News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by Solvency on Monday June 12, 2023 @09:58AM (#36293515)
The inability to be present has more to do with this artificially complex modern life we've engineered ourselves into, more than the trappings of our intellect.

Life was far more assuring, rewarding, bountiful, and meaningful if you were living in a small Native American community in the year 1400 and millions of bison roamed the plains, and the soil was the most fertile in the world, and you had a direct, non-abstracted, immediate relationship with every person in the community around you. All of your inputs lead to physically direct outputs.

And all of your biological wetware and quirks were designed and evolved to operate in this context. Hunting, foraging, moving your own body around, sleeping and waking with the sun, having non-digital relationships, eating whole foods from the earth.

And it's not to say life never had its struggles. But it was certainly more biologically consistent and natural than what we've turned it into.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by dotnet00 on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:23AM (#36293941)
This reads like the usual "natural is better" fallacy.

If you're going to focus on things like the soil being fertile and being directly involved with your neighbors, you kinda also have to consider the complete inability to cope with storms and disease and all the social ills that were reinforced because of that tight knit community.

We like to think of past life as having been the benefits of all our modern moral leanings and all our "invisible" technologies combined with idealized visions of farming fertile lands and hunting among herds of animals, but any history book makes it obvious why our ancestors struggled so hard for us to live differently.

Ignoring that many of the anecdotes presented in the linked article are mostly the author projecting despair onto others, those fundamental issues of disease, old age and death, were even worse when we lived "naturally" and had stronger ties to the people we lived around.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by digging on Monday June 12, 2023 @11:39AM (#36295333)
Largely agreed. A total regression view is inaccurate and foolish. Plenty of people had shit lives before industrialization and plenty of good lives were cut short.

We can't just assume "the past is better." That's wrong in many ways. However, when we look at our lives today, we can see things that are not good, and we can find ways that those things could be good. Many solutions can come from the past. Connection to our communities and investment in our environment seem to have real benefits for us an individuals, besides the systemic benefits.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by nradov on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:34PM (#36298682)
How can solutions come from the past when we don't even have reliable information about what the past was like? Archaeological data on the lives of pre-Columbian indigenous New World peoples is extremely limited. Even much of what we think we know is probably mistaken, or at least badly distorted by modern biases.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by digging on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:56PM (#36299091)
Simple: we don't replicate the lives of past peoples. We take ideas from [our ideas of] the past and find out if they work for us. And... it doesn't need to be from indigenous New World people.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by nradov on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:38PM (#36300702)
Hardly simple. You are talking about running huge social experiments based on guesses about what might work better. It would be interesting to see the results of such experiments, but extremely difficult to convince people to participate.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by digging on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:50AM (#36311046)
> You are talking about running huge social experiments based on guesses about what might work better

No, I'm not. But it's a good idea.

> extremely difficult to convince people to participate

Yes - easier to just stop tricking people into known-unhealthy behaviors first.

> Hardly simple.

The answer is simple. The implementation may or may not be [more simple than trying to replicate the lives of people in the past].

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by fasterik on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:06PM (#36295778)
Yep. Also known as the golden age fallacy. It's nostalgia for a past that never existed.

Some people can't accept the fact that human life has always been terrible, and it's better today than it ever has been.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by tomjakubowski on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:32PM (#36296242)
the notion that quality of life could be boiled down to a number, to be put in some ranking for comparison across eras, is ludicrous
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by yamazakiwi on Monday June 12, 2023 @01:01PM (#36296850)
We don't need to rank eras and it doesn't hurt to make some comparisons or think about how life used to be. The main issue is people comparing while omitting large issues, not people claiming specific eras are better than others.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by toolz on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:10PM (#36298247)
This is your opinion and I would suggest not a very popular opinion at that. I imagine the vast majority of the world can look at the number of violent crimes trending down over time and use that as a data point to rank eras. Similarly extreme poverty rate since the industrial revolution has drastically fallen. Another metric that I imagine the extreme vast majority of the world would find a useful metric in ranking eras. There are plenty of other metrics to rank eras that make plenty of sense if you look for them, and why shouldn't we?

