But what is AI? If it's just "artificial intelligence", it effectively includes all programming with if/then logic gates based on program input.
And? You think that is the totality of a physical safety critical system?
I can see how it appears to intelligent, but it lacks reasoning, creativity, and critical thinking.
It requires creativity to recognize the rules of the game as “try to be the first to reach the ball”, to recognize that the thrower may not have time to carefully aim, and that the others might chase the ball regardless of its location. Only if all three of those creative leaps are made, then logical deduction can take over to conclude “if the ball goes in front of me, stop before a kid does the same”.
And that’s not even getting into cases where you conditionally act like there’s a stop sign. The city of Houghton,MI has major streets along the side of a hill, and minor streets going up and down the hill. Every winter, sand is put down for traction, and every spring it is cleaned away. If there’s a late-season snowstorm after the spring cleaning, cars going downhill on the minor streets physically cannot stop, so everybody on the major streets looks uphill before crossing.
Short of location-dependent fine-tuned models, I’m not sure how machine learning could replicate the logic of “if snowy in late spring, grant right-of-way to cars headed downhill”.
- A failure by Tesla to view the system that they are developing as what it really is - a physical safety-critical system and not "an AI". Those two are distinct systems as, with a physical safety-critical systems, the totality of the systems safety components cannot be fully expressed in software - neither initially nor continuously.
- To build on that point, Tesla is not allowing the Operational Design Domain (ODD) via a robust, well-maintained validation process determine the vehicle hardware as the ODD demands it to be. Instead, Tesla is trying to "front run" it (ignore the demands of the ODD) by largely focusing on hardware costs. The tension from failing to recognize that is why Tesla, in part, has a long history of being forced to (somewhat clandestinely) change the relevant sensor and compute hardware on their vehicles while promising to "solve FSD" (whatever that means) by the end of every year since around 2015 or so.