Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by ChumpGPT on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:41PM
(#36190610)
Yeah, as an American who pays a shit ton of taxes, I don't mind what weapons they use. As a matter of fact I would like to see my Gov supply them with whatever they need.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by moose_man on Sunday June 04, 2023 @09:13PM
(#36191154)
If we're concerned about Nazis I'd be more concerned about the Russian forces since they are executing civilians and throwing them in mass graves. That's more Nazilike than a Swastika.
You know why the Russian private army is called Wagner right?
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by lisasays on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:23PM
(#36190504)
Not mentioned in the WP article is the fun fact that one of the major participating units (the Russia Volunteer Corps) is led by the Russo-German neo-Nazi Daniel Kapustin/Nikitin, aka White Rex:
Know for, among other things, the martial arts events festival (whose political bent one can guess from the name) he helped organized, as late as 2018:
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by moose_man on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:29PM
(#36190535)
And your point is? When there are death squads and mass graves being deployed in your country by a top 10 global military power you use the resources you can get. If Russia invaded my country and was executing civilians and burying them in mass graves you bet I would also be working with anyone I could to stop them.
Churchill - If Hitler invaded hell I would make at least a favourable reference to the devil in the House of Commons.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by lisasays on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:40PM
(#36190605)
And your point is?
To the extent that there is any - it's that it's awfully negligent (on the part of Brussels), and stupid (of Kyiv) to be handing the enemy such a picture-perfect propaganda play. In fact, just about the shrillest of optics and meme fodder that Putin's sycophants could ever wish for, in their wettest and wildest of dreams:
"Actual Nazis, with NATO weapons, crossing into the Motherland!"
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by moose_man on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:42PM
(#36190622)
I mean sure, the situation isn't ideal, but being invaded by Russia isn't either. Besides, who knows if it is worth trade off? Maybe it will force Russia to deploy more forces to guard their borders and leave open opportunities for the counter offensive that wouldn't otherwise happen. We can't say yet whether it is a stupid move until it plays out.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by lisasays on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:47PM
(#36190655)
I mean sure, the situation isn't ideal, but so is being invaded by Russia.
The thing is, this exactly the logic that moved so many people in so many European countries (including, very close to the front of the pack, Ukraine itself) to seek either full or partial alliance with the German occupiers in the first place, back during that other conflict (which supposedly never really ended, according to what Putin is desperately trying to tell the world).
That, and again, the shitty optics and (unfortunately quite) tangible propaganda benefit for the other side.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by moose_man on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:50PM
(#36190674)
A handful of Russian right wingers larping as Nazis is not equivalent to the threat of Nazi Germany. Besides, the Russian occupation forces are doing a far more realistic and faithful impression of the SD / Waffen SS themselves with all the mass graves, torture and forced disappearances. They even have the deportation thing down as well.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by lisasays on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:56PM
(#36190710)
A handful of Russian right wingers larping as Nazis is not equivalent to the threat of Nazi Germany.
Look, it's objectively stupid and inflammatory, in any conflict, to not just send people over the border to do whatever business you want them to do -- but to send people with either (1) highly questionable ties (2) doing stupid provocative shit, and (3) at the same time when you're attempting to claim plausible deniability - using the wrong weapons.
Examples abound in recent and less-recent history. And it doesn't matter how small they are in terms of headcount. The bottom line is that it (at best) works against your stated goals, and at worst - can counteract these goals entirely.
Besides, the Russian occupation forces are doing a far more realistic and faithful impression of the SD / Waffen SS themselves with all the mass graves, torture and forced disappearances.
Damn right they are. But rather then do something to stop that - these tactics simply enable them to brainwash their own public further, and convince them of the "regrettable necessity" of the special operation which they ... keep insisting they were forced to undertake.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by dekhn on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:22PM
(#36190860)
I wouldn't say it's objectively stupid or inflammatory- rather it seems like a calculated risk.
A lot of things shifted in the last year and it's clear now that Ukraine is using a wide range of options available to it- walking out progressively more aggressive responses, basically to test the russians and make the russian soldiers and leadership less confident in their approach. I imagine that they carefully watch the world's response to their actions, and adjust as necessary.