Is it even possible to make progress if we're not defining what progress looks like? Is progress such a ludicrous goal for the human race? If progress is a reasonable goal and you can't make progress without defining what progress looks like then it's necessary for progress to have metrics that can be used to rank eras.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by fasterik on Monday June 12, 2023 @03:46PM (#36299842)
What I said doesn't depend on that assumption. I can make the claim that life is qualitatively better while being agnostic about whether we can attach a number to it.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by swader999 on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:41AM (#36294320)
Disease, weather, conflicts with other warring tribes. Fitting into the hierarchy, the ever present threat of banishment.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by hospitalJail on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:05AM (#36293611)
Ignorance is bliss? Is it better to believe in gods that will reincarnate you as a bear if you die in battle? Or is it better to have access to knowledge?

Also, bad weather and praying to gods wasnt exactly input/output.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by swader999 on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:43AM (#36294361)
I could go another round as a bear. Bears are awesome.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by hospitalJail on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:57AM (#36294700)
No, you don't get to be a bear at all. That was the mysticism the clan leader tricked you into dying for him for.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by swader999 on Monday June 12, 2023 @11:52AM (#36295559)
Yeah that figures.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by anthlax on Monday June 12, 2023 @01:17PM (#36297175)
How do you know?
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by ROTMetro on Monday June 12, 2023 @11:48AM (#36295490)
Unless you had a Crow/Sioux type situation where your tribe was being eradicated by a neighboring tribe and you had been captured and enslaved, or your clan lacked power/influence due to a low number of strong males. But sure, if you were in the top it might have been like you describe.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by ericmcer on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:21PM (#36296035)
Have fun with that.

I much prefer having modern medicine, grocery stores, modern entertainment etc.

Just yesterday I picked up a bunch of tacos and sat down to watch the movie Renfield with the family and I had a brief moment of awe about all the resources that are at our fingertips. I am not rich by any means but can watch one of the greatest actors in history performing on a 72inch 4k screen in my living room whenever I want. It is amazing.

If you were a Native American in the 1400s you were pretty much guaranteed to die young and in a painful fashion after a very hard life.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by steve_g on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:45PM (#36296479)
I agree with you 100%. The average person now lives better than the richest kings a few hundred years ago.

But I think it's funny that you use Nick Cage as an example. Not to be mean - I like him too. But it's still funny.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by ericmcer on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:16PM (#36298351)
Oh yeah I was hoping someone would notice the Nick Cage greatest actor bit haha
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by glitchc on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:41PM (#36298834)
> greatest actor

Surely you don't mean Nicholas Cage! That title clearly belongs to John Cena.

Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by 31carmichael on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:10AM (#36321688)
I'll also stay in 2023, thank you. The author of the comment, "Life was far more assuring, rewarding, bountiful, and meaningful back when...... " is ignorant and cannot imagine the hardships of such a life. He's nostalgic for a life that he didn't live. You don't have to fight off a saber tooth tiger to find meaning in this life.
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by mahathu on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:47PM (#36296523)
Enjoy working 12 hour days every day and eating potatoes 365 days of the year?
Re:Life Is So Terrible and Beautiful at the Same Time by lm28469 on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:56PM (#36296728)
Open literally any history book and be amazed at how far you are from reality. For the extreme vast majority of history we worked way less to sustain ourselves, certainly not the current 8 hours per day + average 100 minutes commute. The current 8 hours a day only sounds good because we had a short period of 10-12+ hours a day in mines and factories

It's funny how people are so confidently incorrect and so happy to be slave to their work, almost bragging about it. I can't even wrap my head around that, some form of Stockholm syndrome perhaps

https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/hours_...

https://medium.com/world-issues-politics-economics-and-more/...

https://www.inc.com/jessica-stillman/for-95-percent-of-human...