News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by idiotsecant on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:35PM (#36296280)
Literally nobody is saying that reddit can't charge for their API. What everyone is saying is that the proposed API usage fee structure is not designed to keep reddit's lights on. It's clearly designed to remove third party interoperability.
Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:37PM (#36296324)
what other similar sites in the industry have much lower API costs?
Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by orra on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:45PM (#36296460)
That's a completely unrelated question.
Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:57PM (#36296761)
Its totally related question, if new reddit pricing is aligned with industry, then it is fair and reasonable pricing, and apps which go down are those who built little businesses on something reddit provided for free while not contributing back, and who now can't monetize their traffic well enough.

Apollo dev can start charging his customers $5/m and cover API costs, but the problem is that his value proposition is too small for such price.

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by orra on Monday June 12, 2023 @01:20PM (#36297236)
The question is whether the API pricing is designed to lock out thirty party apps. The pricing being orders of magnitude greater than the revenue from advertisers makes this clear.

You say we should ask whether pricing is aligned with the rest of the industry. Well, the new reddit pricing is not far off twitter. The latter are infamous for freezing out third party clients.

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @01:26PM (#36297367)
> The pricing being orders of magnitude greater than the revenue from advertisers

Can you share how you came to this statement?

> Well, the new reddit pricing is not far off twitter.

I asked not about just twitter, but about any similar site you know. For example, imgur which is often referred in this situation actually charges $3k/50m requests, not far from reddit prices: https://rapidapi.com/imgur/api/imgur-9/pricing

If you don't know such example, then reddit pricing is fair and reasonable, and that's apps problem that they can't monetize traffic.

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by giantrobot on Monday June 12, 2023 @03:14PM (#36299401)
> and apps which go down are those who built little businesses on something reddit provided for free while not contributing back

Holy shit. Reddit's only content is provided by the users. The users of their APIs generate/moderate a non-trivial amount of content that gives anyone a reason to visit Reddit. Suggesting the API users aren't "giving back" is just ludicrous.

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @03:59PM (#36300061)
> Suggesting the API users aren't "giving back" is just ludicrous.

and they don't, apollo free app doesn't allow you to post, you need to pay $5 to unlock post feature.

Also, obviously, I talked about revenue numbers, not content which already generated far than enough using default reddit app/web.

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by weaksauce on Monday June 12, 2023 @01:44PM (#36297775)
imgur charges ~150usd for what would cost ~15,000usd in the new structure
Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:56PM (#36299097)
its $3k/50m requests not $150/50m reqs, not far from reddit prices: https://rapidapi.com/imgur/api/imgur-9/pricing
Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by weaksauce on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:12PM (#36300263)
from the dev himself:

> I'm deeply disappointed in this price. Reddit iterated that the price would be A) reasonable and based in reality, and B) they would not operate like Twitter. Twitter's pricing was publicly ridiculed for its obscene price of $42,000 for 50 million tweets. Reddit's is still $12,000. For reference, I pay Imgur (a site similar to Reddit in user base and media) $166 for the same 50 million API calls.

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:18PM (#36300380)
I gave you link on official pricing, it is up to you who you want to trust.
Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by weaksauce on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:22PM (#36300430)
https://web.archive.org/web/20210925071659/https://rapidapi....

was much cheaper just 2 years ago and he's been using it for at least 8 years... i imagine he was grandfathered in to an even earlier one/negotiated a deal.

that's what sane api companies do... grandfather and don't pull the rug out in 30 days

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:31PM (#36300588)
That page says if he doesn't fit into mega plan, it will cost him 50k per 50m reqs, or I am missing something?
Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by weaksauce on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:48PM (#36300856)
What i'm saying is that just 2 years ago someone who signed up at the mega plan was spending 6,000 less for the same service. apollo has been using that api for a lot longer than 2 years... unfortunately the wayback doesn't go further back than 2 years. it's entirely possible that he's getting 50m req at 160 bucks because he's grandfathered in a deal is a deal generally and if they do increase their pricing you have a long time to either find an alternative or agree to it.

aside from that i don't think the $0.001/request thing is for anyone operating at a scale much larger than 150m per month. just the initial $4000 makes it $1333/50m requests... to go from that to 50k/50m is asinine as it would be 37x more expensive; you are doing a custom deal at that point.

His initial api access at the highest tier may well have been $500/150m requests based on how much the api has shot up in price for new users in just two years.

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:51PM (#36300904)
so, current facts are:

- imgur officially charges way more than reddit for API on the scale

- your point is based solely on speculations and words of apollo dev, which I absolutely don't trust

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by weaksauce on Monday June 12, 2023 @05:09PM (#36301172)
> so, current facts are: > - imgur officially charges way more than reddit for API on the scale > your point is based solely on speculations

no, we have a reasonable extrapolation based on a worldview based in how the world operates. "if you need more than this call for pricing" is a trope and i've never seen a thing go up in price per unit when you guarantee a certain amount of revenue per year. flex capacity and pricing is more expensive than guaranteed traffic.

> and words of apollo dev which I absolutely don't trust

he's been nothing but forthcoming and transparent from what i've seen whereas spuz has a history of doing shady shit.

Re:Reddit goes down fully as thousands of subreddits protest... by riku_iki on Monday June 12, 2023 @05:18PM (#36301295)
> if you need more than this call for pricing" is a trope and i've never seen a thing go up in price per unit when you guarantee a certain amount of revenue per year

it is all over the board: you give free doze at the beginning, and squeeze business when they rooted into your product

> he's been nothing but forthcoming and transparent from what i've seen whereas spuz has a history of doing shady shit.

in my view guy is total scam:

- recorded business call without other party consent

- on that call openly proposed to get $10m to go to sunset

- when got rejected started wave in the internet with heavy manipulated numbers:

  * imgur API pricing

  * comparing Ads revenue from reddit MAU (majority do few visits per month) to his hyper active users with 250 reqs/d