Those responses include tacitly supporting guerillas. Will the upcoming counteroffensive lead to Ukrainian troops entering the traditionally borders of Russia (not just occupied lands)? It seems unlikely. Will we continue to see guerilla action on the borders and possibly closer to home (Moscow)? It seems very likely.
Also, if the ukranians send nazi russians to russia to kill russians to stop the war, and the nazis get killed, that's a win for everybody, right?
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by lisasays on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:33PM
(#36190926)
So, if the ukranians send nazi russians to russia to kill russians to stop the war, and the nazis get killed, that's a win for everybody, right?
Aside from the fact that they most likely won't (get killed) -- no, it's still not a win, or is it ever a win - to knowingly collaborate with committed Nazis for any tactical end, at any time.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by moose_man on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:58PM
(#36190724)
I get your concern, maybe it will end up being a bad move, who knows. Sometimes people screw up. But frankly this worries me a lot more than whatever methods the Ukrainians use for shaping attacks in advance of their offensive: https://meduza.io/en/news/2023/06/04/two-year-old-girl-kille...
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by lisasays on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:18PM
(#36190838)
Purposely, no. I honestly didn't understand what was meant to be implied by the article - and in fact there are lots of trolls (or troll-equivalent) accounts posting all kind of crazy, button-push stuff. Like civilian bombing / massacre victims being human shields or false-flag attacks by the Ukrainians themselves, for example.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by lisasays on Monday June 05, 2023 @01:29AM
(#36192707)
Agreed. Part of the strategy for obtaining that goal is to stop giving them free propaganda points, in my view. Being as propaganda is one of the primary capital streams (besides oil revenues) that the regime unequivocally responsible for this whole calamity seems to run on.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by gdy on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:44PM
(#36218125)
"Whats your point"
My point is that Nazis in the Ukraine isn't a new thing and you can't justify their position in the Ukrainian society by the ongoing war. They freely marched with torches on the streets of Kiev before anything happened.
"theres similar marches in Russia too"
Not really, Russian ultra-nationalists are suppressed under Putin, some of their leaders are in jail and their organizations are designated as extremist. There were so called Russian Marches, but no more.
"does that make all of them Nazis"
Yeah, people marching on the streets with torches and shouting nationalistic and supremacist slogans are nazis, be it in Russia or Ukraine. Doubly so if they carry the portraits of Nazi collaborators and perpetrators of genocide. Slogans 'Ukraine above all' don't help either.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by _kbh_ on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @08:10AM
(#36225797)
> Not really, Russian ultra-nationalists are suppressed under Putin, some of their leaders are in jail and their organizations are designated as extremist. There were so called Russian Marches, but no more.
My brother in christ, the head of the main PMC in Russia has Nazi symbols tattooed on him and named his PMC after Hitlers favourite composer.
Nazis aren't suppressed under Putin, they are actively hired by the government.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by gdy on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:17AM
(#36226417)
You won't find torch marches in Russia though.
Wagner may be run by a nazi, but then it's a closeted nazi who doesn't advertise his views and doesn't shout 'Russia above all' and other kinds of stuff that torch bearing Ukrainian nazis love.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by _kbh_ on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:08AM
(#36239489)
> Wagner may be run by a nazi, but then it's a closeted nazi who doesn't advertise his views
You know the reason we know of this is because we have a photo of his tattoos right?. A person tatted up with Nazis symbols isn’t exactly a ‘closeted’ Nazi.
Re:Use of NATO arms for attack in Russia raises doubts about...
by gdy on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @05:21AM
(#36307643)
Oops, I didn't google Utkin specifically.
But back to my point, you can see his tattoos only because someone dug out a photo of him and shared it on the internet. Not because he was marching bare-chested on the streets of Moscow on Hitler's birthday carrying a torch and shouting 'Glory to Russia!'. Even if he wanted to, he wouldn't do that because that would not be accepted by Russian society or by Kremlin.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/05/23/belgorod-att...
he is a neo nazi!!!
You know why the Russian private army is called Wagner right?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denis_Kapustin_(militant)
Know for, among other things, the martial arts events festival (whose political bent one can guess from the name) he helped organized, as late as 2018:
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kampf_der_Nibelungen
Churchill - If Hitler invaded hell I would make at least a favourable reference to the devil in the House of Commons.
