News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by dumpsterdiver on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @05:04AM (#36224556)
Appending a prayer to an abortion doesn't change the practical concerns behind a person's decision to have an abortion (granted, the child was fully out of the womb when they were aborted in this case. I think everyone can agree that out of the womb is too late to abort, but things were different 2500 years ago), and humans if nothing else, have always been pretty dang practical.

It is interesting that civilizations have engaged in ritual sacrifice. The question is why? Were they truly invested heart and soul in the rituals we uncover evidence of today? Or were they more like sporting events? Something to get the crowd riled up. A traumatic event that the community could witness together, potentially creating a bond, and helping them to forget about their other troubles.

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by thworp on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @05:57AM (#36224879)
> It is interesting that civilizations have engaged in ritual sacrifice. The question is why?

A few thoughts:

- Sacrifice and civilization are closely related. To live in a society you have to sacrifice some autonomy, some of your (and your family's) goals and some resources. Further, to prepare for the future you have to make a sacrifice in the present. Many people even sacrifice their present selves for their future (not born yet) offspring. It is only logical (if a bit esoteric) then, to think that making a bigger sacrifice will transmute into bigger positives.

- Christianity (not that familiar with Judaism or Islam) was revolutionary because Jesus already made the ultimate sacrifice, essentially freeing everyone from the obligation.

- If one takes a sober view, the history of ritual sacrifices has not ended (and probably never will). Mao was willing to sacrifice millions to bring about Communism (read: Paradise / heaven on earth). Similarly for the Bolsheviks, Nazis, Red Khmer, Robespierre etc. They all explicitly stated in their own writing that the deaths were a worthwhile sacrifice. That is the psychopathic variant of ritual sacrifice, slaughtering a goat to Zeus looks a lot more tame and rational in comparison, no?

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by dumpsterdiver on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @06:28AM (#36225072)
It leaves a bad taste in my mouth bringing it back around to politics (I wish I lived in a world where I didn't have anything to say about it), but cancel culture has shown that people still love to gather 'round for a good old fashioned sacrifice.
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by aaomidi on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:07AM (#36227745)
We sacrifice millions every year because we

1. Don’t want to change our reliance on cars

2. Don’t want to address hunger and houselessness.

3. We are doing basically nothing about global warming.

A lot of countries COVID strategy was effectively human sacrifice too. This practice never ended.

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by Eumenes on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:24PM (#36229037)
Homeboy just compared human sacrifice to [current social justice talking points]. Most who died of covid were overweight, old, and had preexisting medical conditions related to lifestyle. They contributed to their own "sacrifice".
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by aaomidi on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:27PM (#36229102)
People who wonder how we justified sacrificing humans before. This is how.

We legitimately believed that sacrificing humans was helping prosperity, etc. We’re doing the same now with a few extra steps of indirection and abstraction.

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by Eumenes on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:35PM (#36229260)
Authoritative religious figures stealing baby from a mothers arm and the local shaman sacrificing it on an altar = same as driving a car. Hacker news is a RIOT.
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by aaomidi on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:43PM (#36229410)
Wait until you realize that a lot of human sacrifice in the past had willing victims.

Willing being a bit of a stretch considering the entire society was conditioned to believe it was necessary.

Anyway, I’ll leave you with that and maybe you’ll go do some research on this topic.

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by mchaver on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @01:28PM (#36230066)
I think it still exists in some extreme groups. Just think about any cause worth dying for an you essentially find an argument for a sacrifice.

In fact I remember the Texas governor Dan Patrick saying a lot of grandparents would be willing to sacrifice themselves during Covid for the economy (oddly he did not seem to be willing to lead by example).

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by handsaway on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:26PM (#36229082)
We can safely add plenty of liberal democracies to that list if the criteria is "willing to cause the deaths of millions to realize their political project". At the very least Britain and the US.
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by hef19898 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @06:05AM (#36224929)
Once a child is born, it is by definition not abortion. The rest of your post isn't even worth reading anymore...
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by dumpsterdiver on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @07:16AM (#36225428)
When a parent "sacrifices" a child after it is born, they have indeed aborted that particular mission.

This article is referring to events that happened 2500 years ago. What do you think abortion looked like 2500 years ago? Was it any less barbaric?

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by hef19898 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @08:00AM (#36225721)
Child sacrifices are, by modern standards, babaric. But then again a lot things 2,500 years ago were. Applying modern morality get's you nowhere.

I don't have the slightest idea what is babaric about abortion, if done properly that is.

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by dumpsterdiver on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:13AM (#36226391)
To be clear, I do not object to the concept of abortion. I welcome it, in fact, because I don't generally like other people and I don't expect them to get better. That being said, I still consider the practice to be barbaric. The very same practice that I support, yes. Does that make me a barbarian? I think it actually does. If that is what I am, then I have accepted it.
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by strogonoff on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:39AM (#36227339)
Violence and the Sacred is a book that tries to answer, among some other things, why ritual sacrifices used to happen. I haven’t finished it yet, René Girard could perhaps be a bit meandering, but it’s an insightful read so far.

He observes that sacrifices always targeted a victim that is nearly a human member of society (if not an actual human then an animal which people like and are reasonably close to on a daily basis) but never quite.

Part of his theory appears to be that the sacrifice lets out the impulse that causes members of society to be violent to each other, but focuses this impulse on someone who is outside of that society and who would be unable to push back and seek revenge later, thus defusing it.

In older human societies a transgression could easily lead to an infinite loop of vendetta-like bloodshed, and the mechanism of sacrifice have eventually arisen as a viable steam vent making societies more resilient.

(The justice system of modern civilization achieves a similar purpose, he notes.)

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by Amezarak on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @03:10PM (#36231925)
This doesn’t pass the smell test. Many ancient cultures also ritually sacrificed warriors and nobility.
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by strogonoff on Thursday June 08, 2023 @02:46AM (#36238158)
Any references, or we are supposed to go off your word? René Girard gives plenty in the book.

He also notes that sacrifice of an outcast is a thing, I think I mentioned it already: once a person is stripped of his or her membership in society, that person becomes a perfectly valid sacrificial scapegoat—no matter whether that person used to be a warrior or a noble.

Note also that, while we are talking about ritual sacrifice here, plain simple murder was as much of a thing back then. The two are very different things.

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by Amezarak on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:31AM (#36256871)
Most classical histories include some ethnographic descriptions of foreign rituals. Check out Herodotus, Thucydides, Livy, etc.

For a modern and extensive compilation, Frazer famously wrote a huge multi-volume work that documents sacrificial myths from all over the world in The Golden Bough. He selects and uses them to make his own argument, but you’re not likely to find a more comprehensive compilation.

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by Tagbert on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:25AM (#36228032)
I’m not sure why you are bringing abortion into this. The Carthaginian’s would not consider what they were doing abortion and most modern people would also not consider this related to abortion. Is there some correlation that you wanted to make?
Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by TehShrike on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @01:19PM (#36229937)
They are both the murder of your own child.

One day, abortion of an unborn child will be widely considered as shocking as child sacrifice is today.

Re:Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children by Eumenes on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:15PM (#36228868)
Perhaps they knew something we didn't know. I'm convinced human sacrifice is more than just, lets appease this deity or usher in a form of eugenics/genocide. These people were far more advanced then we give them credit for.