> At least at this stage of technology’s development, centralized AI models can be more effectively updated and controlled to prevent and respond to abuse compared to open source AI models.
> While centralized models can adapt to abuse and vulnerabilities, open source AI models like LLaMA, once released to the public, will always be available to bad actors who are always willing to engage in high-risk tasks, including fraud, obscene material involving children, privacy intrusions, and other crime.
> Meta’s choice to distribute LLaMA in such an unrestrained and permissive manner raises important and complicated questions about when and how it is appropriate to openly release sophisticated AI models.
Unlike others, Meta released LLaMA for download by approved researchers, rather than centralizing and restricting access to the underlying data…
I don’t know any way to read this other than “you would have been fine by us if you kept it behind an API wall”.
This isn’t my takeaway from the letter [1]. Expressing caution towards one element of a thing doesn’t imply acceptance of or even preference for the other aspects.
[1] https://www.blumenthal.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/06062023meta...