I view the noscript tag more along the lines of "Hey, your browser isn't working" than "Here's a sales pitch for my site for you and the 2 other people who disabled Javascript".
I had to support obsolete computers running internet explorer too many times in my life and I am glad that I don’t have to right now.
We also eventually stopped the Minitel, even though it was still used by a few people.
JS cannot access your files, your browser certainly protects you against cryptomining...
JS is not always eye candy, there are many things that cannot be done with forms alone. If you want a terrible web experience, feel free, but it's not the devs' job to write an exposé to explain why they had to use JS.
Not everyone wants to download and execute programs from the internet every time they visit a site.
Note: the ‘web’ is comprised of both web pages & applications where web applications obviously need JavaScript, but web pages are better served with JavaScript as an enhancement. In the post here, we have a web app, but there’s nothing that tells me what it is and with so many site’s running these project generator defaults of “You need to enable JavaScript to run this app”, it’s impossible to tell if this is an actual application or another SPA that should have just been static content.
You could also check out 2018 articles praising uBlock Origin for allowing users to disable JS by default in v1.17.0 such as https://www.zdnet.com/article/ublock-origin-gets-option-to-b...
You can build what you want. Xavier says this on his site:
My name is Xavier Salazar (he/him), and I love emoji. I currently work full-time at @slackhq and work remotely from Portland, OR I spend more time than my manager knows creating and perfecting the silliest little ideas for the internet. I've been able to cover the costs of these projects by myself, but, at the end of the day, they are not free. Supporting me, even only for a couple dollars, goes a long way in making sure I can continue to create and support these projects.
You left out the noscript part. I’m not implying the project as a whole is minimal effort.
It would be nice to at least see a small explanation of what I as a user am missing out (one or two sentences), or the bare minimum is to at least name the application in the noscript instead of leaving the default text of create-react-app (or similar project generator).
Would it really increase your trust in this site, if the site itself told you it's content?
A malicious actor would just put "Enable JavaScript now or you will miss out on cool prices" or something like this.
"noscript" shouldn't serve any other means but telling you that javascript is disabled.
If this application said “Emoji Kitchen let’s you combine existing emoji to create new hybrid emojis” I could decide if I think that’s silly, probably legit, and it’s worth the ‘risk’. It would also assist the aforementioned crawlers and scrapers.
What app? What am I missing? Why don’t devs put in the minimal amount of effort into their noscript to explain why I should bother allowing scripts on this site?