To the extent that there is any - it's that it's awfully negligent (on the part of Brussels), and stupid (of Kyiv) to be handing the enemy such a picture-perfect propaganda play. In fact, just about the shrillest of optics and meme fodder that Putin's sycophants could ever wish for, in their wettest and wildest of dreams:
What's your point?The thing is, this exactly the logic that moved so many people in so many European countries (including, very close to the front of the pack, Ukraine itself) to seek either full or partial alliance with the German occupiers in the first place, back during that other conflict (which supposedly never really ended, according to what Putin is desperately trying to tell the world).
That, and again, the shitty optics and (unfortunately quite) tangible propaganda benefit for the other side.
Look, it's objectively stupid and inflammatory, in any conflict, to not just send people over the border to do whatever business you want them to do -- but to send people with either (1) highly questionable ties (2) doing stupid provocative shit, and (3) at the same time when you're attempting to claim plausible deniability - using the wrong weapons.
Examples abound in recent and less-recent history. And it doesn't matter how small they are in terms of headcount. The bottom line is that it (at best) works against your stated goals, and at worst - can counteract these goals entirely.
Besides, the Russian occupation forces are doing a far more realistic and faithful impression of the SD / Waffen SS themselves with all the mass graves, torture and forced disappearances.
Damn right they are. But rather then do something to stop that - these tactics simply enable them to brainwash their own public further, and convince them of the "regrettable necessity" of the special operation which they ... keep insisting they were forced to undertake.
A lot of things shifted in the last year and it's clear now that Ukraine is using a wide range of options available to it- walking out progressively more aggressive responses, basically to test the russians and make the russian soldiers and leadership less confident in their approach. I imagine that they carefully watch the world's response to their actions, and adjust as necessary.
Those responses include tacitly supporting guerillas. Will the upcoming counteroffensive lead to Ukrainian troops entering the traditionally borders of Russia (not just occupied lands)? It seems unlikely. Will we continue to see guerilla action on the borders and possibly closer to home (Moscow)? It seems very likely.
Also, if the ukranians send nazi russians to russia to kill russians to stop the war, and the nazis get killed, that's a win for everybody, right?
Aside from the fact that they most likely won't (get killed) -- no, it's still not a win, or is it ever a win - to knowingly collaborate with committed Nazis for any tactical end, at any time.
Trite as it may sound to some here.
I gotcha.
I suggest you watch this BBC report[0] on torch march in Kiev on Jan 2 2014 when Crimea was still Ukrainian.
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHhGEiwCHZE
You don't have to like people for them to be useful too you.
Like how Russias main PMC is run by a Nazi, but it doesn't make all Russians Nazi's does it?.
My point is that Nazis in the Ukraine isn't a new thing and you can't justify their position in the Ukrainian society by the ongoing war. They freely marched with torches on the streets of Kiev before anything happened.
"theres similar marches in Russia too"
Not really, Russian ultra-nationalists are suppressed under Putin, some of their leaders are in jail and their organizations are designated as extremist. There were so called Russian Marches, but no more.
"does that make all of them Nazis"
Yeah, people marching on the streets with torches and shouting nationalistic and supremacist slogans are nazis, be it in Russia or Ukraine. Doubly so if they carry the portraits of Nazi collaborators and perpetrators of genocide. Slogans 'Ukraine above all' don't help either.
My brother in christ, the head of the main PMC in Russia has Nazi symbols tattooed on him and named his PMC after Hitlers favourite composer.
Nazis aren't suppressed under Putin, they are actively hired by the government.
Wagner may be run by a nazi, but then it's a closeted nazi who doesn't advertise his views and doesn't shout 'Russia above all' and other kinds of stuff that torch bearing Ukrainian nazis love.
You know the reason we know of this is because we have a photo of his tattoos right?. A person tatted up with Nazis symbols isn’t exactly a ‘closeted’ Nazi.
https://twitter.com/JJansaSDS/status/1498596035664429056
But back to my point, you can see his tattoos only because someone dug out a photo of him and shared it on the internet. Not because he was marching bare-chested on the streets of Moscow on Hitler's birthday carrying a torch and shouting 'Glory to Russia!'. Even if he wanted to, he wouldn't do that because that would not be accepted by Russian society or by Kremlin.
That's the difference with the Ukraine.