My guess was the only thing that I could really think of. That and the syntax support and integration of non-list datatypes into the core language (e.g. function syntax).
Clojure has "sequences" or "seqs", which are semantically the closest to what lispers mean by a "list"—but also "vectors," denoted by square brackets, "maps," denoted by curly brackets, and "sets", denoted by curly brackets prefixed with a hash sign. Having these as core data structures violates the Lisp principle of "everything is just a list," and they introduce something other than round parens into the syntax, which looks really weird to those practiced with traditional/conventional Lisps.
For those well-practiced in "true" Lisps, Clojure reads like a very strange hybrid (one might say "corruption") of Lisp and JSON.
The precise/pedantic lisper may insist that since Lisp stands for List Processing and Lists are chains of cons cells and since Clojure doesn't have cons cells for the built-in lists, then Clojure is not a Lisp.
If, however, you view lisp (lower case) as a family of homo-iconic languages that use s-expressions, then Clojure happily fits under that umbrella.
The trick is to pay close attention to whether the person is talking about a Lisp (ANSI Common Lisp implementation) or a lisp (the family). Sometimes people say "lisp" when they are talking about "Lisp", which can cause some confusion.
=> (class (read-string "(some list)"))
clojure.lang.PersistentList
They are written in Java, and implement a bunch of interfaces, so the implementation looks complicated, but they are basically just classes with _first and _rest fields.https://github.com/clojure/clojure/blob/master/src/jvm/cloju...
The main point is that Lisp actually has decades old established set of data structures, their operators and programming concepts. For example when I would have read a Lisp book, I would find explanations of these core datastructures and operators. In a Clojure book many things work sufficiently differently and also are named differently. In Lisp for example "atom" is a central concept. It's anything which is not a linked list element. In Clojure this word is used to name a completely different concept: a data structure to manage state.
Clojure is more like Lisp, Java, SML put into a blender. The result may have a similar color, some traces of flavor, but other then that it is a new language.