Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by dodedo on Thursday February 23, 2012 @11:40PM
(#3628060)
This is covered by 18 USC 6002: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/6002
In short, a judge will grant a person legal immunity from prosecution. This removes the fifth amendment argument, as you cannot be prosecuted for the child porn, and you can be compelled to testify.
For example, an accomplice to a crime might be offered immunity -- after which the accomplice cannot refuse to testify under the fifth amendment. Remember, the fifth only guarantees that you will not be compelled to serve as a witness against yourself -- it does NOT grant you the right to remain silent at all times, contrary to popular belief.
Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by fossuser on Friday February 24, 2012 @02:15AM
(#3628334)
What if the decryption key is "I am guilty of the murder", would it then be protected since the act of revealing it would be self incriminating?
Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by mfjordvald on Friday February 24, 2012 @03:50AM
(#3628497)
How would that work? If I write "I just killed a child" here it doesn't mean I actually did that. Similarly. if I used a decryption key "I am guilty of the murder" then it still does not mean I'm guilty of any murder, just that I have a poor sense of humour and used an odd encryption key.
Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by pantaloons on Friday February 24, 2012 @04:43AM
(#3628607)
That encryption key wouldn't provide proof, but there are many that would. Trivially a sufficiently long key could embed a video of the murder.
Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by Dylan16807 on Friday February 24, 2012 @07:11PM
(#3631679)
And it would be trivially impossible to memorize.
If someone is asked to decrypt their drive for a murder case, could they then invoke the Fifth Amendment on the basis that they might have child pornography? Can the Fifth Amendment protect you on an unrelated crime that you mention without either admitting to it?