“The black culture has done more damage [than] the klan ever did” “The Jewish Mafia wants to replace us all with brown people” “Trannies are pedophiles” “Diversity is a codeword for White Genocide” “Hitler was right”, accompanied by a montage of the former dictator Black people belong “locked in cages at the zoo” LGBTQ+ rights activists need “IRON IN THEIR DIET. Preferably from a #AFiringSquad”
Using an ethnic description for a mafia doesn't equate to characterizing an entire ethnicity a certain way. Terms like Italian mafia and Russian mafia are commonly used.
Both of these are objectionable, but don't cross the line in terms of what is so objectionable that it shouldn't even be allowed to be uttered on the world's public square. An open discourse allows a wide range of opinions, some of which many find highly offensive. If you don't like it, you can block the person, or criticize them. You don't have a right to block other people from reading their content.
“Trannies are pedophiles” is hate, yes.
“Diversity is a codeword for White Genocide” is not hate. It's just something a racist would very likely say.
Of course, "Hitler was right", is hate, as is the "IRON IN THEIR DIET" tweet.
People understand the basic conceits of public politeness, so racists know they have to put in the smallest amount of work to let other people cover for them. These have not even really met that bar... But it's worth considering how much of this you would accept from say... known klan members?
Like, I get that if hate groups say it, it's not inherently hate speech, but at what point do you want to be defending hate groups? I don't feel like I need to get real in the weeds about how what the limit of shit I will put up with from KKK members is... And I think it's disingenuous to suggest we should really get deep in the weeds to iron out exactly how they can walk around the rules. We know who the rulebreakers are, and pretending like we don't until they say something truly egregious is like pretending leopards aren't gonna eat our faces.
Twitter considered using a gender pronoun that corresponds with a person's biological sex to be hate, in the case where the person who that pronoun was being applied to wanted to be referred to by a different gender pronoun. People were banned if they refused to comply with this left-wing convention of language. Such an opinionated/ideologically-subjective interpretation of hate being used to censor people is totally inappropriate in my opinion, and I never want to see Twitter descend to that again.
The "no dog whistles allowed" standard affords for space significant subjectivity in determinations of content being "hate", which in turn allows political factions to institute censorship to prevent views that are not hateful from being expressed.
Not arguing that. But I do think it had a better set of standards for this before it came down to the subjective whims of how Musk was feeling on any given day.
Also, no one has ever considered misgendering hate speech in any legitimate conversation. If you have examples of people legitimately getting censored for misgendering someone, I would love to see it...
From my perspective, they're demanding that I misgender them, while I insist on accurately gendering them. From my vantage point, it would be no different than a black person demanding that I refer to them as racially white.
"Also, no one has ever considered misgendering hate speech in any legitimate conversation. If you have examples of people legitimately getting censored for misgendering someone, I would love to see it..."
Numerous people were banned on my own timeline for using the "wrong" gender pronoun.
This individual was banned for two tweets stating:
"How are transwomen not men? What is the difference between a man and a transwoman?"
and
"Men aren’t women."
https://www.wsj.com/articles/writer-sues-twitter-over-ban-fo...
I don't want Twitter to ever come back under the type of ideologues who instituted that policy. Those are the ideologues behind the incessant attacks on Musk. It's shocking how intent they are on instituting censorship.