News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by chrisco255 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @10:59PM (#36222336)
The title of an HN submission does not have to match the article's title. It's also not editorializing. It's a factual statement, except it should probably be revised to 661 Gt instead of the 600 Gt quoted (doesn't change substance).
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by Jtsummers on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:41PM (#36222561)
* * *
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by yongjik on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:37PM (#36222538)
In addition to others' comments, I see no reason why "vs. a prediction of a 20k Gt loss" should be a good summary, when (I assume) the number was lifted from:

> whereas the steady-state approach would estimate ice loss of −20 028.1 Gt over the same period

I'm not a climatologist, but for all I know this could mean something like "If we draw a straight line between point A and B it will intersect a point that is 20,000 Gt below the observed value, which is clearly silly, and that's why we should not do that." I see no claim about which research group actually made a prediction of 20k Gt loss, but obviously I didn't read the whole article, so I'll wait for the OP to chime in and explain where in the paper it cites a previous work that made such a prediction.

I'm not holding my breath, though.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by aerojoe23 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:15PM (#36222431)
The ice shelves, not all of Antarctica, gained ice. I guess you could read the HN title and think, "see Antarctica must not be getting warmer if it gained ice." Where the shelves could have gained from the glaciers flowing faster off the land, and amount of ice could still have gone down.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by postalrat on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:31PM (#36222512)
Well did Antarctica gain ice or are you simply speculating?
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by defrost on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:39PM (#36222554)
Overall Antarctica in total has steadily lost ice mass since 1990.

See: Figure 8 (Shepherd et al. 2018) reproduced in link below

https://www.antarcticglaciers.org/glaciers-and-climate/what-...

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by chrisco255 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @01:27PM (#36230060)
Overall Antarctica in total has steadily gained ice mass since 4200 BC. Sea levels are currently 9 meters below what they were at that time.

See: Figure 6 (Zwartz et al. 1998) reproduced in link below: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/222450369_Holocene_...

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by defrost on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @04:56PM (#36233431)
Did you read your linked paper?

Figure 6. does not show total Antartica ice mass change, it shows a local area change in relative sea level markers.

Today the relative sea level markers are much lower as the land itself is riding higher overall due to glacial rebound, the lifting of the land as a great weight is removed.

Your paper (as discussed in the conclusion) argues that during the past 6,000 years a great deal of ice has been lost, having retreated some 30km and thinned by some 800m in thickness.

Did you make a typo, or did you misunderstand your own linked source material?

Either way, thank you for the paper.