There is really no reason to use Chrome on Windows 10/11 these days.
I am no Microsoft fanatic but it is useful and convenient for me to use it also on iPad and Android to share bookmarks, send tabs between devices.
Is it perfect? Nope. Somehow scammy Microsoft Rewards is enable by default.
* Under control of your employer (spying that you'll actually care about), more so than chrome, and a LOT more than firefox.
* Constant changes by the evil empire, never in the interest of the user, including the evil empire that you work for in the case of active directory
* Still (imho) doesn't match Google services and syncing in functionality and how well it works
* Same browser engine as Chrome, so no real advantage
Just install your favorite ad blocker directly from the chrome web store
> Constant changes by the evil empire
Same problem with Chrome
In my eyes edge is mostly equivalent to chrome. Edge has native vertical tabs and slightly better Windows-integration, Chrome slightly better Google-integration. Both are under the control of both your employer and a tech giant with questionable ethics. And both tech giants use their respective platforms to aggressively promote their browser.
I guess we could agree that you should use neither.
2- with the hype and hoopla of ChatGPT, a surprising number of non-tech savvy people heard " Microsoft has AI, Google doesn't", so they'll actively use Edge (and Bing) for the generative AI
The tricking people to sign in stuff is nefarious and is a more recent and growing problem. Google even gets away with it through iOS by forcing app logins/"authorization" that then results in the user logged in to Google on Safari. The whole Chrome logging in if someone checks their Gmail is terrible.
If your computing experience solely comes from a non-tech role in a corporate work environment where your employer legally owns your devices and they are remotely controlled and monitored, then all of this may seem fairly mundane. Otherwise, it is concerning anyone on hn would think what is going on here is ok or does not need to be actively avoided.
The Center for Humane Technology has good articles and video presentations on good tactics to use tech to your advantage. https://www.humanetech.com/
I can log into my work account in the browser, letting me save my work passwords to a trusted account, and search internally using Bing. It also has decent Outlook integration, which is helpful to my workflow.
I also love vertical tabs, because I end up managing 100+ tabs at work regularly. I'm eager to see a fully conceived version of this appear in other browsers because it's honestly a game changer.
And, not a huge deal, but when you copy a URL from the address bar, it pastes as a formatted link, which is really helpful when you have to do this regularly.
It really isn't a bad browser, it's just got poor privacy, which isn't important for me when I'm working. My employer already knows what I'm up to anyway.
I use Chrome as a personal browser, so it's nice keeping them completely separate from each other.
As for Firefox Sync, the protocol is byzantine and poorly documented[1], while using it “properly” requires emailing a human at Mozilla to “document expectations and timelines”[2], which for a hobby or small-scale application I read as “fuck you”. (Using it improperly, like filching the API key from one of the official clients, risks tripping the hostile and deliberately undocumented security heuristics.) For me that’s already enough to reject it for anything I couldn’t bear losing (like my passwords).
[1] https://www.codejam.info/2021/08/scripting-firefox-sync-lock...
[2] https://www.codejam.info/2021/08/scripting-firefox-sync-lock...
But I need to upgrade my PC. When I do I'll try Firefox again. Would be awesome if it would work for me again.
We are paying for pretty much everything and in countless different ways (including taxes)
The idea that the only way "to pay" is to some oligopoly keen on surveillance capitalism is absurd. If well-intentioned it is just self-limiting.
...yeah, thought so.
Who is going to win in the long run? The small number of people who care about privacy/their data VS the billions willingly using these malicious services? Even in tech/IT crowds, most don't care about privacy first products. Even on this forum it seems to be pretty split down the middle. Internet users have been getting free browsers, email, search, etc, for a very long time now.
I don't see the average person waking up one day and saying, 'I want to take my data back'. The government is not to be trusted. Personally, I think abstinence is the only solution.
By undermining trust with users (turning them into products) they put a lid on the market.
So even from a pure financial perspective they have opted for short term profit and killing the golden goose.
I've attempted to educate friends/family on tech privacy concerns, but nobody cares, even my friends in the industry. I have many tech friends that won't even modify their home network, let alone ditch FB or Google or Snapchat or Tiktok. Ultimately, computing and the internet is untrustworthy and always will be so. I don't possess the knowledge or time to assess every line of code or dependency in a project. Let alone backdoors in chips, hardware, and my ISP providing a line to the NSA.
Abstinence + sabotage of platforms is probably the only way. Keep the corporate developers busy fighting spam, fraud, abuse - make it unprofitable to build spyware.
To me the commingled business models of big tech as we have come to know them, dipping their fingers at every possible data jar, are an outlier, a dissonance.
How and when this could resolve into something more stable its not obvious. Politicians can go being immoral and look the other way for a long time. But you cant buy all the politicians all the time.
If we start by clearly separating what is really free (because its a commmon public good paid by all), from what is paid by users to private companies for real services provided in competitive markets and with respects to their clients (not product) we'll be on a good path.
National security related privacy is another can of worms altogether. You really dont want a repeat of 20th century dictators dissolving democracy and exterminating whomever they managed to cast as the enemy with the ruthless efficiency of an AI guided panopticon.
I mean these things are pretty basic. Only when we give up on common sense will dystopia become a reality.
It's not a false argument, it's a question. Which you pointedly didn't answer, and instead resorted to base emotional manipulation.
> The idea that the only way "to pay" is to some oligopoly keen on surveillance capitalism is absurd.
Strawman - nobody proposed that idea except you.
Really hoping that dang will start cracking down on extremely emotionally manipulative rhetoric like this. Your post makes no interesting points, and is instead an excellent example of emotional, empty, partisan political rhetoric that is present throughout most of the internet and media these days.
Not a niche, nerdy altermative. A mainstream, institutionally recognized and supported alternative.
The capability is already there, almost, in the form of all the amazing open source communities have achieved.
But now we need to win maybe the most important battles of all: Winning the moral and political argument and.convincing people that free and open source computing is not a weirdo obsession but the bedrock on which a democratic society will be built.
Really looking forward to a future HN where every second entry is not about how an entrenched business class has confiscated and abuses our digital future.