reddit API for years, and did so without any funding problems
Re:Reddit Doubles Down by jprete on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:35PM (#36320720)
I'm talking about deterring ML data harvesting, or at least getting a better price for it.
Re:Reddit Doubles Down by Semaphor on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @11:11PM (#36320955)
If it were about ML, why did they go heavily after third-party apps, even making up lies about one of the developers?
Re:Reddit Doubles Down by jprete on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @07:55AM (#36324491)
Because it wasn't about ML. As I said, I believe Reddit was lying. But the ML story was at least plausible at the time.
Re:Reddit Doubles Down by johnnyanmac on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @11:32AM (#36327495)
>But AI developers/companies seem to almost universally believe they have fair-use rights to train their models on any data they can get their hands on

Google and many other companies for almost 2 decades have spent their time scraping petabytes of data from the web. A lot of that with no expectation of payment. Some companies became billionaires off of that ability to freely access mass bulks of data.

Data scraping has always been a grey area, but I find it strange how it's suddenly taken a turn for some people whenever modern AI comes up. We can't really be drawing lines based on what we feel is good/evil, because we will never agree as a whole on what is good/evil.

Re:Reddit Doubles Down by lost_tourist on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @11:14PM (#36320979)
They could have set up a signature with 3rd party apps, those apps could have have charged the apps a couple bucks/required ads in the feeds from reddit/etc. Instead they wanted 100% control and 100% of the data. This isn't -just- about killing off AI scrapers, this is about sending a message that reddit is 100% under the CEO's control for when they have the IPO. Wallstreet does not like "free" stuff, all they see are cost centers and profit centers.