News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by Joakal on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @09:12PM (#3619057)
So how is he going to pay online-only bills? Are the courts going to give him taxpayer money for late fees? Or it's his own fault for not predicting his arrest?

Can he read about politics as part of his duty as a voter? Due to Internet as a medium for accessing news, he's further restricted on being an informed voter.

How is he meant to send material to his lawyers? "Mail it" So instead of sending it virtually for free, he has to print it out, determine postage, go find a postal office and then ship it. Vice versa to receive it but it takes time. Not to mention the massive phone bill because VOIP is INTERNET.

How is he going to be monitored from accessing Internet that's everywhere? Anti-Satellite jammers? Anti-Wifi jammers?

How is it possible to prevent him from giving the password to someone to start a megaupload website? Better prevent phones, mail, etc, in that case.

Since I know he's technically proficient, he's probably using the Internet as we speak. So this order only serves to pad the ego of the prosecution team, show incompetence of judge and punish honest people for being honest.

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by tzs on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @09:35PM (#3619126)
How did he pay his bills, etc., when he was in jail?

I think you might be overlooking that he's merely out on bail. That means he is still charged with the crimes he was arrested for. The court has decided that he is not a flight risk and so they are going to let him stay out until his trial rather than housing him in jail, but it is quite common for courts to place restrictions on the person as a condition of offering them bail.

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by Joakal on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @09:44PM (#3619154)
Internet access is a fundamental right since it's quickly becoming a necessity. It is also quite common for the courts to disregard asinine restrictions. If he used electricity to infringe on copyright, are they going to turn off his electricity too? Or is the Internet too young?

Did we forget that Library Internet access issue thread already? There are crucial needs being served by the Internet just like water, electricity, security, etc.

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by SquareWheel on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @09:40PM (#3619139)

  "So how is he going to pay online-only bills?"

  "Can he read about politics as part of his duty as a voter?"
Paying bills online and reading about politics are not human rights either. There are alternatives available for any task he's expected to do as a member of society.

  "Since I know he's technically proficient, he's probably using the Internet as we speak."
That's a really bad argument, and I think you know it. He very well may be online as we speak, his neighbors probably have an unsecured network, but why is that a good reason to intentionally give the man internet access? He's shown time and time again that he uses the internet to commit criminal acts, there is no reason for him to have that access.

This is not a human rights violation.

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by Joakal on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @09:50PM (#3619169)
> Paying bills online and reading about politics are not human rights either. There are alternatives available for any task he's expected to do as a member of society.

I'm sorry, but Internet access is the human right. You're putting human right implications in my mouth.

The alternatives available? Jeez, I wonder how he can find out as an Internet user. Hopefully he had heard about yellow pages? Yes, there actually young people who do NOT understand non-Internet alternatives.

> He's shown time and time again that he uses the internet to commit criminal acts, there is no reason for him to have that access.

He used electricity too. So, cut off his electricity too? Remember, he needs electricity to run servers and not necessarily the Internet. Seize all electronics instead? He may have files embedded in the house alarm. Personally, I didn't want to respond because your rationale is asinine!

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by SquareWheel on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @10:06PM (#3619219)
You could take that argument as far as you'd like. He used oxygen to help him commit the crimes, thus we should take away his oxygen.

No, the internet has directly helped him commit crimes. It is a tool he used. As it is non-essential, and we may disagree on that point but the courts are agreeing with me, then it is logical to remove his privilege.

I don't believe my rationale is asinine at all. I think you're equating this man's freedom with the protection of the internet itself, and are overstepping your position because of it.

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by Joakal on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @10:17PM (#3619268)
The prosecution took it that far and the judge does not understand the implications of Internet as a necessity. I even highlighted that it restricts many needs to function as a member of society. The reality is that there are electronics that can easily tap into the World Wide Internet, which gives credence to my argument that his electricity should be shut off along with all electronics (may be battery powered) as part of the effort to prevent access to the Internet.

The Internet did not help him commit crimes, it's a neutral platform. They are merely carriers just like roads, servers, etc.

> I think you're equating this man's freedom with the protection of the internet itself, and are overstepping your position because of it.

Nope, I'm talking specifically about the human right to the Internet due to the necessities, abundance of electronics with access to Internet, many potential outlets and most of all; unenforceable to prevent access. I think you're overstepping your position again by implicating me with other positions when I've been quite clear.

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by SquareWheel on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @10:30PM (#3619312)
I don't think you have been that clear, but I don't want to see this discussion turn personal. I have nothing against you, and your opinion is just as valid as my own.

On the question of if the internet is a human right, I think it's quite obvious the answer is no. It has never been viewed as one in the past as far as I know, I've yet to see a judge rule that to be the case.

A better question is, should it be? I'd like to see that happen, though I think it will take time to get there.

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by Joakal on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @10:45PM (#3619344)
I apologise. I was explaining that I did not like being misrepresented by others. I would have been less defensive to a request to clarify my posts.

As for it being a human right from precedent, it's already recognised in some European countries (some of it even includes minimal Internet transfer rates) and discussed at UN. Unfortunately for UN, I believe certain influences do not want it to happen, eg USA based on ACTA's proposal that had included demands for three strikes among other Internet access restrictions.

There's a lot of information from this article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_access and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_Internet_access

No hard feelings, mate!

Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by SquareWheel on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @11:02PM (#3619385)
No hard feelings here either. Have a good day, dear sir.
Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by felixfurtak on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @12:13AM (#3619562)
Ok, how about this one. Suppose his entire music collection was stored online in something like Google Music. And that all his books were eBooks, stored on Amazon. Lets assume he had his Kindle siezed. Is it right to deny him books and music?
Re:Megaupload Founder Kim Dotcom Released From Prison by SquareWheel on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @12:18AM (#3619573)
It's a shame, but it's still not a human right. I'm not arguing that it wouldn't be a significant inconvenience, it absolutely would.

When it comes to cloud-based media though, realize that you don't own the content. You could have your account banned or content removed at any time, as decided by the courts or the company you're relying on.